As the European Parliament begins to prepare its report on international roaming charges, doubts are now growing over whether the capping of such charges will truly bring about a reduction in prices. In today’s free market scenario, such measures appear rather retrospective and reek of archaic State intervention that effectively ruined the economies of large countries such as France, Germany and the United Kingdom in the 1970s.
But what’s in it for the consumer, according to the European Commission that came out with its grand cost cutting plan in early July?
According to Information Society Commissioner Viviane Reding, the EC is to oblige mobile phone companies to do away with what it describes as “unjustified high costs” when using a mobile phone abroad. Ms Reding has been quoted as stating that costs are expected to go down by between 40 to 60 per cent.
Interestingly, that other bureaucratic monster that is the Malta Communications Authority supports such a move and is on record as stating that it will continue to work with the other European regulators in providing additional input for the formulation of this regulation.
Mobile operators have actually indicated that market forces will eventually dictate that roaming charges will have to fall by about 50 per cent over the next year, so this attempt by the Brussels based bureaucrats to intervene does appear rather forceful and unnecessary.
Moreover, some top commentators in the field of telephony believe that such measures will dampen the philosophy of free market enterprise, ironically the very foundations on which the EU is based upon.
All this regulation changes the locus of decision-making. Why bother to negotiate wholesale and retail charges if the regulator will do it for you? Why should customers bother to compare operators? Why should operators bother to compete with new products? Why not lobby the regulator instead? Just try to fix it in Brussels.
“Price controls reduce communication and coordination between operators and customers. There is less awareness of what different customers want, less incentive and ability to provide it. Increasing reliance on regulators and politicians means prices and services are determined by bureaucrats instead of customers,” a commentator said recently.
Roaming charges may have been high in the past but the market is changing and charges are falling significantly. It is now in the operators’ interests to stimulate this market not exploit it. Price caps on mobile charges could inadvertently discourage this competition, to the longer term detriment of customers. Having made its point, Brussels should pause for a while. A misguided attempt to solve yesterday’s problem could create a worse problem tomorrow.
The Malta Independent on Sunday spoke to Vodafone Malta about the issue, and they are understandably concerned about the turn things are taking.
This situation begged the question if the company is actually against the reduction of roaming charges.
“Not at all. In fact Vodafone Malta is already delivering cheaper roaming prices to its customers through Vodafone Passport (also known as Travel Promise). Vodafone introduced this innovative retail roaming tariff package in June 2005 with the scope of providing customers with cheaper roaming prices, greater transparency & simplicity. This tariff proposition was introduced well before the proposed regulation was issued”, a senior management source at the company told this paper.
Vodafone also provides a number of incentives to customers who roam frequently and crucially. It has committed itself to reduce charges by 40 per cent by April 2007.
“Through VF Passport, whenever a Vodafone customer roams on another Vodafone network, local domestic tariffs apply to his call in the EU member State and his call home, with a connection fee applied to each call made or received. Vodafone Malta has also announced the reduction of roaming prices by 40 per cent with effect from 1 April 2007. We are also offering and agreed on a number of reciprocal wholesale agreements with other operators at 0.45€ per minute for EU roaming traffic,” the source added.
Additionally, Vodafone has already signed up over 10 million Passport customers across the EU and is adding approximately 150,000 customers a week. It will further increase tariff transparency with roaming tariff information available through a free SMS service to be deployed across Europe including Malta.
“Our aim is to provide a high quality roaming experience at the best possible price for our customers,” the source said.
Vodafone Malta also acknowledged that current charges are way too high but believes that the market should address this and not some other competition strangling regulation that leads nowhere.
“Our roaming prices depend on the tariffs charged by our roaming partners when our subscribers roam abroad. It is true that roaming charges are perceived to be high by many but one must consider that roaming services form part of a whole portfolio of service offered by mobile operators. One has to note that there are many costs involved and a huge amount of investment required providing widespread roaming services across Europe and the rest of the world. Vodafone Passport was in fact introduced in order to eliminate the perception that roaming is expensive and provide our customers with value for money.”
