The estimates of the Education, Youth and Employment Ministry were passed in Parliament on Wednesday night, with the Malta Labour Party calling for a type of education that was more student-centred and the government insisting that it will continue building on the successes that have been achieved in the sector in recent years.
Carmelo Abela (MLP)
Malta Labour Party education spokesman Carmelo Abela said that the fact that the government was spending so much on education was a positive sign. Mr Abela pointed out, however, that various questions also needed to be asked.
He asked whether an analysis of the National Minimum Curriculum had been made. Mr Abela also had questions regarding the quality of education that was being given in schools.
He emphasised the need for student-centred education based on the students ability to learn, and asked if this was being monitored at primary education level. He also enquired about monitoring the removal of streaming in the fourth year of primary school, seeing that it still existed in the fifth and sixth years.
The Labour MP also asked whether the strategic plan was being monitored, and what was being done to minimise absenteeism in schools and combat illiteracy. He also wanted to know what was being done to minimise the north-south divide, affirming that people in the north tended to continue their studies while those in the south did not.
Mr Abela said the fact that many students are continuing their studies is a good sign but he added that there is still much to be done, especially when comparing the local situation with other countries, EU member states in particular.
The Labour MP asked the government to explain the type of support services intended for students and their families, such as school psychologists and counselling, and how these were to be put into practice.
He suggested there should be an evaluation of the situation with regard to the college system that is being set up and stressed that a Labour government would give due importance to both academic as well as vocational education.
The MP asked if the funds set aside for the Junior College are sufficient. While having more funds for research and innovation is a positive sign, he asked how these funds were to be spent.
Mr Abela also noted the Lm33,000 spent on reports regarding the revision of the Matsec system, which had led to no concrete result. However, he added that it is satisfactory for the party to know that students may now see the corrected examination paper.
Justyne Caruana (MLP)
The focal points of Labour MP Justyne Caruana’s comments were youth, employment and sport. Finding employment has become an unpleasant adventure for young people, she said, because of the limited opportunities they are faced with. This problem manifests itself in various others, like an increase in psychological problems and illnesses, and an increase in drug abuse. “We must help young people become good citizens with strong
values,” said Dr Caruana, MLP spokesman on youth, sport and culture.
Young people are given full attention in the MLP’s document plan specifically targeting this sector. Employment and the need for continuous training are emphasised in the document.
Part-time employment is on the increase, but that does not mean more choice for young people. Dr Caruana asserted that this was happening only because of a lack of employment opportunities, which leaves young people with no choice but to take up part-time jobs.
Young people are not being given their due importance, she said. Graduates, Gozitans in particular, are finding it hard to find employment. There is also the problem of “forced emigration”. “While I think emigration is a good thing, some young people emigrate because they have no alternative. This results in a brain drain,” she said.
The youth sector must be given priority. The MLP is therefore proposing the One Stop Shop, the primary aim of which is to give young people direct access to services. The party is also proposing a National Youth Centre that would host youth conferences and youth meetings.
Young people’s quality of life must be improved and their level of participation in society must be enhanced. Dr Caruana pointed out that this is a problem, particularly judging by the participation of young people in this year’s youth parliament coordinated by the National Youth Council.
Help must be offered to young people who lead or have led a criminal life, to reintegrate them into society.
With regard to sport, Dr Caruana remarked that it provides alternative entertainment to young people and offers a better life-style. “What happened to the government proposal for specialised schools?” she asked, as she pointed out that, unlike in other countries, unfortunately there are no professional athletes in Malta.
Sport is important for tourism yet not much has been done here, said Dr Caruana. The Rolex Middle Sea Race was the achievement of a dedicated few. Rugby is important for tourism, yet the national rugby team does not even have a pitch it can use for practice, she said.
Karl Chircop (MLP)
The MLP social protection spokesman, Karl Chircop, said that the situation regarding employment is far from positive. According to the Labour Force Survey provided by the NSO, he said, there has been only a marginal increase in the rate of employment and there has been an increase in the number of people economically inactive when compared to numbers in recent years. Even with regard to unemployment, the fall in the unemployment rate has been marginal, he added.
The figures are bad enough, but the details are more worrying, with 23,000 people depending on just a part-time job. The situation in Gozo is particularly alarming, he said.
