The trial by the bench of two adult brothers charged with raping and sexually abusing two boys, who are also brothers, came to an end yesterday, with Mr Justice Joseph Galea Debono deferring the case for judgement, expected on 26 October.
The trial of Dennis Pandolfino, 58, from Sliema and his 63-year-old brother Anthony, from Pembroke, began on Tuesday. The men pleaded not guilty to raping, defiling and sexually abusing the two brothers who at the time were 10 and 11 years old. They are now 14 and 15 years old.
The men were also charged with holding the boys against their will and being in possession of pornographic material. The prosecution claimed the men raped and sexually abused the two underage brothers when their mother entrusted them to their care.
After the prosecution rested its case on Thursday and the defence lawyers and the prosecution had made their final submissions, Mr Justice Galea Debono yesterday heard a number of witnesses summoned by the defence.
Psychiatrist Peter Muscat said that in 2002 Dennis Pandolfino had consulted him because he felt anxious and was not managing to concentrate at work.
He said Dennis Pandolfino told him that he was anxious because a Tunisian man was taking two boys he took care of, and their mother, to Tunisia in order to force her into prostitution. He told the psychiatrist that he was worried about the children and as a result was suffering anxiety attacks.
Replying to a question from Senior Counsel to the Republic Anthony Barbara, who prosecuted, Dr Muscat said that Dennis Pandolfino never spoke to him about feeling attracted to the boys or to young children.
The defence also summoned two teachers who taught the older of the two brothers who lived with Anthony Pandolfino for a number of years.
They said they saw nothing abnormal in his behaviour at school and said they never noticed that he was allegedly being subjected to abuse. They said he was well-behaved and obeyed them at school.
At the end of yesterday’s sitting, Mr Justice Galea Debono deferred the case to 26 October. He explained that there are many legal issues which have to be looked into before a judgement can be drawn up and that while jurors in a trial by jury had to simply declare an accused guilty or not guilty, without giving their reasons as to why they reached that conclusion, a judge presiding over a trial by the bench had to give reasons for every decision he took.
Senior Counsel to the Republic Anthony Barbara prosecuted. Dr Joseph Mifsud represented Dennis Pandolfino while Dr Joseph Giglio appeared for Anthony Pandolfino.