While its general budgetary proposals have been opened to public consultation this year for the second year running, the government has been holding its cards close to its chest when it comes to the exact details of what it has in mind. With Budget 2007 just around the corner, David Lindsay spoke to Finance Ministry Parliamentary Secretary Tonio Fenech for an insight into the lead-up to the evening of 18 October
This is the second year in which the government has opened the budget process to public consultation. What has been the government’s experience this year and what has the government gained from it?
Like last year, this year we’ve had public meetings, we’ve also had a number of meetings with the constituted bodies and there are still some others to take place.
But this year, we’ve done something innovative and tried to gather a more direct response from the general public by sending out a small leaflet with a questionnaire on what people considered to be their own priorities and the issues the budget should address. I think, with a response from over 2,000 people, in addition to people who sent in emails and documents, this part of the exercise had a good impact.
The exercise had some very interesting results, particularly when people were asked what they value most and what the budget should continue sustaining.
What really stood out was health. We speak a lot about things like the need to be competitive, the environment and investment in education, but the first thing people think about, from the results of the questionnaire, is health.
Of course there were a number of other issues being raised, such as the impact of energy prices on households and the need to invest in education, but health really stood out as a public priority.
In terms of the general debate at large, the government this year did something that was a first. Instead of identifying the budgetary options it was contemplating and, from the eight or 10 measures we had available we choose four to publish in the budget speech, this year we’ve put our cards on the table and said what we can afford as a country.
We have said we are clearly safe in assuming we can have a net impact on our revenues of Lm8 million. We have identified the areas we would like to see those funds go toward and, since we cannot do them all, we have asked people to prioritise.
But the public at large found it difficult to prioritise, and that, I think, helps people appreciate how difficult it is to make a budget because, at the end of the day, there are a lot of good things we would want to do but available funding is limited.
There are a lot of good projects that have been proposed by ministers, but if this year we are talking about providing tax relief, unfortunately we would obviously not be able to fund other projects where Lm8 million would have otherwise gone toward.
It’s a question of balancing at the end of the day and when it comes to formulating a budget, it’s a choice between lots of good things, but unfortunately working with the purse you have.
The general public discussions we held were also good in themselves, although you always wish they were better attended. This is the second year we’ve had such discussions and we can’t expect the mentality to have changed already. People will still tend to wait to see what the budget says, and then react after.
Speaking of balancing, there has been a lot of talk about the upcoming budget being aimed at easing burdens, while there was also a focus on boosting the economy and meeting the Maastricht criteria. How do you balance these aspects with limited funds available?
Within the economy itself, there are objectives that at times can be conflicting, but there are also objectives which can be complementary.
For example, will a relief on the tax bands be an incentive for the economy to grow? I do not completely agree with those who argue that increasing the potential to spend will necessarily bring the economic growth in the proportions they talk about. If that was true, we’d take away our taxes completely and let the economy flourish.
The question is what is the real impact of a relief on the tax bands? We are a small, open economy dependent on imports and therefore, if we give an Lm8 million tax relief on income and all that goes into the economy through spending, it will have a multiplier effect, but it will not have the same effect as it would in America, for example, where everything is produced within the country and there is a huge value added component.
On the other hand, in an economy that has to remain competitive we realise the reality of energy prices has led us to place a burden on the individual family household through the introduction of the fuel surcharge and that wage claim pressures start to rise as people expect to maintain at least the same level of income they are used to.
We have the Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA) mechanism to evaluate the inflationary impact, but higher claims for wages will obviously make our economy less competitive by increasing the cost of production, both in services and particularly in manufacturing. So a relief in the tax bands could also have a positive growth effect on the economy since it would reduce wage claims pressures.
We have also identified other measures that will have a direct effect, such as the National Insurance issue for part-time workers. There are a lot of women not entering the labour market, or at least not the open labour market, because there is a huge disincentive.
With the way our pension system operates today, with a minimum rate of some Lm5.85 per week, if a part-time worker is earning Lm2,000 per year, it’s hardly worth their while to go out and work since one fourth of what they earn is going to pay the NI contribution. What we are saying is that we move to a proportionate system where part-time work, particularly among women, is encouraged and not penalised.
There is a debate that has come up also with the social partners over what pension such a part-timer would be entitled to and we are proposing they would be entitled to a benefit proportionate to that which the minimum rate would have given. Since such a worker is not contributing the full amount, it cannot be expected that they are paid the full amount as a pension. One has to remember that if we had not taken this measure, in reality those individuals would not have received a direct pension anyway because they weren’t working. Now, at least, they will receive something.
Another measure with such a direct effect relates to the self-employed, where today’s income tax rules do not allow self-employed to take relief from work carried out by the spouse. We are saying the rule should be abolished. We need to allow that spouse’s contribution to the business to be recognised, for the spouse to be paid for that contribution and for that pay to be a deductible expense from the income tax return of the self-employed. We believe removing this restriction could also help a lot of people come back into the labour market.
