A Court of Criminal Appeal increased a six-year jail term of a man convicted of defiling his two adopted daughters to 10 years after it ruled that the Magistrates’ Court had not taken into account the fact that it was a continuous offence.
The man, whose name cannot be published by court order so as to protect the identity of his two underage children, was originally jailed for six years after he was found guilty of defiling his two adopted children who at the time were 12 and 14 years old.
The Attorney General appealed the judgement handed down by the Magistrates’ Court claiming that this court did not consider the defilement as a continuous crime, and therefore did not apply article 18 of the Criminal Code.
This article states that if several acts committed by the offender, even if at different times, are committed in pursuance of the same design, these shall be deemed to be a continuous offence. The article also stipulates that the punishment can be increased by one or two degrees according to law.
The Court of Criminal Appeal, presided over by Mr Justice Giannino Caruana Demajo, upheld the Attorney General’s claim that the Magistrates’ Court did not take into consideration that the abuse took place over a period of seven years.
The court heard how the girls were brought over to Malta when they were five and seven years old and were adopted by the man and his wife.
Seven years later, the younger of the two girls told a priest that her father had been sexually abusing her since their arrival in Malta. The priest urged the child to seek help and put her in touch with social services. But when the social worker spoke to the older sister, she at first was too embarrassed to say anything but eventually told him not to take action against her father and said that she would “take care of everything herself”.
A few days later the older sister spoke out. When the social worker spoke to her again, she claimed that her father had not only touched her but also had sex with her.
However, medical tests carried out on the two sisters revealed that they were both still virgins.
The defendant also appealed the judgement handed down by the Magistrates’ Court. He claimed that his two children were lying about him and that they used to provoke him by jumping on him and kissing him goodnight before they went to sleep.
However, the court turned down his appeal since, it said, it believed more the testimony of the two young girls rather than that of the father.
Handing down his judgement, Mr Justice Caruana Curran upheld the Attorney General’s request to apply Article 18 of the Criminal Code since, he said, the continuous offence had been proven in court.
After applying this article, the minimum punishment for this crime was of five years’ imprisonment while the maximum was that of 12 years.
Mr Justice Caruana Curran said that the crime is one which is “shocking” to society and the court believed that the punishment should be closer to the maximum rather than the minimum. He therefore increased the jail term handed down by the first court from six years to 10 years.