Despite generally positive reactions to Budget 2007 from major social partners, in stark contrast Opposition Leader ALFRED SANT described it as hollow and feeble, without a clear strategy to improve the way the country operates. Francesca Vella met him to discuss the matter and the way the Labour Party is trying to gain credibility among the Maltese.
The opposition’s harsh criticism of the budget must have come as no surprise to many people, I immediately told Opposition Leader Alfred Sant when I met him in his office less than 24 hours after Prime Minister and Finance Minister Lawrence Gonzi delivered the budget speech in Parliament.
Although my comment did not irk him in any way, the Opposition Leader – in his composed manner – seemed determined to give me clear reasons as to why the Labour Party had taken such a stand on the budget.
Dr Sant explained that the heavy tax burdens imposed during the past five to seven years have had a big say on the country’s performance; the fact that it is not doing too well with regard to competitiveness is also, in part, a result of the constant increase in taxes, he said.
“The Nationalist government started adopting a number of policies based on the idea of ‘money no problem’. Naturally, when you spend more, you need to increase taxes, and in turn an increase in the cost of living is generated and people feel they can’t cope,” Dr Sant said, adding that as a result, the expectations for this year’s budget were twofold.
Judging by the fact that after all these years of problems and heavy burdens, the government is now speaking about having placed the country’s finances on solid ground, one would have expected more schemes to alleviate the burden on the lower-and-middle-income brackets of society, and it was also expected that the budget would include a number of measures that would provide a stimulus to the economy, he said.
“Yes, in this year’s budget we saw that there is going to be a movement in certain income tax bands and yes, there will be a reduction in the departure tax – a u-turn, since the government increased this tax from Lm10 to Lm20 just two years ago. However this will only come into effect as from June and to top it all, the situation of the electricity and water surcharge has remained unchanged,” Dr Sant argued.
He added that so many fundamental issues and sectors, like the manufacturing and tourism industries, are not being addressed in the correct manner.
“The country needs a plan for such crucial sectors – we need to see the way we’re going to go about resolving the problems of tourism, a sector that is not only in the doldrums but in a crisis,” Dr Sant said.
He added that very little was mentioned in this year’s budget on sectors that are facing stagnation, like the self-employed, agriculture and fisheries.
When I asked him what the Labour Party is proposing with regard to the fuel surcharge, he said that he will be explaining the plan this week, but “the system is not transparent and people are being faced with burdens as a result of the fact that Enemalta’s performance is not efficient enough”.
The price of oil fluctuates and the current tendency is that it is on the downside. “So why is the surcharge still high?” he asks, and proposed that the surcharge changes depending on the price of oil.
He feels that the budget required much more reflection with regard to the need to improve the quality of life.
He emphasised that the country requires clear strategies. “If we were operating on the basis of a specific plan for tourism, for example, this sector would definitely have progressed, but during these past few years, we have simply been talking about what we should do to try to strengthen it. Nothing, apart from an increased budget, was mentioned in the budget, with regard to tourism. There is no plan,” Dr Sant stressed.
He said that it is for these reasons that the Labour Party is saying that the budget is hollow and feeble – “it is full of rhetoric and it lacks the dynamic vision that people expect”.
“The fact that the government is failing to abide by set plans to improve the way the country operates in a number of sectors gives the impression that the government has run out of ideas… that it is running on the spot. When it comes to projecting a vision, it stalls. In fact the government has no vision, except that of conforming to criteria imposed by the EU with regard to the budget.”
In its initial reaction to the budget, the Labour Party also mentioned modernisation of the economy as a crucial aspect for the country to operate in a better, more competitive manner.
Dr Sant explained that the Labour Party has been carrying out consultations on a regular basis with a number of entrepreneurs, businessmen and social partners.
“One of the main complaints is the country’s bureaucratic system and this is the main issue that comes up as an explanation for every delayed project in the country, in both the private and public sectors,” he said.
When I asked him what could be done to cut down on red tape, he mentioned three fundamental aspects that he believes should be able to help – management, planning and coordination.
