The Malta Independent 20 November 2026, Friday
View E-Paper

Interview: The Other factors

Malta Independent Monday, 25 September 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 21 years ago

The tourism industry has struggled over the past few years. New destinations that are able to lower prices because they have the volume and a wider choice have negatively affected operators in Malta. But there are other factors that play an important part in the final equation, as PHILIP FENECH, President of the Hospitality and Entertainment section of the Chamber of Small and Medium sized Enterprise – GRTU, told Bernard Busuttil last week

How has tourism changed in the past years?

The tourism model abroad has changed a great deal and a lack of foresight on the part of the stakeholders made it difficult to adapt. The advent of low cost airlines pulled the carpet from underneath many tour operators and legacy airlines. While legacy airlines charge higher prices, the tour operator model is becoming old-fashioned.

Today, anybody browsing the internet has access to cheap or discounted flights. This phenomenon has given rise to emotive tourism.

What is emotive tourism?

It is the simply the opportunity to take a holiday, a weekend break on the spur of the moment. Low cost carries introduced this new concept by not only lowering prices but moving away from the concept of “tourism seasons”.

This change created a new level of growth for the tourism sector.

What relevance do low cost carriers have to the industry?

I had been lobbying for low cost airlines for the past 18 months. They are finally here, albeit 18 months late, but at least, they are now operating. I believe that the government must do its utmost to prevent hotels from closing down due to lack of business. A brief halt in hotel activity implies an immediate stop to other business activities, especially those in the sector that I, as a GRTU section president, represent, retailing in entertainment and providers of ancillary services and their suppliers. The less people working in tourism earn, the less they can invest or redirect into the economy.

What about running costs?

Industry operators are having to charge higher prices because they are facing ever increasing operational costs, imported inflation and the impact of the increase in fuel prices, apart from other government induced costs. Some establishments have seen an almost 10 per cent increase in their expenses because of the fuel price increases. We are seeing medium sized businesses paying up to Lm15,000 in electricity bills while large operators can pay up to Lm50,000 in energy costs.

How is the market reacting to these price structures?

The industry is starting to understand how it must change to adapt to the new market structure. Air Malta and British Airways subsidiaries reduced their prices as a result of the introduction of low cost carriers. This means that when they are facing competition, they are ready to compete as well to stay in the market. And the market is responding to the new price structures.

The privatisation of the Malta International Airport (MIA) has not left a positive mark on the tourism industry. As the sole airport, it charges high landing fees and its only aim is to increase profits.

I believe that this prompted the government to introduce a market support scheme for low cost carriers in order to lure them to operate here. It would have been more worthwhile, had the government retained ownership of the airport and ran it on a breakeven basis. Hence, airport charges would have been lower and this would have given further impetus to legacy airlines, tour operators and low cost carriers to charge lower prices.

Do you expect results to improve in the short term?

Low cost carriers give immediate results. Meridiana, which began operating last April, substantially increased arrivals from the Italian market within a short period of time. Since Ryanair began advertising Malta on its website on 12 September, it has received 8,000 bookings. The arrival of low cost carrier German Wings in March is also expected to be of benefit to the tourism industry. These carriers will improve accessibility and, in turn, benefit those in the real estate and letting industry, businessmen and the cruise liner business.

Do low cost carriers provide other openings?

The government should take up any opportunities that these airlines present it with… for example, Ryanair’s proposal to use Malta as a base and the volume discount scheme, which is related to performance.

Ryanair are proposing that compensation for MIA’s high landing charges should not be the same for all low cost carriers, but distributed on the basis that a carrier brings over a preset number of passengers. This would create a greater sense of competition between carriers. With a target of 200,000 passengers, Air Malta, which already carries 1.5m passengers, would gain from the scheme.

Do legacy airlines still have a future here?

The increased demand generated by low cost carriers can be taken up by legacy airlines which fly to major airports and offer scheduled flights. As a result, tour operators will be enticed to stay in Malta and not relocate to higher volume destinations. A meeting was recently organised between GRTU and the Finance Ministry during which we explained this model to the government, so that it could take it into consideration in next year’s budget.

What about the tourism infrastructure?

Some would argue that we have too many tourism structures, the end results of the industry’s attempts to absorb more and more tourists. To have a sustainable industry, we need to attract an additional 500,000 tourists.

What does the industry need to get back on track?

We need an immediate financial boost to prevent more hotels from closing down. We don’t need a boom and bust strategy, but a short-term fix with a long-term strategy.

Are you expecting any new measures in the next budget?

I expect a revision of the airport tax and more incentives to boost growth in the tourism sector. We joined the EU to enjoy freedom of movement and integration with other EU countries, but how can you move around if you are shackled? Therefore, the government must remove these few remaining barriers.

What else can the government do?

The government needs to try harder to attract operators, in the broad sense, that may have doubts about operating to Malta. EasyJet, for example, have not been as eager to come here as Ryanair are.

We have to learn that the tourism model is changing and we cannot dictate to the world what we want. We need to work hard to maintain the level of tourists that come to Malta and reverse the trends seen over the past five years.

What are local businessmen doing in this respect?

Local businessmen are performing miracles on a daily basis and they continue to invest millions of liri in the hope that the economy will pick up in a strong manner. The local product has never been as good as it is today, however we need a more coordinated set-up, especially where government entities are concerned. A lot of meetings have been held to discuss the traffic arrangements when Manwel Dimech Bridge will be rebuilt but I don’t think the same level of coordination existed when Civil Aviation Avenue was closed.

How can we attract more tourists?

We need to extend the tourism product to the small towns and villages. Granted that many tourists come to Malta for the sun, sea and the nightlife, there are others who want to see a lot more of the island. We should try and retain as many local characteristics as possible. For example, in Spinola, it would be great to have local fishermen selling fresh fish to the restaurants while the tourists are dining there. This would boost the quality of the product on offer and enhance the local character of the area.

Can the industry guarantee such diversity?

We have to achieve a varied yet balanced model of activity that reflects the economic, physical and social structure of Malta. However, unfortunately, the conclusions reached by, for example, the Church’s environment commission in their analysis of the Malta Tourism Authority’s draft strategic plan, do not help the industry.

A very detailed study is under way to analyse how we can strike this balance. Therefore, frivolous comments that may encourage a negative debate are certainly not welcome at this stage.

  • don't miss