The Malta Independent 19 November 2026, Thursday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Thursday, 2 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 21 years ago

“Failure” was the term most commonly used by the opposition to describe the government’s budgetary performance in relation to tourism. The government, on the other hand, affirmed that even though tourism is going through a rough patch, the results and prospects are still positive.

Joseph Cuschieri (MLP)

Labour spokesperson for Air Malta and Hotels, Joseph Cuschieri announced that far from being a good year for tourism, as the minister had forecast in March, the result was a decrease of 12,000 tourists visiting the country. In addition, tourist spending in Malta decreased by 0.4 per cent when compared to last year.

There has been a decrease in tourists from Austria, France, Germany and Sweden, while the “biggest blow” has come from the United Kingdom.

“If this is not called a failure, I don’t know what it is called,” Mr Cuschieri said.

Mr Cuschieri went on to say that during his speech on Friday, the Prime Minister had said that his government is an ambitious one. These tourism statistics, however, are “ambitions of failure”, for which taxi drivers, bus drivers, waiters and barmen afterwards get the blame.

The Labour MP also pointed out that while the government said it will not impose taxes in the tourist sector, it has imposed the 18 per cent VAT and increased museum entrance fees.

The Prime Minister said the government’s actions must be judged on facts and not talk, said Mr Cuschieri. The facts are that the number of tourists is decreasing. He added the situation was very different when the opposition was in government between 1996 and 1998, wherein tourism increased by 13 per cent.

The number of hotels has decreased and the government’s incentives were only a gimmick because they have solved nothing, Mr Cuschieri said, adding that the Prime Minister must stop taking people for a ride.

According to the Labour spokesperson, there is much widespread concern about the situation among many hotel owners, NGOs and indeed, the MHRA itself. The Labour party, said Mr Cuschieri, is willing to help the government out of this crisis, an offer which has been rejected in the past. The national interest, declared Mr Cuschieri, demands a solution.

The MLP has sought to keep itself updated on this sector, said Mr Cuschieri, which is why the party outlined its document relating to tourism. The country cannot lag behind, but must keep apace by offering an attractive package, an endeavour which requires great discipline, he said.

Carmelo Abela (MLP)

“Culture belongs to everyone,” affirmed Mr Abela, Labour spokesperson for Education, Culture and Youth.

Mr Abela posed various questions regarding government initiatives related to culture. He said various cultural activities have taken off lately, Notte Bianca being one of them, and this was a positive sign. He asked whether a strategy for the culture sector existed and if so, what was the government actually doing?

Mr Abela also enquired about the National Orchestra which, he pointed out, is facing financial problems. He commented about the closing down of FM Bronja, the only radio station to focus on culture, and asked about the role of the media in relation to public service – or was it simply a question of business and money?

The MP asked whether there are any funds available to continue restoration of the Manoel Theatre and what commitment the government was taking to improve Carnival and make it a tourist attraction, with the Maltese profiting at the same time. He also asked about the future of the Royal Opera House site.

While commenting about St James Cavalier, Mr Abela pointed out something had to be done to make the establishment more attractive to families. “I had suggested the removal of VAT from tickets,” he added.

Mr Abela concluded by saying the country has much talent to offer and this must be manifested primarily in schools and through the expressive arts, because culture belongs to everyone.

Evarist Bartolo (MLP)

Labour Spokesperson for Tourism, Evarist Bartolo described the Gonzi administration as a “government of failed aims,” adding that it has not reached its aims because it has no plan for tourism.

“Good news is made public while the bad news is kept secret,” Dr Bartolo said, adding that tourism in neighbouring countries such as Greece, Spain and Italy has increased while it has decreased in Malta.

The Labour MP criticised the government for not producing a national plan which should have been done ages ago. He also pointed out that the proposals made by the Consultation Group for Tourism, which the government appointed, had already been made by the Labour Party but were not accepted.

The Labour Party believes there has to be a serious and effective strategy plan for tourism and the plan would involve Air Malta, which, the party believes, should remain Malta’s national airline.

National statistics show a decrease in the tourism sector and indeed, many three-star and four-star hotels have decided to close down for the winter.

At present, the Malta Tourism Authority (MTA) cannot operate professionally, Dr Bartolo claimed. It exists to repeat the government line, and competent individuals within the authority are not left to operate professionally, said the Labour spokesperson. The authority needs a sense of direction, as it currently suffers from intrinsic problems, such as unnecessary delays in correspondence. There is need for a new, committed board, Dr Bartolo said.

Most tourists come during summer to enjoy the sun and sea. Necessary measures must be taken to protect our bays and beaches, as well as our sea, the Labour MP added.

Dr Bartolo expressed great concern regarding tourism in Gozo. Tourist-related employment in Gozo, he said, is decreasing. In addition, there have been complaints related to lethargic conditions in Gozo.

Improvements need to be made in the tourist areas to the north and south of Malta, such as Bugibba, Mellieha and Wied il-Ghajn, stated Dr Bartolo. We need good services, especially considering changing market trends.

Dr Bartolo claimed that a Labour government would ensure taxes are used to make Malta more competitive. It would also make sure any decision taken would not negatively affect the tourism sector and Malta’s competitiveness.

