The Malta Independent 19 November 2026, Thursday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Thursday, 2 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 21 years ago

In Minister Cristina’s words, the Social Solidarity portfolio is vast and covers a wide variety of issues. Yesterday’s debate touched on many of them – from IVF to rent reform to gender equality to social housing to underage drinking – with particular emphasis on the utilities surcharge.

Marie Louise Coleiro Preca (MLP)

The Labour spokesperson on social solidarity described budget 2007 as “disappointing” because, in spite of the government’s claim that the economy is back on track, there are sections in society which are not feeling any better.

She added that Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi’s statement lacks both ideology and vision, and does not take into consideration social stratification.

Ms Coleiro Preca reiterated that whole clusters of society were left out of the budget and said that the Social Solidarity Ministry can realistically gauge the progress which is claimed to have been achieved through economic growth.

She also cast doubts on whether the country is getting value for money for all that is spent. A case in point, she said, is that Sedqa drug prevention programmes are diminishing, while users are on the increase.

Labour’s Social Solidarity spokesperson harped on the point that the surcharge on water and electricity bills is penalising a lot of families. She accused the government of sustaining disgusting social practices (“porkerija socjali”) especially with regard to large families, minimum wage earners and the disabled.

Large families, said Ms Coleiro Preca, tend to consume more electricity, as do families which have disabled members. Although the disabled might not use specific medication machinery, they still tend to consume large amounts of electricity. The Labour MP accused government of not taking care of minimum wage earners, who were not included in any of the budget measures. She also raised doubts over whether those receiving a contributory pension will be eligible for free medical aid.

Ms Coleiro Preca accused the government of humiliating people by introducing a system whereby those who are exempt from paying surcharge are to present a voucher when paying their water and electricity bills. She said that the PN does not have a social conscience and is striving to bring the country back to the era of milk vouchers.

She called for a clarification of the criteria on which families are exempted and insisted that in the name of all those families, transparent criteria should be issued.

The Labour MP challenged the government to publish the National Family Commission recommendations, asking for more from-school-to-work transition programmes for the disabled, more consideration towards those whose primary job is part-time, and the rights of non-unionised workers. She also made fun of Dr Gonzi’s cost of living adjustment calculations.

Karl Chircop (MLP)

Dr Chircop said the budget penalises large families instead of helping them. He said that this argument is pertinent in the light of the country’s ageing society, and the decrease in fertility rate.

“The government should have increased children’s allowance and decreased surcharge for large families in a bid to encourage larger families”, he said, adding that from 1997 to date, the government reduced children’s allowance by Lm7 million.

He also discussed the issue of widows’ pensions, facetiously suggesting that widows/widowers who re-marry ought to remain married only for five years, because that is the time limit the government has imposed on the entitlement to the pension.

Helena Dalli (MLP)

The opposition MP said Prime Minister Gonzi devoted a lot of words to the role of women; however, the rate of female participation has only risen by 3.3 per cent since 1987’s 30 per cent.

She insisted that there are too few jobs created for women, and most of them are on a part-time basis. She added that “career opportunities for women are lacking, and are focused on lower-end jobs.” She also pointed out the high number of 20- to 30-year-old women who are unemployed. She called for a more balanced way of distributing decision-making jobs between the sexes.

Ms Dalli also justified the MLP poster depicting a chuckling Lawrence Gonzi, with the slogan: “He is laughing at you” (“Jidhak Bik”). She said the PN-led government is pulling wool over people’s eyes by saying that it produces tax-free budgets. She added that the population is now accustomed to the government’s way of introducing taxes throughout the year.

Joe Abela (MLP)

Mr Abela spoke about Adult Training Centres. He insisted that the centres’ employees should be informed about their future, once the centres are incorporated into the new structures. He said that some centres lack cleaners, while others are currently without heads or assistant heads. This is demoralising, said the Labour MP, especially to those who are expecting a promotion.

The Labour spokesman asked whether it is time to strike a balance between funds which are available to institutions, and those given to people who choose to tend to the elderly in their family. He said that with the present system, it is more worthwhile for families to institutionalise their elderly, rather than to keep them at home

Stefan Buontempo (MLP)

Dr Buontempo criticised Minister Dolores Cristina for voting Lm3 million in the 2006 budget to buy empty houses. He said that the government has not finalised a single promise of sale. He said the MLP had to be the process’s watchdog, but there was nothing to watch over. The Labour MP added that the amount voted was only enough to buy around 100 units, while currently there are around 30,000 empty units.