We also recognise people feel the airport tax has had an impact on them and we will be addressing that. We understand the tax has created some uneasiness, although we do not completely agree it has reduced the potential for people to travel since travel has actually increased. But we do understand it is a tax people don’t feel so positive about.
The fuel surcharge is also being addressed through a new measure being introduced.
The issue of securitisation of property is another important measure. We intend to settle the long overdue debts people have had with the government, particularly through the expropriation of land, and we believe this is an important measure in itself and will bring some justice to these people.
What is important is that these measures and the others are a basket of measures. The Labour party at the moment is trying to raise expectations, but the government is going to be responsible in the decisions it takes. We will not jeopardise our targets. People have made sacrifices and we are not going to throw those away.
But yes, we are seeing progress being made in our economy. Public finances are reaching a sustainable level, which means can start the first phase of affording relief.
When we have asked people to contribute for the benefit of their future we have done that, and when we can give some relief then we will obviously do so.
This being the last full year budget before Malta intends adopting the euro, how do you see Malta meeting the four Maastricht criteria?
In terms of the public deficit and debt, we will meet the criteria, as those are something clearly in control in terms of budgetary planning.
We are targeting to close this year with the deficit at 2.8 per cent of GDP, which will qualify us for a revocation of the excessive deficit procedure.
The debt level is also reducing. The criteria is to come closer to the 60 per cent of GDP threshold and our progress in this respect is also apparent, while we have always been below the margin for the interest rate criterion.
There has been some preoccupation raised on the fourth criterion, the inflation rate, with the HICP at the moment being 0.3 per cent over the reference value. We are not off the mark by any significant amount, we’ve been at the 0.3 per cent level before, we have also been below that level and that will probably happen again.
It is important to note that the impact of the increase in the fuel surcharge in October is now being felt in the inflation rate. The HICP criteria, however, moves along a 12-month moving average, which means that this October, the surcharge was 55 per cent against last year’s 17 per cent, but once October passes, the differential will be, for example, 60 to 55 per cent.
How are pre-budgetary meetings with the constituted bodies progressing and how would you gauge their feedback?
We’ve already had two meetings with the Malta Council for Economic and Social Development extended group, which also includes civil society.
Closer to the budget we will be holding a long session with the social partners within the restrictive group, where the government will discuss the financial figures and the budget measures in more specificity.
We’ve received written submissions from practically all organisations. We have analysed and discussed the submissions with the social partners in our meetings and have also sought reactions from other parties to have a fully inclusive understanding of different viewpoints, so we are also progressing on that front.
In terms of the actual measures, there does seem to be a general consensus on most issues, while of course, there has been, and still is, debate on others.
The government is placing a lot of importance on the area of research and innovation, but has been criticised by some quarters for failing to implement the venture capital fund it has referred to in past budgets. What could we expect along these lines?
The government some years ago applied a focus to the area of information technology and now the country, particularly those working in the sector, is reaping the benefits. Now, we are giving the same importance to innovation.
We have, within the pre-budget document, published our proposed industrial policy where a venture capital fund is specifically mentioned. The fund will have a role and will be mentioned again in this year’s budget speech.
But with regard to venture capital, the real issue is not the government’s availability to provide a fund. The issue is the actual take-up of the fund – and that is where we fail.
I call on the social partners, particularly the Federation of Industry, to appreciate that it is not enough that the government provides venture capital funding, which we have done. The people who are to benefit from such funding will not merely be given cash grants to do whatever they want to do – they have to come with significant projects that are innovative or that propose innovative product or service ventures. So unless we have proposals coming in, the venture capital fund will once again fail to be a success and we will, as a country, continue to sit on the fund.
This is not something government does alone, it is something industry needs to participate in. One cannot expect the government to come up with both the ideas and the funds. More than industry itself, upcoming entrepreneurs need to present good proposals for the venture committee, convince them the project is doable and that they have the capabilities to succeed in what they are proposing. Yes, there is a process involved, but what we need is people to come forward with proposals.
There seems to be a certain ambiguity over the future of the extra 50c COLA given out last year as compensation for the fuel surcharge. Is this to be repeated in the forthcoming budget?
That was already decided in last year’s consultation process and budget.
The way our mechanism works is we have our retail price index and the compensation is always a year retrospective – we measure the inflation of the last year and give the compensation.
We knew that last year’s fuel surcharge would have an impact that we did not need to wait for following budget to recognise. But legitimately, the way our system works is that we should be giving it out next year, in this year’s budget.
So had we agreed last year to give a 50c compensation in advance, which would then obviously be integrated into, and not be over and above, next year’s increase. What we are saying is we will not reduce the 50c, but whatever the COLA will be, the 50c will be integrated into that. That was clearly agreed, government will keep the commitment it agreed to last year and I think everybody understands that.