Poor intra-departmental communications, consultants being appointed with little or no accountability and resistance from the private sector were singled out as being some of the hurdles faced by Malta as its strives to bring the European Union’s ethos of producer responsibility to Maltese shores.
Of the four main EU regulations on producer responsibility – respectively dealing with packaging, batteries, end of life vehicles and waste from electrical and electronic equipment – three have been transposed into law but none of the four have been properly implemented in practical terms, German waste expert Helmut Schnurer told The Malta Independent on Sunday this week.
“Malta has transposed three of the four producer responsibility regulations but, in practical terms, has implemented none of them,” Dr Schnurer, who is in Malta as part of a twinning project signed between Malta and Germany, through which Germany is providing expertise on implementing EU producer responsibility requirements.
He cites the fact that there is still no licensed facility for end of life vehicles, apart from a few “old scrapyards” that are engaged in basic activities, but which are not in accordance with the EU directive.
Batteries are being collected and managed through WasteServ, which, although positive, is still not being done by the producer, or in Malta’s case, the importer.
“The difference is that when WasteServ is doing it you are paying for it with your taxes and this is not right. The cost should be carried by the producers or importers of batteries, which should be made responsible.”
Packaging waste regulations are not being implemented either and although there is a voluntary GreenPack scheme in Malta, fees for signing on have proved a disincentive for the private sector. Dr Schnurer proposes raising the eco-contribution to rates higher than those paid by GreenPack members, who are exempt from the eco-contribution, which would provide the private sector with a financial incentive to participate.
Waste from electrical and electronic equipment is being stored but it is piling up, although a detailed compilation of the costs involved in its export to another European country for recycling is being drawn up.
But as Malta grapples with finding ways to implement the regulations, Dr Schnurer’s experience is that poor communication between Malta’s various authorities and a tendency to appoint foreign consultants to carry out work in the area for Malta is hampering the process.
“While we have seen some very good and interesting results,” Dr Schnurer explains, “one problem is that foreign consultants are being engaged for many simple problems.
“They come here, make a report, and disappear taking their payment with them. They are, more or less, not responsible or accountable. In Malta there is a need to have skilled and trained people like we have in Germany, who have gone to different places in the world to compare different solutions and to adopt these solutions to the Maltese situation.
“It is argued that Malta is in a particular situation with its dense population and, being a small island, it cannot afford to have a large recycling facility, which means waste needs to be exported for recycling.
“But in order to make such decisions, you need to have skilled Maltese people who stay in Malta, and not foreigners coming in on consultancies.
“What we are doing in Malta is different. We are not selling anything and we are not paid by Malta, but by the EC. So we offer our advice but of course its the Maltese government who has to decide whether to accept our advice or not.”
Dr Schnurer, who worked within the Germany’s environment ministry for over 20 years and was deputy director general for waste management, also sees bureaucratic shortcomings in terms of communications between the various ministries, departments and authorities involved in issues related to producer responsibilities.
“My feeling is that communications are very bad and there is very little flow of information between ministries and authorities. What happens is that you have many people who are working very hard but do not know what their neighbour is doing. Finding information is also very difficult.
“Sometimes people are doing the same things and work overlaps or is doubled, or someone could be relying on another to do a job but that person does not know.
“This is something that needs to be improved. In my opinion Malta needs a management scheme – an authority or a company to oversee the processes being undertaken by the ministries, MEPA, authorities and industry – and an organisational scheme so that everyone knows what their job is.”
Dr Schnurer cites the closing down of Maghtab as a success in Malta’s waste management drive and that a lot of good work has been carried out in limiting its hazardous gasses. He warns, however, that since the engineered landfills under development are an interim solution, there are a limited number of years in which to build new facilities.
Another challenge faced by Malta is that there is no specific facility for the treatment, disposal and recycling of waste. But Dr Schnurer is not of the commonly held opinion that Malta is too small and that recycling activities are not economically feasible.
“This is wrong,” he insists. “What Malta could do is some preliminary work toward recycling, and to bring these waste streams together with those of other European countries.”
The practice, he explains, is common across the EU, where waste streams from different countries are brought together at specialised facilities for recycling.
The one-year twinning project is located at WasteServ Malta and the EU provides its e400,000 funding. Six workshops on different aspects of producer responsibility have been organised in the first half-year on subjects such as packaging waste, batteries, waste oils, electrical and electronic waste.
The project has also had staff from Maltese authorities sent to Germany for one-week visits to view German waste management practices, while representatives from companies and bodies such as the Federation of Industry have also met with their German counterparts to study best practices in producer responsibility.