Around 1,000 court cases have been pending before the Law Courts for more than 10 years, Parliamentary Secretary Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici told parliament on Monday.
In addition, he said, there are between 600 and 700 cases before the First Hall of the Civil Court that have yet to be appointed. He explained that at present there is no timeframe within which cases have to be appointed, and those court cases that take a long time to be appointed to a magistrate or judge create a variety of problems.
Cases that are not appointed continue to be the main problem faced by the Civil Court. Dr Mifsud Bonnici said that sometimes it takes up to two years for a case to be appointed. Some cases are also postponed for long periods of time, thereby reducing efficiency, he said.
During a debate on the amendments to the Code of Organisation and Civil Procedure, Dr Mifsud Bonnici said the amendments proposed by the government in the field of civil law are aimed at improving the operations of the Law Courts and judicial proceedings, making them more effective and efficient.
Dr Mifsud Bonnici said that a number of measures already in place have succeeded in reducing the number of pending cases in court. Most of these amendments, he said, involve cases dealing with property and succession, as well as cases within the First Hall of the Civil Court and the court of appeal.
The proposed amendments will enable a case to be appointed within two months, and will not allow a case to be postponed for more than two months. He said that if a case is left pending for too long, either party may file an application before the Chief Justice asking for a judge to be appointed to preside over the case.
The proposed amendments also include measures against frivolous appeals aimed at delaying cases.
Dr Mifsud Bonnici said people rightly expect justice within a reasonable period of time, and three years was considered a sufficient period of time for cases to be decided.
He said that the bill also proposed raising the competence of the Magistrates’ Court in its civil jurisdiction from a maximum of Lm5,000 to Lm10,000.
Another reform that had removed many cases from the Magistrates’ Court was a new procedure whereby uncontested official letters claiming payment for debts would automatically become an executive title.
Dr Mifsud Bonnici said that, despite heavy criticism, up to 6,000 people will have availed themselves of this new procedure by the end of the year, thus considerably reducing the workload of magistrates and judges. He said that, in the light of this success, the government was proposing to raise the cap on claims for the settlement of debts to Lm10,000 from Lm5,000.
Opposition justice spokesman Anglu Farrugia said that safeguarding democracy is essential. The right to justice cannot be tampered with and therefore procedures within the law courts must reflect justice.
Dr Farrugia added that there is far too much confusion in the Law Courts and certain procedures are in chaos.
“Justice must be done for everybody, and it is essential that the situation at hand does not remain stagnant, especially if human rights are involved,” he said.