In a heated debate on Wednesday evening, Parliament discussed the general financial estimates for 2007 in the health, elderly and community care sector. A division was called, and despite a general ruckus in the House, the estimates were eventually approved with 32 votes in favour and 28 against
Silvio Parnis (MLP)
Labour MP Silvio Parnis, opening the debate on Wednesday evening, made constructive critical comments regarding the budget allocation for the elderly, stating that it provided benefits, yet was devoid of particular attention to certain critical issues.
Making reference to the surcharge and the increased cost of living, Mr Parnis drew attention to the fact that the elderly were paying their bills using their pensions; a situation, he said, that will be reviewed by the MLP when in government.
Mr Parnis questioned why the government will stop providing medication for cholesterol, Eskol and Statins, for persons over 75, when it has been proved, as many authorities claim, that these drugs are still beneficial for those beyond that age.
Elaborating on St Vincent de Paule, Parnis praised the Lm3 million expenditure on the Mother Theresa Complex, accommodating 180 elderly women. It is time, however, that this amount of money is allocated more appropriately.
The Labour spokesperson for the elderly complained about the hospital’s management, control and structure, saying they were inadequate, particularly when it rains. He also made reference to the food and laundry service, which leaves much room for improvement.
“It is time there was more seriousness and transparency in this sector,” Parnis concluded, saying that the MLP would shortly present a document on the elderly, that will be worked upon when Labour is in government, continuing to build upon the good that has been done.
Michael Farrugia (MLP)
Michael Farrugia, Labour’s main spokesperson on health, took up the St Vincent de Paule residence theme, voicing major concerns about employees being unable to undertake research or further specialisation, due to the residence being understaffed. This is also the reason why nurses find it difficult to take leave, he said. The budget allocation for salaries and wages for 2007 does not help the situation either, as it has not been increased. “Does it mean that staff is going to decrease?” he asked.
Farrugia went on to criticise the problem of medicines running out of stock, particularly at the St Luke’s pharmacy, saying he was concerned the new budget estimates would limit the importation of medicines.
Making reference to the registration of medicines, the Labour spokesperson said the current system resulted in numerous medicines being made unavailable. He suggested that by adopting the system of importing medicines already registered in another EU Country, Malta would decrease expenditure on dossiers and registration, and medicine prices would likewise drop, bringing the country in line with other EU member-states.
In his intervention, Mr Farrugia emphasised the need for more and better health education. Rising numbers in obesity in children, underage smoking and drinking, sexual activity among students, abortion and teenage pregnancies, as well as HIV cases, were worrying factors. Education needs to be realistic and equated with today’s days and times, he said, stressing that law is not the only solution.
Farrugia also mentioned the impending need for better health centres, more attention being paid to public health, as well as health and safety. He further questioned the state of the Addolorata Cemetery, the state of the promised residence in Mellieha, the “Mater Dei Saga”, the situation regarding the Eskol and Statins medication, as well as enquiring what the government is doing to decrease waiting lists in several hospital departments, now that the PM has suddenly realised that this is a problem.
The Labour MP concluded by offering hope to all Maltese and Gozitans, stating that the MLP’s document on health will offer a more transparent and just system, improving patients’ rights to better conditions and medicines.
Joseph Cassar (PN)
Nationalist MP Joseph Cassar, focused his intervention on mental health, expressing his disappointment that the Opposition had failed to comment on the issue, not even in its document on health.
Much has been done in this sector, Cassar said, citing as an example the Monte Carmeli Hostel Project, where a female ward for acute mental problems has been set up, and the services that are being provided in the community.
Cassar elaborated upon the expenditure undertaken for the Occupational Therapy Department at Monte Carmeli, stating that this provided a state of the art workspace for patients to explore their talents. He also mentioned the Transfer Centre at St. Luke’s, which is proving quite popular with patients and is managing to alleviate the taboo Monte Carmeli has acquired.
Helen D’Amato (PN)
Parliamentary Secretary for the elderly and community care, Helen D’Amato, began her intervention by primarily thanking all those in the health and community care sector, particularly those who had prepared Silvio Parnis’ speech. She failed to see why the opposition is criticising the government for forgetting the elderly, when in reality it is they who have forgotten, none of the speakers having said anything about the MLP’s own plan for the elderly.
She continued by highlighting areas within the whole budget document which positively affect the elderly. She mentioned the revision of tax bands, supplementary aid, the 17,000 families who will benefit from subsidies on the surcharge, the efforts in education on elderly care, such as those in MCAST and ETC, and the developments in the environment, infrastructure and roads, that will all aid in helping the elderly.
D’Amato also highlighted community initiative that enjoy a high rate of use among the public: Tele-care, the telephone rebate, Home Help, Meals on Wheels, the handyman service – all these are a clear indication that the elderly appreciate what is being done and want it to continue, she said.
Answering Mr Farrugia’s question regarding the Mellieha residence, D’Amato assured that it will be built, starting next year. She concluded by emphasising that, “We are not money hoarders or pick-pockets,” and that the government will continue to improve and work upon this sector.
Louis Deguara (PN)
Health Minister Louis Deguara said the budget for 2007 was a good one, because the government moved in a sustainable manner. He highlighted various challenges the Ministry of Health will be facing this coming year, the most imminent being the migration of patients and staff from St Luke’s to Mater Dei. In connection to this, he mentioned the fact that staff had already been taken twice to the new hospital to orient themselves with the facilities. This will be done a third time, he said, and all are eager to start their jobs, he added. He also mentioned that the Acute Admission Ward was opened on Wednesday at Mater Dei, and the first five patients had already been admitted.
Answering a question put to him by Labour’s main spokesperson, Michael Farrugia, regarding the brain drain in doctors and nurses, Deguara said doctors are leaving for reasons related to remuneration, just like elsewhere in the world, and not because of EU prospects. To counteract this, there is a need for further training and specialisation on the islands, he said, even though the number of doctors graduating exceed those who are leaving. With regard to nurses, brain drain is definitely not a problem, he continued.
On the subject of waiting lists, Dr Deguara stated that the government is working upon the problem, but further and better cooperation from doctors and consultants is required, so as to alleviate the strain on patients and the hospital itself.
Speaking about the price of medicines, the minister said a mechanism to regulate the prices will be installed; however, he said, medicine registration was needed so as to ensure that all medicines in Malta are state of the art.
Regarding the Eskol and Statins medication for the elderly, Dr Deguara said the government has looked into the whole issue, and upon advice given by the World Health Organisation will now continue providing it to people over the age of 75, meaning that there will be an increase of 63,000 beneficiaries in addition to those already on the medication.
Deguara wound up the debate, by stating that the challenges being faced by the government in the health sector will best be met if all MPs work together.