The Malta Independent 19 November 2026, Thursday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Friday, 3 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 21 years ago

A comprehensive education on sexuality in the form of ABCD – Abstinence, Be faithful, Condomise and Don’t do drugs – may very well instil responsibility, but many still argue that the “condomise” aspect of it should not be encouraged. Some believe it may encourage earlier sexual activity, so it should be excluded completely. However, there is much more to ABCD than condomisation, Francesca Vella finds.

Maltese society’s level of sexuality education

A recent Eurobarometer survey revealed that the Maltese are among the most misinformed Europeans with regard to the contraction of AIDS (Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome) – one of the deadliest pandemics of all time.

AIDS has claimed more than 25 million lives worldwide since the first cases were reported in 1981. And yet the survey revealed around 14 per cent of Maltese people are unaware that HIV/AIDS can be contracted by having unprotected sex. To add insult to injury, around nine per cent are certain AIDS cannot be transmitted through unprotected sex.

On the other hand, the findings also show that some 17 per cent of the Maltese think it possible that a handshake may be enough to contract AIDS.

Clearly, becoming knowledgeable about HIV/AIDS is not the be-all and end-all of sex education, but since AIDS is probably the best known of all STDs, the Eurobarometer survey definitely reflects a lot about the general level of Maltese society’s sexuality education.

People are still confused about sexuality in general, and particularly about sexual health. It is probable that the country is still overcoming taboos related to pre-marital sex, teenage sex, contraception, homosexuality, bisexuality and the like.

Research is “showing” society the crude realities that might have existed for many years – that school-age children have become more sexually active and that teenage pregnancies and the prevalence of STDs are constantly increasing.

Admittedly the research is open to debate on another front: are figures really increasing, or are we simply becoming a more open society? One thing, however, is certain: we cannot remain passive when faced with such figures.

What is happening in schools?

It is clear that differences exist in specific aspects of sexuality education in public private and church schools. The national minimum criteria on personal and social development (BSD), established by the Education Division do exist, but it is ultimately up to every head of school to decide upon ways of educating children and young people on their sexual behaviour and sexual health.

State schools are arguably better regulated through the Division. When it comes to private schools, the management and the Curia respectively may decide to censor certain information on sexuality education, or at least divulge it in a less “liberal” manner.

Four specific specialised teachers who are employed to teach Personal and Social Development (PSD) in state schools, are also available on a twice-weekly basis to carry out sessions on Sexuality and Relationships Education (SRE) in different schools.

Two of them go to government primary schools and work with parents and teachers, while the other two go to secondary schools – at this stage they also carry out work with students.

“We teach about issues of sexual health and we do not simply inform students about the sexual act. In no way do we encourage it, but rather we pose reflective questions. Instilling a sense of responsibility among students is our ultimate aim,” explained Sylvana Zammit Pulo, one of the four PSD teachers.

SRE empowers students with information to help them make informed choices. SRE forms part of the whole PSD syllabus, so every school, state or otherwise, is meant to go into it, but the extent to which each school does so may well be very different.

SRE was established four years ago as part of a continued effort to address National Minimum Curriculum objectives and local concern for the need of more in-depth and comprehensive sexuality education for students.

SRE aims at empowering children, young people, as well as adults, to view sexuality and relationships with a positive and open attitude.

As things currently stand, however, it is clear that human resources are very limited. Ms Zammit Pulo explained that for this reason, their system of team teaching also works by means of follow-ups and creating a sense of continuity through close collaboration with PSD teachers.

She said parents generally react positively and a number of tools are offered for parents to help them and their children develop a healthy attitude towards sexuality.

Ms Zammit Pulo explained that the PSD process in secondary schools is gradual. PSD first introduces sessions on relationships, values and decisions. Later students are introduced to the reproductive system and the differences between female and male bodies.

While students are taught about their sexual health in primary schools, information about STDs and contraception come about when students are around thirteen years old, but if certain issues are raised in class they are tackled at any age.

GU clinic alone, bacteria attack and no national sexual health policy

At present, the real situation with regard to the number of cases of STDs in Malta remains unknown.

Although by law, anyone who diagnoses an STD is meant to notify the Health Department, it is practically the genitourinary (GU) clinic alone that contributes to statistics of such cases – in no way can these be accurate, however, since not every infected person necessarily visits the clinic.

Even the Disease Surveillance Unit (DSU), which received notifications of infectious diseases, including STDs, told this newspaper that most cases of STDs are reported to the unit by Dr Philip Carabot at the GU clinic.

The unit investigates all cases reported and takes necessary action, which would involve contacting the doctor reporting the case and then the patients themselves in order to trace any contacts and carry out the relevant tests and referral for treatment if necessary.

Although sexuality education in schools is not the remit of the DSU, the unit carries out a different kind of sex education among certain sections of the public, since the unit’s aim is to trace contacts, test them and give them the relevant information. Surveillance also helps health officials at the unit to monitor any outbreaks and to try tracing the source so that it can be contained.

Dr Carabot expressed concern over the local situation and said that people underestimate the effect of STDs.

“This year in particular for example, there has been an increase in the number of people suffering from gonorrhoea. The bacteria have become highly resistant to common antibiotics we prescribe so it’s a constant battle,” he said.