Granted that costs are rather high to service roaming networks but what is the company offering its customers? How will this much-vaunted “self-regulation” operate?
“Since the announcement of the Commission’s proposals, most of the industry players within the EU announced substantial wholesale and retail price reductions which are already delivering cheaper roaming prices to consumers. These announcements, which include those made by Vodafone earlier this year, continue to add grist to our mill as follows:
“They reflect the different competitive positioning of the mobile players and the way they wish to differentiate their products and services:
“They are proof of the general competitive environment in the roaming market across the EU:
“They represent major commercial and financial risks for mobile operators in the event that call volumes do not increase as a result of cheaper prices.
“The above clearly shows that even without regulation, the industry is already delivering cheaper roaming prices across the board. In our view, regulatory intervention should only be contemplated and implemented in the event that competition in the market does not work.
“Even if the roaming market was not thought to be competitive, the existing regulatory framework (i.e. Competition Law and the EU’s Electronic Communications Regulatory Framework) already provides regulators with the tools to analyse this market and objectively determine whether it is competitive or not with the possibility of applying proportionate remedies to address the market problem.”
For example, eight EU member States found no problem in their respective wholesale market for roaming while other member States are expected to reach similar conclusions. It is also true that the mobile market has been found to be competitive overall and no abuse has been discovered so far.
Although Vodafone Malta supports the eventual price reductions for customers who use roaming services, it is still very sceptical on this heavy-handed approach from supposedly free market Brussels.
“Vodafone Malta supports the Commission’s objective of delivering cheaper roaming prices to consumers. However, we feel that this proposed regulation is intrusive, heavy handed and arbitrary and may inhibit competition in the long term to the detriment of the consumer. Basically we agree with the objective of the Commission but disagree on the ‘how’,” the source explained.
Among the points raised by the company are the following:
The proposed regulation has ignored the fact that the market is already delivering lower prices and will continue to do so in the future,
For example, the proposed regulation will make Vodafone Passport illegal since any tariff that combines fixed and variable fees would not be allowed. This because the regulation prohibits any minute costing more than the limit set by the Commission – even if subsequent minutes of a call cost much less. This popular product developed after extensive market research and investment and a result of competition in the market would have to be withdrawn. This is a clear case which shows that the retail regulation as proposed does not work in the interests of consumers although the Commission’s objective is in favour of the consumer.
“We thought that retail price regulation was a thing of the past – in fact the regulatory framework introduced in 2002 does not include the retail mobile market in the list of relevant markets. By establishing a single wholesale and retail price for roaming services across all EU markets, the regulation ignores the different costs of providing services in different countries as well as the needs of different consumers requiring different tariff plans. This is a case in point for VF Malta since our dis-economies of scale do not always allow us to achieve the same price levels applicable in other much larger EU jurisdictions. Retail price controls places the mobile industry in a straightjacket killing off innovation in tariff design and competition in the market. Retail price controls are usually applied on traditional monopolies and not on an industry which the Commission itself acknowledges is very competitive.”
The proposed regulation raises a number of concerns among investors regarding Europe’s approach to regulation. The roaming regulation is viewed as driving value out of the industry and this may inhibit future investment in one of the EU’s leading and most dynamic sectors. The main concern is the perception of arbitrary intervention in a market notwithstanding the existence of a regulatory framework, which at its core should draw up regulations for industry to act competitively, as well as a discipline for policy-makers to regulate as a last resort. Regulatory intervention outside the framework sets a worrying precedent, the company spokesperson concluded.
This situation is a déjà vu for those who were involved in the pharmaceutical products “price wars”, when the government had threatened to introduce price orders, which industry players had denounced as a huge retrograde step that would lead to catastrophic results such as loss of jobs. Let’s hope that the situation regarding roaming charges will go down the road of reason, which is to let the free market self regulate itself. It’s always worked before and should not fail now.