The Malta Independent 20 November 2026, Friday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Thursday, 19 October 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Amendments to the Code of Organisation and Civil Procedure are crucial in order for there to be justice for all, since some may argue that justice delayed is justice denied, Nationalist MP Mario de Marco said in parliament on Tuesday.

Labour Spokesman for Home Affairs Gavin Gulia also spoke about the delays in the judiciary process, referring to the fact that a number of court cases take far too long to be concluded.

He urged the government to publish the statistics so that there would be better understanding of the number of pending cases when compared to previous years.

In reply, Parliamentary Secretary in the Justice and Home Affairs Ministry Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici gave various examples of how there has been a decrease in the backlog of court cases.

For instance, he said that in the Small Claims Tribunal, in 2004 there were 2,100 cases to be heard and in 2006 these have decreased to 1,800 cases.

Justice and Home Affairs Minister Tonio Borg stated that cases, especially of a less serious nature, should not take more than three years to be decided.

Dr Gulia claimed that he felt positive about the fact that at present, there is more specialisation and decentralisation in the courts. He agreed that something should be done in order to decrease the delay in sentencing court cases. However, Dr Gulia stated that he disagreed with the amendment, whereby cases which have not be given a sentence after three years or more from the start of hearing, would be given the opportunity to be heard by a different magistrate.

He argued that this amendment might cause various complications and also lead to abuse from the parties involved. He also maintained that there is a great probability that efficient magistrates would have to take on cases of the less efficient ones. He mentioned that people could abuse of this system, since there may be ones who would be willing for the sentencing to be delayed and thus have their case heard by a different magistrate.

Dr Gulia pointed out what he said was another disadvantage of this amendment. He claimed that when a case is handed over to another magistrate, the elements of hearing the witnesses and studying the case would be lost in this process. He continued to argue that should the magistrate choose to hear the witnesses all over again, it will take a lot of time before the sentence may be given.

Labour MP Josè Herrera claimed that with regard to the appointment of senior magistrates, he agrees with the concept of seniority, especially if that person is efficient and of good character. He argued that the senior magistrate should be the oldest and the one possessing the most experience in this line of work.

The issue of lawyers taking on cases pro bono, with reference to legal aid, was also discussed by Dr Herrera. He stated that he was in disagreement with the fact that there is an official list of the lawyers expected to work pro bono. Additionally, he stated that if a lawyer is forced to work pro bono, such lawyer might be less efficient in his work. Instead, Dr Herrera maintained that working pro bono should be left at the lawyer’s discretion.

Dr de Marco agreed that some people are unable to afford legal fees and thus need to be provided with good legal representation in order for justice to be served.

Dr Borg also made reference to the amendment whereby official letters with the sentence would be sent to those awaiting the sentence. Such parties have 30 days in which to contest the given sentence. According to Dr Borg, this is an efficient way of decreasing the judiciary process backlog and also decreases legal fees.

  • don't miss