In Europe, Green politics has been a force to be reckoned with for years but in Malta Alternattiva Demokratika, with the exceptions of its local council successes and an inspiring performance in the first MEP elections, has still to come into its own. David Lindsay speaks to AD chairman HARRY VASSALLO about the party’s bid to change Malta’s political status quo
Alternattiva Demokratika chairman Harry Vassallo is upbeat about the prospects of Malta’s Green party being elected to Parliament the next time Malta goes to the polls for a general election.
Such a development would mark a significant milestone on the party’s 15-year electoral road, which began in 1992 when it contested its first general election in a bid to provide an alternative to the duopoly presented by Malta’s two main political players.
But despite what many consider to have been a rather poor showing at the last general election, Dr Vassallo is enthusiastic about the next and does not mince his words.
“Our poor performance in the last election was actually engineered by us. I think the whole country remembers that, in view of EU accession, we basically told people to vote for another party, which was unheard of in any election.”
After having “endorsed” the Nationalist Party in the 2003 election, AD was rewarded with an outstanding result in the European parliamentary elections, where its candidate Prof. Arnold Cassola pulled in 9.3 per cent of the vote – representing a 1,300 per cent gain over the general election’s 0.7 per cent vote. AD had missed, by a tantalisingly narrow margin, winning one of Malta’s five European parliamentary seats.
But although an MEP election does not exactly carry the same weight as a general election, the result was nevertheless important, according to Dr Vassallo, in that it shows that the potential for the Green party to make real political headway is alive and well.
“The result showed a desire in the population to have a good reform of politics and for a different form of political debate. I think there are very few people in this country who would seriously worry or be very antagonistic towards the idea of the Greens being in Parliament. I think people can see the benefit of having a third party there to have our perspective reinforced.”
But AD’s main hurdle in finally gaining that long-sought parliamentary seat is the political structures and institutions of the country, rather than winning over the electorate itself.
“Basically you have two parties that, in Oliver Friggieri’s words, are ‘totalising’. They have long histories and well-established networks of client-patron systems. Challenging that is huge. This goes without mentioning our exclusion from broadcasting, while they uniquely own television stations of their own.
“This country wants to be itself and instead it is being tied down to being two
people.”
AD’s strategy for combating the formidable machinery of the Nationalist and Labour parties is to firstly field candidates in each and every one of what can be considered as 13 individual elections comprising the general election, while fully matching the other parties’ machinery on the ground in a handful of districts.
But AD’s virtual exclusion from the mass media, particularly from the television airwaves, is something of a hindrance to delivering the party’s message to the masses. On the other hand, however, the exclusion could potentially backfire and work in AD’s favour.
“I think people are beginning to realise that the other parties exclude us as much as they can, and that is beginning to act in our favour because it is a bit of a giveaway.
“However, it would be much better if we could explain who we are, what we would like to achieve and how we can serve the people. But that takes time and we certainly aren’t afforded the air time to do that.”
Dr Vassallo does believe, however, that the party can match the others on the ground, on a one-to-one basis. He refers to AD’s experience in local council elections where, although the party deliberately holds back from fielding candidates in each and every contest, wary of devoting all its resources to the local council run, the exercise has been a valuable experience.
“In every local council election where we did door-to-door canvassing and where we met the people, and when we were able, in some cases, to get around a district two or three times, we’ve had superb results. Lija, for example, gave us some 19 per cent of the vote in a recent local council election.
“But in districts where we merely sent out leaflets, we have been in the region of two and three per cent. Our national result is likely to be at those levels simply because we do not have the clout to cover all the territory, but in one or two districts, and hopefully three or four, we will be able to realise our full potential. Then we will be able to have our media presence and be able to speak on a national level.”
In the lead-up to the last election, there had been a lot of talk about the possibility of AD forming a coalition with the PN, with AD’s intention being to secure Malta’s EU membership, which was hanging in the balance, given the MLP’s resistance to accession. A coalition was never formed but AD eventually still gave its backing to the PN. I ask Dr Vassallo about the difficulties of instilling a coalition mentality into what has essentially been a deeply polarised political scenario since independence.
“If one looks at the situation one can easily and immediately tell that we exist to make coalitions necessary, so we definitely have that mentality, while the other parties are still in a winner-takes-all way of thinking.
“The coalition did not happen in 2003 – when it should have because we had been pulling the same political rope for several years – because we would have been too great a threat to the Nationalist Party. As far as I’m concerned, the Nationalist Party put itself before EU membership in its refusal to form a coalition with us.
“A coalition in 2003 would have meant that everybody who was not Labour would have felt free to vote Green. I believe we would have made terrific inroads to that part of the electorate, and that was the Nationalist Party’s greatest fear.
“Had we formed a coalition, everybody could have given us a ‘one’ (vote) safely and they the (PN) surely did not want to give us that reward. In fact, they have refused to acknowledge our contribution to EU accession ever since, which is very petty and false.”