“The way by which the Labour Party carried out the much-needed Bugibba project back in 1996-1998, showed that things can be done in the framework of a modernised economy, through a managerial way of getting things done,” Dr Sant said, adding that modernisation implies a system that delivers in both the public and private sectors.
He stressed that reducing bureaucracy should be a priority and explained that the system cannot be adopted across the board right away, but rather, one could attach a priority commitment to a couple of projects by coordinating them properly and by setting deadlines.
“The concept of waste separation, for example, is a project that has not delivered as yet. A strategy to run over two to three years should have been organised, and with a coordinated effort, the system could have been set in place,” he said.
I asked him whether he believes that the recent cruise liners industry might be “harming” the hotels industry in a certain sense.
Dr Sant explained that the tourism industry in Malta must be considered as a whole package of different options for tourists, if the industry is to regain ground.
He added that Malta potentially has a lot to offer to various types of tourists – students, tourists who want to stay in luxury hotels, those who want to get a taste of our culture and heritage, and others who want to enjoy the beaches. Those who visit Malta on cruises are only part of the whole package.
While he said that the Labour Party in government in 1997 had embarked on a project to introduce the cruise liner industry in Malta, Dr Sant said the Nationalist government took years to implement this project.
“It should have been carried out much faster. There is still more to be done with regard to our reception facilities, as well as the tours we offer, some of which are not up to standard,” Dr Sant said.
Some might argue that tourists who visit Malta on cruise liners come for a day and leave, he said, adding that the Labour Party’s concept has always been to project Malta as a port of departure, not simply as a port of call.
He explained that the country’s strategic position would make it possible for cruise liners to leave from Malta and go on cruises of both the Eastern and Western Mediterranean. It would follow that new companies would also operate from Malta, but we need to provide incentives and the right facilities for this to happen, Dr Sant said.
“When long distance cruises leave from Malta, for example, incoming tourists who would be going to join a cruise might stay on for another day. This may happen and it may also not, but it is still an opportunity,” he enthused.
The Opposition Leader also gave a sketch about plans the Labour Party has for the Grand Harbour and said that while certain areas, like the Marsa area, beg to be developed, this natural harbour has so much potential – in fact it compares very well with other famous harbours around the world.
He explained that the Labour Party has in mind the development of the Grand Harbour as a whole, adding that it can be developed beautifully – all of it – possibly by providing an incentive for the private sector to take over, while making sure the targets are accomplished as fast as possible.
Dr Sant further insisted on better management, even when I mentioned education. How can we truly provide excellence in education?
“If we want to develop our resources, we need to establish what is needed to reach targets. In other words, if we established – years ago – that the pharmaceutical and IT industries were potential areas for investment, then why did we fail to come up with a plan to educate enough people in these sectors?
“Foreign pharmaceutical companies did invest in Malta, but they did not find enough people to employ. Likewise, we are facing the same problems with IT. These crash programmes for IT students that are being launched now are a very amateurish way of doing things.”
While acknowledging the fact that funding is important, Dr Sant said that a main plank of the Labour Party’s plan for education is to lay sound foundations for the development of children by introducing a so-called reception class at the pre-primary stage to ensure that every child gets the necessary skills before starting primary school as we know it.
He explained that by means of this reception or foundation class, the education system should improve as a whole – all the way up to university.
The Labour Party has been drawing up a number of vision statements on every sector one could possibly imagine. Nonetheless, the fact that in the eyes of many people, the MLP more often than not, seeks to simply criticise, failing to provide possible alternatives, might be undermining its credibility. So I ask Dr Sant whether my assumption is correct and how credible he believes the Labour Party is among the people in general.
“Without any doubt, we believe that the opposition’s job is to criticise. We are convincing people that we are credible, more than credible. The MLP has won consistently in the local council elections during the past three years. That covers the whole of Malta. The same goes for the European Parliament elections.”
On the whole, many more people are better-understanding the need for change – change that should be guided by a party that can deliver and the Labour Party wants to make the difference, Dr Sant explained.
“Our problem has always been that we tell the truth, we say things that people don’t like to hear, but at the end of the day, people prefer politicians who tell them the way things actually stand.
“This is our strategy. On the basis of how we see things, we want to come up with plans in a number of sectors, which would then converge to bring about economic growth.”