It is unfortunate that the Budget ritual in the Malta Parliament is habitually smothered in party political foam, with the government side glorifying its performance and the Opposition sniping at the flow of mantras coming from the ministerial benches.
With a general election looming on the horizon, this process becomes all the more intense, producing far more heat than light. The spectacle is by no means uplifting. It certainly does not help to enlighten public opinion. Much less does it contribute to a general understanding of the economic state of play.
The taxpaying electorate needs objective information if it is to be mobilized and empowered to play a constructive role in Malta's struggle for economic survival.
Malta's challenge is to earn its keep and hold its own in a globalised world driven by ruthless, unforgiving competition. This it has to do by augmenting its foreign earnings while it consumes its resources frugally
In the past several years it has not been that way. The government has been overspending steadily and deliberately, driven by a money no problem craze that produced a structural deficit and mounting debt. Suffice it to say that government debt shot up from Lm63 million in l987, to just over Lml.4 billion at the end of last year. Malta was living well beyond its means.
On accession to the EU, the government was obliged to backtrack and conform to the Maastricht criteria with regard to deficit spending and the level of debt.
Austerity regime
This necessitated sharp austerity measures, chiefly in the form of steep taxation. It squeezed all social classes. It crushed those at the middle and lower levels. But it simultaneously pressed the manufacturing and commercial sectors to the wall. There were many casualties and thousands of families were set back.
This happened at a time when Malta was struggling to maintain its competitiveness in overseas markets, and when tax erosion was eating away at the citizens' spending power.
This process was steady and remorseless, but never minutely analysed, while a number of factories, hotels were closing down and Malta foreign-earning power was weakening.
Professor Joseph Falzon, of the Department of Banking and Finance at the University of Malta, has now done just that. He did so in a paper commissioned by the GRTU as part of the consultation process relating to the 2007 Budget.
In an elaborate report, backed by illuminating statistics, he established that our exports of goods and services have been declining since 2000, in both nominal and real terms The level of total exports at market prices in 2005 was just over 10 per cent less than the level of total exports in 2005. In real terms (after adjusting for inflation), real exports also declined in 200l, 2003 and 2005.
The increase in gross profits between l996 and 2005 for the whole Maltese economy has only been half the rate of inflation. Manufacturing, as well as Hotels and Restaurants, registered an absolute decline in their total operating surplus.
If this scenario materialises, policy makers have to face the question as to where future economic growth can come from.
Against this background, and with hindsight, the harm of the money no problem years could be better understood. EU accession suppressed, in large part, the original folly, and led to the introduction of severe austerity measures, largely in the form of stiff taxation, which in turn stoked the fire of inflation while eroding Malta's competitivity.
Thanks to Professor Falzon's initiative, we now have a realistic measure of Malta's economic malaise. It is time for all policy makers to call a spade a spade.
[email protected]