An EU directive to be transposed into Maltese law will set minimum standards for asylum seekers’ qualification for refugee status and subsidiary protection status such as that of humanitarian protection. It will also curtail the current ministerial discretion in cases of granting humanitarian protection status to asylum seekers and instead lay down minimum criteria States will have to abide by when granting such status.
The so-called Qualification Directive stipulates common, minimum criteria across the European Union to identify asylum seekers who are in genuine need of international protection, while also ensuring minimum levels of benefits are available to such persons in all member States.
While the criteria by which Malta grants refugee status appears to be largely in line with what the directive proposes, it is in the area of granting humanitarian protection status to asylum seekers that matters are about to be changed.
As matters currently stand, Malta’s refugee commissioner recommends to the minister responsible, in Malta’s case Home Affairs Minister Tonio Borg, whether individual cases should be granted humanitarian protection status or not. The directive, however, establishes minimum criteria for asylum seekers’ qualification for humanitarian protection status and, as such, will limit the minister’s powers of discretion in awarding such status.
Malta and no less than 18 other member States had failed to transpose the new directive by the 10 October deadline. The European Commission is now considering initiating legal proceedings against those countries.
Speaking to The Malta Independent on Sunday, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) senior legal assistant for Malta Neil Falzon commented that the UNHCR is generally pleased with the means by which refugee status is granted by Malta and that the directive “ generally reflects what goes on in Malta” .
It is in the area of the granting of humanitarian protection status to asylum seekers that, in some cases, the local situation is not wholly compatible with the directive, but once transposed and implemented it will “ be an improvement on the Maltese situation” .
“Unlike refugee status,” he explains, “ Malta’s Refugee Act stipulates that the granting of humanitarian protection status is at the discretion of the minister, following a recommendation from the Refugee Commissioner.
“What the directive does is put down, in black and white, which individuals are to be granted humanitarian status, such as those fleeing civil wars and militia.”
But while Dr Falzon stresses the UNHCR is generally satisfied with Malta’s Refugee Status Determination process and that the UNHCR has positive, co-operative relations with the Maltese authorities, there are nevertheless disagreements on how humanitarian status is, or rather is not, granted in some cases.
He cites Iraqi and Eritrean asylum seekers as examples where the UNHCR finds itself in strong disagreement with the Refugee Commissioner.
The granting of humanitarian protection status to Eritreans who, along with Sudanese, constitute the majority of asylum seekers arriving in Malta, is one such bone of contention. Malta’s Refugee Commission feels that certain groups of Eritreans can be safely repatriated but, given the circumstances prevailing in the war-torn country, the UNHCR recommends all Eritreans be given humanitarian protection status. The UN body, however, does agree that, generally speaking, such status has been granted in most cases where it has been warranted.
In the case of Iraqi asylum seekers, which have been fewer and further between, the two bodies are at odds over their analyses of the safety of Iraq. While the Refugee Commission believes the whole of Iraq is safe for repatriation, the UNHCR is of the opinion that it is only the northern, relatively stable section of the country that could be considered safe for repatriation. As such, the UNHCR believes most Iraqis requesting humanitarian protection should also be allowed such status.
The Qualification Directive goes over and above the provisions of the 1951 UN Refugee Convention in that it widens the scope in which individuals are granted refugee status to those fleeing civil wars, while widening the definition of persecutors to non-State agents such as warlords and militia. The directive also adopts a gender-sensitive interpretation of the Refugee Convention by allowing refugee recognition to those who have a well-founded fear of being persecuted on account of their sexual orientation or gender. As such, the directive recognises the legitimacy of asylum claims made by women based on acts of sexual violence, domestic violence, female genital mutilation and those facing persecution because of their homosexuality.
The directive also lays out benefits to be granted to refugees and those with subsidiary protection status. These include the issuing of residency permits and travel documents. Also included are access to education, employment, social welfare and healthcare – the core benefits of which are to be in line with the same levels and eligibility conditions as the nationals of the member state in question.
The office of the Attorney General, which is responsible for drafting the new legislation, is said to be in the process of drawing up the necessary legal documents for the transposition of the directive into Maltese law.