Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi yesterday described Labour leader Dr Alfred Sant’s solution to reduce the surcharge as “superficial and incorrect”.
Addressing a press conference after Dr Sant had given his reply to the government’s budget for 2007, the Prime Minister said the MLP leader had still not understood – even when presented with numerous reports by independent experts – that the surcharge did not have an element of
inefficiency costs in it.
“The surcharge reflects the international price of oil and nothing else. Dr Sant’s premise is incorrect, yet he refuses to understand this,” said Dr Gonzi.
The prime minister reiterated that VAT is not paid on energy bills for home users and although there is a VAT element in commercial cases, businesses received a VAT refund.
“His theory does not work. He does not have a solution and over the past months and weeks he has taken the country for a ride,” Dr Gonzi said.
The prime minister described the leader of the opposition’s speech as suitable “for a mass meeting and not a reply to the government’s budget”.
Dr Gonzi said that of the 109 measures introduced in the 2007 budget – aimed at stimulating economic growth and a better standard of living – the Opposition Leader had mentioned only one, the revision of the tax bands, and had got it wrong.
“In two hours, Dr Sant spent little time on the budget and the measures this government is introducing. Instead of making reference to the investment in education, he quoted statistics aimed at putting the sector in a bad light. He did not speak about the environment or our initiatives to help the self-employed and owners of small businesses,” the Prime Minister said.
He said the Opposition Leader had made a number of u-turns in his speech.
“On 17 March 2004, he had said that whoever was pushing for low-cost carriers was short-sighted. Today, he said low costs airlines are an important element of the travel industry. Today, he also changed his position on the euro and by so doing, he has accepted that the government has managed to meet the Maastricht criteria – the deficit is now below three per cent of GDP, public debt is being reduced and interest rates are stable. The only outstanding issue is inflation but we are working hard to control it,” the prime minister said.
Dr Sant’s speech does not provide an alternative, Dr Gonzi said, and neither does it reflect an opposition that has a vision for the future.
Replying to questions from the press, Dr Gonzi said that after 10 years, Dr Sant had still not learnt any lessons and continued to contradict himself. He said that, contrary to Dr Sant’s assertion that the budget for 2007 was full of taxes, the government was increasing its revenue because the economy was growing and companies were making a profit.