The Malta Independent 19 November 2026, Thursday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Wednesday, 1 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 21 years ago

The Institute of Maltese Journalists’ (IGM) Press Ethics Commission said that, contrary to claims made by General Workers Union president Salv Sammut, NET TV journalist Nathaniel Attard had not breached journalistic ethics.

The commission said that it had received a complaint from Mr Sammut, saying that on 17 August a “voice on tape” comment he had given to Mr Attard had been aired during a news broadcast.

The complaint was based on Article 4 of the Code of Ethics, but Mr Sammut did not specify which part of the article applied to the case. Mr Sammut said he objected to being recorded while he was giving his comments.

Neither this nor other facts mentioned by Mr Sammut constituted a breach of the article mentioned, and therefore the commission turned down his request.

The commission also dealt with a second complaint against Mr Attard, this time by GWU media officer Charles Vella, who claimed that what he said during a telephone conversation on 30 August was broadcast without his knowledge. He also complained that the following day, an article containing quotes from the conversation, which was being recorded without his knowledge, had been published.

The complaint was based on Article 4 (b) which states that it is unethical to expose a source without permission.

The commission heard both Mr Vella and Mr Attard, and a recording of the telephone conversation. The commission concluded that Mr Attard had informed Mr Vella that he was recording the conversation, and therefore the second part of the complaint was unjustified.

On the first complaint – regarding the revealing of the source – the commission said: “It is perhaps true that Mr Attard did not get Mr Vella’s permission to quote him as a source… but Mr Attard could have assumed that this was not necessary because of Mr Vella’s position as GWU media and information officer” and therefore anything he said on union matters are part of his work.

Therefore, although the commission believes that, strictly speaking, it would have been better for Mr Attard to have told Mr Vella that he was going to quote him, the infringement was of a slight technical nature and did not deserve to be condemned.

  • don't miss