The Malta Independent 20 November 2026, Friday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Sunday, 22 October 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 13 years ago

Noel Grima

In yet another resounding public rebuke, the Council of Europe has sent back the three nominations the government of Malta had submitted for the post of Maltese judge in the European Court of Justice.

The government had presented three names despite knowing that one of the nominees had to be a woman. The three names submitted by the government of Malta were those of Chief Justice Vincent Degaetano, Judge Joseph D. Camilleri and Judge Joseph Filletti.

Eleven people, including two women, had applied to be considered as Malta’s representative to succeed Judge Giovanni Bonello, who resigned last June on reaching retirement age.

This newspaper is informed the two women were Malta’s ambassador to Tunisia Dr Theresa Vella and Dr Lorraine Schembri Orland.

The government’s selection board seems to have come to the conclusion that only the three names it submitted had wide experience in human rights.

It seems, at least according to KullHadd which ran the story two weeks ago, that in its covering letter, the Maltese government had explained that despite receiving two applications from women lawyers, they did not have enough competence in human rights.

But the Council of Europe’s selection board did not consider this to be a valid excuse for disregarding the stipulation that one of the three nominees had to be a woman and sent the nominations back.

The government is now understood to be considering what it will do in the coming weeks.

This is not the first time that the government of Malta and the Council of Europe have crossed swords regarding the Council’s gender policy.

A few months ago, the government nomination of MPs to sit in the Council’s parliamentary assembly was sent back, in another equally humiliating rebuff, until the government included the name of parliamentary secretary Helen d’Amato in the delegation.

  • don't miss