Industry, Investment and IT minister Austin Gatt told Parliament yesterday that he warned the chief negotiator of Tecom Investments that unless agreement is reached on the SmartCity project in the coming days, the government would pull out of the negotiations.
Speaking during the debate to approve the budget estimates for his ministry, Dr Gatt insisted the government would not sell Malta cheaply and that it was insisting on a number of points before signing the agreement with Tecom Investments.
“I wish however to make it amply clear that even if we wish very much for this project to materialise, we are not ready to do this at any cost. Its advantages, should it happen, are great indeed, but it must be clear that we will not pursue these advantages by submitting to any condition put down by the investors,” Dr Gatt said.
He added that the government had been discussing the project for seven months, and in its view, it is now time to reach a final decision.
“The points still separating us are few but crucial – and you can be sure that I will not reveal what they are. Anyone who would expect the Maltese government not to retire from discussions to avoid embarassment is mistaken.”
Dr Gatt added: “To ensure that such a mistaken impression does not persist, yesterday (Wednesday) I spoke to the principal negotiator for Tecom and warned him that we have now discussed the same things for far too long, and that if we do not reach an agreement in the coming days, the government will stop the discussions. We would do this with sadness, but you can rest assured that we would do this.”
The Minister was responding to questions raised earlier in the same debate by Opposition ICT spokesman, Leo Brincat.
Joe Mizzi (MLP)
Opening the debate yesterday morning, Labour MP Joe Mizzi said the budget lacked details of the government’s plans for the energy sector. He said the government did not have a clear strategy or a serious plan, and that its inability to take action in this sector was having a negative effect on the people and on the country.
He said that earlier this year, the Minister had said a plan existed and the government knew exactly the direction it was taking. Mr Mizzi said the government had opted for diesel generators while at the same time instructing Mepa to control emission levels in Malta.
The Labour MP said that a letter sent in March stated that diesel engines were not sufficient to meet emission levels and the switch to combined-cycle oil generators was a better option.
Turning to alternative energy, Mr Mizzi said the report from the Malta Resources Authority on the subject was heavily criticised. He said the government had no plans for the use of alternative energy in Malta.
“The government has said that we have not made any proposals on electricity generation but this is not true. We had proposed an offshore wind farm and that EU funds could be obtained to set up a link with Sicily which was also using its coastline for an offshore wind farm. Then the Prime Minister comes out saying that they were studying the feasibility of offshore wind farms,” Mr Mizzi said.
The Labour MP insisted on the need to tackle inefficiency both at Enemalta and at a consumer level. He said the public had to be educated to use energy efficient products and that helped to lower consumption. Mr Mizzi said that other countries had succeeded in improving their efficiency levels by 20 per cent. However, he said, the government’s only solution to its energy problems has been to impose a surcharge on water and electricity bills.
He said the industry and investments ministry was saying that the use of solar heater and photovoltaic panels to improve efficiency would have no effect on consumption. Mr Mizzi referred to news reports that quoted the Resources Minister as saying that, for every one per cent increase in efficiency, the cost saving would be Lm1.33 million.
“These are the facts. The Labour Party has been correct all along. We are capable of doing these things, and I will resign if we do not manage,” Mr Mizzi said.
With regard to the surcharge, Mr Mizzi said a Labour government would reduce the surcharge by 40 to 50 per cent. He said the party had come out with a proposal to cap taxation and VAT on oils and inefficiency costs.
Taking the government’s method of calculating the surcharge, Mr Mizzi said that with the latest reduction in the price of oil, the surcharge should go down to 51 per cent and not 59 per cent.
Chris Agius (MLP)
Labour MP Chris Agius said that despite the rhetoric that the country’s finances were in good shape, the government continued increasing the burden on families through taxation.
So much so, he said, that government planned to increase its revenue from taxation by Lm50 million next year. He said that a look at the figures will reveal that government revenue has been on the increase since 1999, with the tax burden increasing by 67 per cent.
He said local industry was feeling the pinch and that these burdens were having a negative impact on the sector’s competitiveness: “The surcharge should have been cut more. Industry is facing difficulties and the government should have given this sector a breather.”
While acknowledging that local industry was no longer focusing on low-wages companies and that Malta had shifted to value-added industries, Mr Agius lamented that there were not enough people with the proper skills to take up the jobs that were being created.
He said that although the government had taken the initiative to positively discriminate in favour of those taking science and IT courses, more incentives were needed.
Leo Brincat (MLP)
The Opposition spokesman on ICT, Leo Brincat, picked on the government’s budget for 2006 to highlight the government’s unfulfilled promises. He mentioned the career space framework, the e-learning national gateway, the outsourcing of PC support to the private sector, the new generation of government portal, as well as the Lm4 million promised in incentives for the sector.
Turning to this year’s budget, Mr Brincat said the Lm100 million investment in SmartCity had still not materialised in the government’s coffers, and he asked what was happening.
With regard to Labour’s policy document on ICT, Mr Brincat said the party was very careful not to approach the sector in a partisan manner, but the government still saw good reason to criticise everything Labour was suggesting. Mr Brincat said the document had received very good feedback from all the stakeholders and he insisted that Labour would continue what was already achieved and improve on those areas that needed improvement.