The Cottonera MP accused the government of ignoring the rent revision and of starting the amalgamation of the Department for Social Accommodation, the Department for Housing Construction and Maintenance to the Housing Authority only now, after it had been announced in September 2000.

David Agius (PN)

Mr Agius accused the MLP of not having a position on pensions and domestic violence. He had expected Helena Dalli to discuss domestic violence, and suggested that she forgot the argument as the opposition is too focused on Dubai and SmartCity.

The PN spokesman praised the Housing Authority and attributed the lack of funds voted to it to its ability to generate its own funds. He also praised the Department for Housing Construction and Maintenance for the work done throughout the year. He said that the department built 266 new units and conducted urban renewal projects on 99 units. He boasted about the lift installation programme, shared ownership scheme and the fact that the opposition could not criticise the government for being corrupt and nepotistic, since it is neither.

Clyde Puli (PN)

The Qormi MP appealed that since the country has a free health service, in vitro fertilisation (IVF) should also be granted gratis. He appealed also for the protection of the unborn children’s rights, especially in the light of IVF.

Mr Puli said that the PN is not dismantling the welfare state, as it accounts for half of government expenditure. He added that the PN’s vision is to help the integration of people and to promote empowerment rather than to a paternalistic way of doing things.

He was pleased that the opposition conceded that fuel prices have risen because of international pressures. However, he said, Dr Sant built up expectations with his promise to slash the surcharge by 40 to 50 per cent. He added that VAT on fuels is only paid by businesses which, in turn, benefit from a rebate.

Joe Cassar (PN)

Dr Cassar said that the “PN tree is yielding good fruit”. Praising Sedqa for its work against substance and gaming abuse, he spoke about the working group which has been commissioned to examine the problem of alcohol abuse among people who are under 16 years of age. The group, he said, is planning on meeting with the widest possible way with all groups that have a stake.

The PN spokesman also praised the Malta Social Work Profession Board which has awarded warrants to 156 social workers and which is working hard to improve the profession. He lauded the Ministry for setting up the Malta Psychology Profession Board in February 2005 which is regulating the profession.

Michael Gonzi (PN)

The PN spokesman said that while government had to make sacrifices to improve the country’s finances, the social budget was never reduced. Dr Gonzi spoke about the importance of the Commissioner for Children, who is working hard for awareness campaigns and is taking initiatives, such as obliging those who want to work with children to produce a clean criminal record. He added that the commissioner also liaised with the media to set up guidelines on how to produce children-friendly programmes and to stop child-exploiting adverts.

Dolores Cristina (PN)

The Family and Social Solidarity Minister said the MLP should not have been so negative about the budget as there were many positive points. She criticised those who spoke about social stratification, as the budget addressed the needs of everyone.

After showing her appreciation to all those working in her Ministry, Mrs Cristina said that her portfolio is vast and covers an array of issues, some of which are not visible to everyone. Now is the time to move from the concept of social services to social benefits, she said. “We are moving towards a culture of personalised services rather than a blanket payment to those who are in need.”

She added that the quality of life does not depend solely on the ministry, but also on investment, employment, education and health.

Ms Cristina reiterated that the budget was a positive one and that although there were things which could have been included, she said, it is not possible to do everything at once. The revised tax bands affected thousands of families, she said, adding that thanks to the revision of tax for those who send their children to independent schools, there are now more people who pay less.

Minister Cristina pointed out that no one from the opposition benches said anything about economic growth and deficit reduction, which as she explained, influence families. She also referred to an exercise carried out during the 22-month MLP government, where the price of one’s shopping basket rose by eight per cent, and that during the 1996-98 legislature, electricity bills were higher than today’s surcharge and all.

Mrs Cristina defended the voucher system, describing it as an administrative tool. She added that voucher holders are completely exempt from the surcharge. She added that the exemption is calculated upon the family’s consumption: the National Statistics Office (NSO) works out the average consumption of families, and this it is used as a benchmark.

She added that people who suffer from a medical condition, including the disabled, do not have a capping on consumption.

The minister said that rent reform proposals will be presented for discussion to cabinet, and that they have been drafted along the Spanish and Portuguese models. Pension reform will be tackled shortly, she said.

Ms Cristina defended the amalgamation process of the Department for Social Accommodation and the Department for Housing Construction and Maintenance and said that such processes should not be rushed.

  • don't miss