The MLP in government would strive to improve the quality of products and services produced and use every opportunity to draw EU funds through the private sector. It would give tourism its due importance by introducing tourism studies in secondary and vocational schools.

Websites are a valuable tool for promoting Malta. The internet would facilitate positive and negative feedback, suggested the Labour MP, adding that this tool is not used to improve the quality of services offered.

More effort is needed to acquire new markets and attract tourists from countries such as the USA and Japan, Dr Bartolo said.

In conclusion, Dr Bartolo pointed out that we must review the way the world sees us and the way we see ourselves. Things will turn out for the worse if this is not done.

Robert Arrigo (PN)

The government has shown great commitment in allocating Lm15 million for tourism, said Mr Arrigo, Nationalist MP. In relation to the CNN advertisement, Mr Arrigo said that the whole matter has to be re-thought. While commenting about Brand Malta, he also said that its collapse is everybody’s responsibility, even if there were some people who were glad the project failed.

Unfortunately, said Mr Arrigo, we have lost our sense of giving a service with a smile, and even if the situation can be improved, we are too focused on exporting this destructive criticism. “There are solutions for the short and long term,” he added.

Mr Arrigo commented on a number of successful cleaning and landscaping projects. He also referred to the MTA, stating that the appointment of Mr Mifsud was a positive step as he comes from the private sector environment and knows his job.

With regard to language schools and host families, Mr Arrigo said that there is a big difference in payments and that it is a shame that while such schools have an association, families don’t.

Thanks to government efforts, the Maltese are now enjoying the benefits of low-cost airlines like Ryanair, said Mr Arrigo. However, why did things change only after low-cost airlines were introduced, he asked, adding that in this context, Air Malta has to be proactive.

Mr Arrigo added that there are various cruise liners sailing in the Mediterranean that Malta can use, but we must go to them.

The Nationalist MP also suggested the introduction of the bed-and-breakfast concept in Malta with the introduction of low-cost airlines, following its success in Sicily.

In his concluding remarks, Mr Arrigo hoped the number of tourists will rise in 2007 and was positive this will happen.

Francis Zammit Dimech (PN)

“It is true tourism is going through a difficult phase,” declared the minister. However, he hastily added, the Labour Party lacks credibility and objectivity when it claims that there has only been a decrease in tourism during the last two years.

In 2004, there was an increase of 3.4 per cent when compared to 2003 and there was an increase of 1.3 per cent in 2005 when compared to 2004.

The minister referred to the document produced by the MLP calling it an “updated document.” He further asked what plan and solutions the party offered for many problems.

Answering Mr Abela’s questions, Dr Zammit Dimech said the private sector should be involved in certain events as happened with the Jazz Festival. Carnival should become a major activity of art and culture to attract more people, Dr Zammit Dimech said. He added that the government’s plan for the Royal Opera House site was temporary roofing and for the site to be used for cultural purposes.

The minister also replied to Dr Bartolo’s remarks, stating it is not true the authority repeats the government’s line. On the contrary, it is the government which depends on the Authority for analysis. Dr Zammit Dimech also challenged the opposition to find solutions to problems such as EasyJet, giving a “precise formula and not beating about the bush.”

The CNN campaign was produced because CNN has broad viewership and it was the CNN European and North African regions which were contacted for the production of the campaign. With regard to host families, the minister replied that he had encouraged them to form their own association.

The minister also answered Mr Cuschieri, denying that any tax was introduced in the tourism sector. On the contrary, a special rate for hotel owners was introduced. The minister invited the opposition to make an analysis of the situation regarding tourism.

The minister added that according to the government’s estimates, Ryanair will bring 85,000 tourists throughout the year. Potential markets for the winter season are also being considered, among which is Scandinavia.

The government is taking its investment seriously, said the minister. The allocated money will mean investments in marketing and branding, enterprise, better services and Gozo.

According to Dr Zammit Dimech, EU funds will enable the government to upgrade the infrastructural, cultural, historical and tourism sectors as well as invest in Malta’s bays and beaches: all this to improve the quality of cultural products and tourism.

An extensive cleaning programme has been formulated before the summer period, beach cleaning being an example. The Environment Upgrade Community has been set up for this purpose.

Other investments made related to the tourism sector involve the environment, roads, transport and Gozo, said Dr Zammit Dimech. The government is especially committed to Gozo because of the island’s dependence on seasonal tourism. In fact, added the minister, future licenses will pay 75 per cent of the present rate.

The minister also spoke about the cultural sector. Various projects are under way to improve the Maritime Museum and Kola’s Mill in Gozo, among other projects. The pre-historic monuments at Hagar Qim and Mnajdra will be sheltered until 2008. Research would continue in the meantime, he said.

A creative programme is to be introduced at the St James Cavalier. Dr Zammit Dimech explained the high-quality programme will enable disadvantaged children to integrate themselves within the arts sector.

Reference was made to Notte Bianca, attended by 200,000 people. Notte Bianca involved 70 different activities and 500 artists with their crews, said the minister. The aim was to promote art and culture appreciation among the Maltese and appreciation of Malta’s baroque capital city. The minister affirmed that such an activity must be repeated.

Dr Zammit Dimech concluded by appealing to all citizens to appreciate Malta’s cultural value.

  • don't miss