This document shows that “we do not only criticise constructively but we consider ICT to be the pivotal point of the national agenda”.
Joe Debono Grech (MLP)
Labour MP Joe Debono Grech launched a tirade against Malta International Airport and the government over what he termed as promotions and appointments being given to appease the Nationalist Party’s “friends of friends”.
He said these things did not happen by coincidence, and that a Labour government would ensure the right of those employed at MIA would be safeguarded when in government.
Joseph Cuschieri (MLP)
Speaking about the national airline, Labour MP Joseph Cuschieri said that Air Malta was an important contributor to the economy and that its employees had made a lot of sacrifices as part of the ongoing restructuring exercise.
He asked the government to define its strategy for the airline, asking how it is disposing of the RJ aircraft.
Mr Cuschieri asked the government what was going to happen when the period of the rescue plan came to an end.
Turning to low cost airlines, Mr Cushieri said he hoped their presence would not have a negative impact on long standing airlines operating to Malta.
John Dalli (PN)
Replying for the government, Nationalist MP John Dalli said the Labour party was starting to speak positively about certain sectors, especially the need to reach consensus on the ICT strategy for Malta.
Mr Dalli said that Parliament needed to collaborate more and “see how together we can reach consensus and start to move with the same momentum that other countries have done. The country does not have time to lose”.
The former finance minister spoke about the workings of the surcharge and the issue of hedging, and why it was important that people realise that the price of oil is dictated by the international market, and how much the commodity really costs.
Austin Gatt (PN)
Minister Austin Gatt closed the debate yesterday by focusing on the entities under his responsibility, investment and IT.
He started off by replying to Mr Mizzi’s statements on energy generation and insisted that the problem with alternative energy was the cost involved and the little effect on consumption.
With regard to the suggestion that combined cycle systems were more efficient, Dr Gatt said this was true; however, Mr Mizzi had failed to point out that gas oil was 12 per cent more expensive than fuel oil.
“Yes, efficiency is higher but gas oil is much more expensive. From a financial point of view, we will gain nothing,” Dr Gatt said.
Dr Gatt said a review of the entities falling under his ministry showed the overall a lot of progress had been registered. Turnover had increased and losses had been considerably reduced.
Turning to the Drydocks, the minister said the yard has diversified its work, moving from ship repair to conversions and super yachts. He said turnover had increased to Lm24 million this year and the losses were down to Lm7 million. The government’s target, he said, was to cut losses to Lm2 million by 2008 and profitability the year after.
He insisted that the government could no longer step in if things went wrong. Dr Gatt insisted that productivity had to improve if the yard wanted to safeguard its workers’ salaries. Higher production levels could have reduced the losses to only Lm1 million and not Lm7 million.
With regard to Air Malta, Dr Gatt said the rescue plan had been a success and the company had reduced its overheads by Lm11 million. He insisted that salaries had not been touched but only overtime.
He said Labour was asking him for guarantees that workers would not lose their jobs after the rescue plan came to an end. “Why don’t you give the employees at Air Malta guarantees that if you are in government they won’t risk losing their job?” Dr Gatt told the Opposition.
Turning to the surcharge, Dr Gatt said the Labour Party had finally come around to understanding that the price of oil goes up and down and that energy bills reflected this fact.
He said that bills today, even with the 63.5 per cent surcharge, were still lower than the bills Alfred Sant started charging in 1997. Only when the surcharge is 72 per cent will we be paying more, Dr Gatt said.
The minister tore into the Labour Party’s proposal to cut the surcharge by 40 to 50 per cent, pointing out that the Opposition did not say where it was going to get the Lm23 million from to “fund” the 50 per cent decrease.
Turning to investment, Dr Gatt said the government had attracted to Malta, Lm1 million in investment every day. Maltese Enterprise had given its approval to 246 companies for a total investment of Lm171 million. He said the Labour Party had to change its approach to investment and concentrate on the country’s interests instead of criticising Malta’s human resources.
The minister said the government’s ICT strategy aims to turn Malta into a centre of ICT excellence in the Mediterranean, and “we have achieved it”.
Replying to criticism that the negotiations on SmartCity were taking so long, Dr Gatt said these projects took time to be completed and the government would not rush into things.
“One must always keep in mind that a project of this magnitude requires enormous attention to the details of how all the obligations of both parties will be executed. This is why discussions go beyond the standard negotiations on a contract on land.
“Everone needs to understand that the government is weakened in any negotiations that are supposed to meet public expectations, or where targets are patterned on wishful thinking, not on reality. Serious negotiations are not conducted in this way, if we are to obtain good conditions and negotiations cannot be done in public unless we want to give up our weapons by the first meeting.
“I have had the opportunity to speak on other occasions both in this chamber and outside it, on how the attitude of the Labour Party is beyond any doubt not helping in this delicate stage. The clear – and occasionally aggressive – opposition to the project is beyond any doubt conditioning the environment of the negotiations, particularly because this is not a project that will last two, five or 10 years, but is a very long term project.”
Dr Gatt said the government was committed to improving the level of education in ICT and to boosting internet access at all levels.
“This is a country that can do a lot and has already done a great deal. In 2000, few believed in my idea, but six years later we showed everyone it was possible. We must not get mired in old practices and attitudes,” Dr Gatt said.