A Court of Criminal Appeal has reduced a man’s prison sentence from 20 years to five years after declaring him not guilty of attempted murder but guilty of causing grievous bodily harm with a sharp and pointed instrument.
In February this year, a panel of jurors found Keith Galea guilty of attempting to kill Jason Said when he hit him with a sharp and pointed instrument in Manoel Island on the night of 27 and 28 September 2001.
The Court of Criminal Appeal, presided over by Chief Justice Vincent De Gaetano and composed of Mr Justice Joseph Micallef and Mr Justice David Scicluna, jailed Galea for five years – the maximum punishment for this crime – in view of his criminal record and the fact that he had committed the crime during the operative period of a suspended sentence.
Galea had appealed against the judgement on five grounds. He complained that his lawyer had not had enough time to prepare his defence, because he was assigned to the case just five days before the trial by jury began, and that he did not have time to prepare his final submissions before the jurors retired to deliberate. He also complained about certain comments passed by Mr Justice Joseph Galea Debono who presided over the trial, claiming that these comments could have influenced the jurors.
The Court of Criminal Appeal rejected these complaints but upheld the one in which Galea argued that the jurors were not supplied with enough evidence to convince them, beyond reasonable doubt, that he had had any intention of killing Mr Said.
The Appeals Court said it was convinced that Galea had not intended to kill Mr Said, but was just guilty of seriously injuring him with a sharp and pointed instrument.
Handing down the new judgement, the Appeals Court reduced Galea’s jail term to five years.