Despite having been a political fixture since 1992, AD still faces something of a challenge in that some circles still perceive the party as being a pressure group. But that erroneous perception extends beyond mere circles and even makes its way into the mainstream media. As an example, Dr Vassallo cites his recent appearance on PBS to discuss the budget, where the host introduced Dr Vassallo not once, but twice, as part of civil society.
“They are reinforcing the myth,” he comments. “True, we are not a political party like the others in that we are not an empire and we certainly are not a media empire – we are a different kind of party.
“Our biggest challenge is that we are taking on the whole winner-takes-all Anglo-Saxon political culture common to countries such as Britain, the United States, and Malta.
“This has been drummed into us despite the fact that our electoral system should provoke other results. Everything, however, has been fine-tuned and dedicated to producing a one-party government, which leads people to expect one-party governments.
“For instance, you mentioned that some people do not consider us to be a political party. People don’t consider us to be an alternative government either, because when they go to vote, many expect every party to present an entire shadow cabinet – a whole government that would constitute a one-party government on its own.
“It is very hard to put across the idea that we are dedicated to preventing that ever happening again.”
Dr Vassallo’s future, should AD not accomplish its goal, will most likely see him stepping back from AD’s helm but still remaining involved with the party.
“If we get one seat, I will probably stay on,” he predicts. “It’s about time that we did. I’ve been at this for a nice long time now, seven or eight years, and if we don’t pull it off I will be glad to make room for someone else and give them all the help I can.
“But what I am looking at is getting the Greens into Parliament, not for the Greens but for the whole country.”
If there is one area that is synonymous with Green ideology, it is the environment. How does Dr Vassallo see the country’s environmental issues being addressed by the government?
“The environment is a subject we hear a lot about from this government. But the people who should have the actual credit for what has been done so far are the ones who voted for EU accession.
“Without EU accession, this government would not be doing even half the things it is doing now. Not only because it wouldn’t have had the funding, but because this government clearly does not have the mindset to address environmental issues.
“In actual fact, although we hear them boasting about what is being done, it is very clear to people involved that this government’s efforts are being kept to an absolute minimum. We do what we can get away with under EU directives.”
The party’s rent reform drive appears to have fallen somewhat by the wayside, and I ask Dr Vassallo what has become of the campaign.
“We have changed method and we hope to be able to dedicate more energies and funds to the campaign in the near future. At the outset, we decided we would not invest our own funds in the project because there are certainly people who have an interest in such a reform and they should be able to invest something in it themselves.
“We did invest our own money and the results were not what we had hoped for. So if people expect us to make a very big splash in the media about the rent reform campaign and to take it on properly, they will also have to think about their side of the contribution, because we are not going to make it on our own.
“We will do the foot soldiering and the administration, but we certainly do not have the financial resources to dedicate to a single issue like this.”
As for the recent budget, AD has placed an emphasis on families and small businesses. In terms of the former, the party has suggested investing more in Malta’s children by allocating Lm6 million of the Lm12 million earmarked for tax cuts to tax deductions for families with children, which works out at about Lm100 per child.
The party would also like to see small businesses’ taxes being cut from the current 35 per cent to 30 – a tax break it proposes to offset by imposing higher taxes on banks, which have been making extraordinary profits of late.
He explains: “We would like to see structural changes in the budget and not one-off measures. This budget eases the pressure on licence fees for small businesses, which is not quite the same thing. We would like to see big corporations that enjoy near monopolistic situations, such as the banks, being given a higher tax rate of 40 per cent, which could be used to lower the tax rates for SMEs from 35 to 30 per cent.
“That’s not spectacular but it would make a big difference, especially if it were established as a trend. If we ever get to the point where Maltese SMEs have the same tax rate as Great Britain, of 19 per cent, this driving, innovative force of the economy could be truly stimulated.”
Gozo can be expected to be particularly featured in AD’s next electoral campaign. I ask Dr Vassallo for his opinion on the island, which is being faced with numerous development proposals.
“Gozo is a very special place,” he comments. “It has its own, extremely strong, identity and the Gozitans deserve better than what they have been getting. Unfortunately, it is not only a question of Gozo having been physically or financially neglected, which is evident, but it is also a question of the system by which it is governed.
“We have client-patron systems all over the country, but in Gozo they are terrific. This is asphyxiating the Gozitans’ great potential – they do have their different character, they are more capable of taking initiatives and they are also more resistant to bureaucratic hurdles. If this potential was to be released, and they are given more decision-making power with less political influence, they could make their island into a great showpiece for Malta.
“Gozo should be given more. It needs a plan and a framework into which the Gozitans can insert their own efforts. I think the biggest challenge right now is that there is no clear vision for Gozo, so nobody really knows whether to build on a Gozo that looks like Manhattan or a Gozo that is exploiting its natural heritage assets while also preserving them.”