The Court of Criminal Appeal yesterday converted a man’s 18-month jail term to a three-year probation period, giving him the last chance to get his life back in order and kick the drug habit.
On 18 January, Stanley Spiteri was sentenced to 18 months in jail after he pleaded guilty to stealing various items from a car on 9 May 2003 in St Julian’s, to the detriment of Laurence Zahra. Spiteri pleaded guilty to all the charges brought against him, including that of being in possession of stolen items and relapsing.
Spiteri appealed the judgement complaining that the punishment he was given was too harsh when compared to the punishment handed down to another man who was accused of committing the same crime.
The Court of Criminal Appeal, presided over by Mr Justice David Scicluna, heard Spiteri’s probation officer and a representative of the national drug and alcohol abuse agency say that the appellant had kicked the drug habit and had also found a job. However, they said there were instances when Spiteri would “slip” or “relapse” but added that the will to change was there.
Handing down his judgement, Mr Justice Scicluna noted that people charged with theft usually plead guilty to the charges brought against them early on in the proceeding, so as to benefit from a lighter punishment and without considering the charges brought against them.
He said that the charge of being in possession of stolen items was an alternative charge to that of theft. He therefore cleared Spiteri of this charge.
In his judgement, Mr Justice Scicluna said the court was willing “to take the risk” and give Spiteri the last chance to change his lifestyle and kick the drug habit. He therefore overturned the 18-month jail term and converted it into a three-year probation period. He also ordered him to start and successfully complete a drug rehabilitation programme.
Moreover, Mr Justice Scicluna extended an 18-month jail term suspended for three years, handed down in 2000, for a further three years starting yesterday.