With Ryanair having just announced it is to start operations to Malta, and with the airline’s current business nemesis residing in Malta as a tax exile, it was inevitable that Malta would be mentioned in the ensuing war of words.
The issue involves Ryanair’s proposed purchase of Ireland’s Aer Lingus, and the stiff opposition put up by telecommunications multimillionaire and Ireland’s eighth richest person Denis O’Brien. Mr O’Brien does not reside in Ireland for tax purposes and recently moved from Portugal to Malta.
Two weeks ago Ryanair put in a bid for Aer Lingus, which O’Brien opposed and responded to by buying a 2.2 per cent stake in Aer Lingus in an attempt to disrupt Ryanair’s e1.49 billion take-over bid.
Although O’Brien insists the move was not personally motivated, Ryanair and its chief executive Michael O’Leary are not ones to take such a matter lying down.
In the latest exchange this week, the outspoken O’Leary suggested O’Brien, who makes regular trips to Ireland on a private jet, should sell the private jet and use Ryanair’s low cost flights instead.
“Poor tax exiles in Malta like Denis O`Brien should trade in their corporate jet and use Ryanair`s e22 low-cost fares,” he is quoted as saying when releasing details of Ryanair’s former offer for Aer Lingus.
“He will make a significant saving on his Challenger 5 or whatever he is flying on this week. If Denis wants to check in his bag, it will only cost him an extra luggage charge of e3.50.”
The comments follow a recent advertising campaign poking fun at O’Brien and his tax-friendly residency in Malta. The campaign, illustrated with a picture of O’Brien, offered “free” flights to Malta with the slogan “all you pay is taxes”.
Ryanair faces stiff opposition to its bid to acquire a controlling 50.1 per cent stake in the airline. With O’Brien’s recent share acquisition, Ryanair’s opponents now hold 47 per cent of the company, while the Irish government and the Irish pilot’s union, which hold 28 and 17 per cent stakes respectively, are wary about the bid in that it would leave Ireland’s airline industry with just one main player.
O’Brien made his fortune when he sold the Esat network, now BT Communications Ireland Limited, and invested the profits in Caribbean mobile phone network Digicel, which is about to be listed on the New York Stock Exchange in a deal that could earn him e1.4 billion.