Dr Chircop went on to ask what had happened to the proposed national employment plan. Great sums of money had been spent on the plan, yet it was never mentioned again.
He also referred to the MLP’s document about working conditions, saying it is a positive sign that some of the party’s initiatives and proposals had been taken up by the government.
David Agius (PN)
“We believe in education,” said Nationalist MP David Agius. The government has invested a lot of money on the sports sector. “We want an annual national sports congress and to involve everybody in order to complement the Malta Sports Council’s valuable work. We want a National Sports Day, the same way we have car-free day and a day for the environment,” he said.
Sport gives a sense of activity, said Mr Agius, an activity that must also be visible in the education sector. Much work is being done in this sector, which must be encouraged. In addition, the government, according to Mr Agius, is considering a proposal for the removal of VAT on areas used for training.
With regard to young people, participation has been numerous within the youth parliament, coordinated by the National Youth Council, he said.
Clyde Puli (PN)
Nationalist MP Clyde Puli said the government aims to provide families and workers with a good quality of life. This is why great emphasis has been placed upon employment.
Mr Puli pointed out the government’s three major priorities with regard to employment, namely a high rate of employment, employment of good quality and a good labour force.
The budget is aimed at generating employment and the government wants a workforce that feels it has enough incentives to work. “We are doing our best to invest in the employability of the individual,” Mr Puli said. He concluded his remarks by saying that the government believed in promoting education for all, starting from an early age.
Jason Azzopardi (PN)
Nationalist MP Jason Azzopardi said that the government has achieved much this year in the education sector. Three colleges (St Benedict, one in Cottonera and another in Gozo) had been opened and students attending these colleges are doing better and are achieving better results thanks to the government’s efforts, he said.
In addition, there has been an increase in the number of students sitting for their matriculation examinations, while the number of school leavers has fallen to 34 per cent. The number of people over 19 who choose to further their studies has also increased.
Dr Azzopardi said that various refurbishment programmes have taken or are taking place, such as those at Adelaide Cini School, Liceo Vassalli (Tal-Handaq) and Verdala.
Louis Galea (PN)
Education, Youth and Employment Minister Louis Galea said that education is crucial for the overall development of the country.
Dr Galea said he recognised that there is still a long way to go. There are still some sectors of society not involved in education and learning for life and this has negative consequences for them, their children and society. “We are aware of our challenges and our opportunities. We face them with enthusiasm and optimism,” he said.
There will always be room for criticism, Dr Galea said, because education depends on more than one factor, such as teachers and parents. Resources are needed at every level, especially if we are to reach the ambitious targets the government has set itself.
The ministry, he said, has made great investments in education. For example, Lm1.5 million had been allocated for the upgrading of laboratories in schools and the benefits of such investments are being reaped by young people. There has been a fall in employment in the public sector and an increase in employment in the private sector.
More than Lm14 million, the bulk of it EU funds, will be spent on the Junior College and University, said Dr Galea. In addition, the government will be embarking on a project whereby it would rent, rather than buy, computers by tender. Whoever wins the contract would upgrade the computers on a regular basis.
A master plan for MCAST was also being drawn up, so that new construction would satisfy future needs.
With reference to the National Minimum Curriculum, Dr Galea said that, after a lengthy analysis, results show that the curriculum has been recognised and has gained universal ownership – a product, he said, of dialogue. He also pointed out allegations that 80 per cent of the curriculum has not been implemented are false. On the contrary, 80 per cent has been implemented while 20 per cent has either not been implemented or has been, but not in an efficient way.
According to Dr Galea, there are two fields in which the government has not yet been successful – the method of class assessment and science coordination. Science coordination means having coordinated science rather than separating science subjects such as physics and chemistry from each other.
Answering Mr Abela’s question about evaluating the college system, Dr Galea affirmed that this was what he had intended. After consulting various professionals, however, he agreed that an evaluation at this stage would be too early.
A college system, added Dr Galea, encouraged a better system of learning. Furthermore, when educators unite, ideas increase and there is an improvement in government administration, all this to the benefit of the students.
In answering the “north-south division” question, the minister said that one must be careful when referring to “north” and “south”.