“We’ve also confirmed and we are now 100 per cent sure that HIV is prevalent among drug users – and yet people are still misinformed on HIV transmission,” Dr Carabot said, adding that another consistent problem he comes across is that only a very small minority of people who visit the clinic ever use condoms.

“While more than 70 per cent never use condoms, some 50 per cent who visit us have sex casually,” he said.

Dr Carabot explained that in a similar way to what is happening elsewhere in Europe, despite intensified sexuality education programmes, trends in sexual behaviour show no shift whatsoever.

He therefore proposed campaigns tailored to people with differing sexualities; rather than failing to accept the fact that not everyone is heterosexual, different campaigns need to target different people – people coming from different backgrounds, homosexuals, drug users, bisexuals and so many more people who engage in different types of sexual activity.

“Parents play a vital role in their children’s sex education. When they’re actively involved, the success rate is much higher. Teachers alone aren’t expected to do miracles,” Dr Carabot said.

In the GU clinic’s 2005 report, Dr Carabot pointed out that the national sexual health policy should be re-written under the chairmanship of a world-recognised expert on the subject.

Unfortunately, this policy has been in the pipeline for the past six years and nothing seems to have been done about it. Moreover, also by means of the clinic’s annual report, Dr Carabot called for urgent national studies on the prevalence of the major STDs (HIV and Chlamydia in particular), since one cannot plan any sensible policies without this basic information.

10-year-olds should learn about contraceptives – report

A report by the Institute for Public Policy Research says lessons about condoms and other contraception should be mandatory during the last year of primary school in England and Wales, www.metro.co.uk reported recently.

The report, which will be published in full next month, also says condoms should be available to secondary school-age pupils at sports centres, schools and colleges.

Britain’s pregnancy rate is the highest in Europe and the report suggests earlier sex education as a way of addressing this problem and to reduce the spread of STDs.

The suggestions were immediately deemed “reckless and irresponsible” by Colin Hart, director of the Christian Institute (UK), who said they would encourage earlier sexual activity among young people.

“It is part of a failed strategy which has been going on for years, having increasingly explicit sex education at even younger ages. It is one reason why we are in the mess we are in,” www.metro.co.uk reported him as saying.

On the other hand, Julia Margo, the report’s chief author said the evidence suggests that talking to children about sex at a younger age equips them with the knowledge they need in order to make judicious decisions when they are older.

“The key is to get to children before they are even remotely thinking about engaging in sex.” She was quoted as saying that parents would choose whether their children took part in the classes.

From a Maltese mother’s perspective

A mother who spoke to The Malta Independent, but who preferred not to be named, said children tend to ask many questions from a very early age, so it is important that their questions about sex and sexuality are answered truthfully.

She said that while it is positive that her children – who attend a private school – receive formal education on sexuality during the last year of primary schooling, with separate sessions being held for girls and boys, she said it would be more useful if parents were made aware of what is being imparted to their children.

“In this way parents might be able to help out if their children still have some questions which they might be too embarrassed to ask,” she said, adding that seminars for parents would be very helpful.

When asked about children being provided with information about contraceptives at a pre-secondary school age, she replied that it would probably bother her if the use of condoms is presented as the first and foremost method of contraception and prevention of STDs.

“I think I would like teachers to put forward the idea that abstinence is actually the safest way and also to present the concept that sexual intercourse is an expression of love and intimacy within a stable relationship,” she said.

She added, however, that she would want her children to be informed about the use of condoms and other methods of contraception, but probably not in the very first years of senior school.

‘Stop AIDS. Keep the Promise.’

The Malta Medical Students Association (MMSA) is one of the very few entities in Malta that has commemorated World AIDS Day (WAD) during the past few years . It has done so by means of help and funding from the GU clinic.

This year however, the Health Promotion Department will also be campaigning on HIV/AIDS prevention and young people will be the main target of the campaign, health promotion officer (sexual health) Elaine Dutton told The Malta Independent.

“Recent studies have shown that sexual activity among young people, particularly schoolboys, has increased drastically.

By means of this campaign we want to attempt to address this issue, although we understand that we are attempting to only partly solve problems related to sexual health and sexual behaviour,” Ms Dutton said.

When asked about the campaign methods, Ms Dutton explained that material and information for guidance teachers is being prepared, and a poster has been designed to target secondary school students in particular.

She stopped short of giving further details however, since the department is still in the planning stage and is carrying out talks, particularly with the Curia, with regard to the content of the campaign.

World AIDS Day is celebrated on 1 December and this year’s slogan, ‘Stop AIDS. Keep the Promise’, is in keeping with the theme of accountability.

This year marks the 25th anniversary of the first reported cases of AIDS. As such, the theme stresses the critical need to meet current commitments to increase the global response to AIDS and reach universal access to treatment, care, and prevention by 2010.

Currently, governments are supposed to be engaged in a target-setting process for universal access, called for in a political declaration unanimously approved by the United Nations General Assembly on 2 June.

While the situation in Malta with regard to accountability to stop AIDS remains highly questionable, the lack of a national sexual health policy, coupled with serious levels of misinformation, poses serious doubts as to how society wants to accept the realities of more sexual activity among the young. It’s a reality, so let’s face it. Is sex still taboo? Is the Church going to continue being so influential and totally censure the use of condoms and other contraception?

We do not live in isolation. If people are not well-informed about the consequences of unprotected casual sex in particular, then the world is going to throw frightening figures right at Maltese society.

  • don't miss