The government is investing Lm47 million in the environment and rural development, Minister George Pullicino told parliament yesterday morning.
Speaking during the debate to approve the vote for his ministry, Mr Pullicino gave a detailed account of what the government was doing in this sector, arguing that farmers, livestock breeders and fisherman were better off now.
Roderick Galdes
Kicking off the debate, Labour MP Roderick Galdes said the Nationalist government had made so many promises over the past two years but very few had materialised. He said the projects made a lot of sense, sounded very good in a budget speech but were useless if they simply remained words on a piece of paper.
Projects dealing with waste treatment, sewage treatment, biodiversity, alternative energy sources and a golf course in Gozo had not materialised, he said. That said a lot about the government’s performance with regard to the environment and rural affairs, Mr Galdes said.
He criticised the government for trying to hoodwink the people of Marsascala by proposing a family park in the town. He also criticised the government for saying a lot about storm water management and he asked why the village of Qormi had been neglected.
Mr Galdes said the government’s changes to local plans had resulted in negative repercussions on people and he said the government was not interested in having a national agenda.
The local plans, he said, had been finalised four years ago but now they had been totally changed by the government. “You are playing with people’s investments,” he claimed.
The Labour MP said the government had turned the Malta Environment and Planning Authority into a top-heavy institution with lots of government interference: “The reforms at Mepa are hilarious and you have turned it into a political football”.
Mr Galdes said the government had made a U-turn on waste management and that while it had criticised the Labour Party for suggesting the construction of more than one waste treatment plant, it was now doing exactly that.
“Why the change in strategy? The government is proving that Labour was right all along, that we have the best updated policy,” Mr Galdes said.
On the hunting and trapping issue, the Labour MP said the government had got itself tangled in a web of its own making, and it did not have the will to fulfil its promises.
Turning to the proposed animal welfare centre, he said not enough money was being voted for this project and he asked whether the government was actually doing anything about it.
Mr Galdes said the budget for 2007 does not reflect the country’s realities and the environment was suffering.
Noel Farrugia
Labour MP Noel Farrugia said people were starting to realise that the Labour Party had the best vision for the sector because it was more creative and positive in its approach to dealing with the needs of farmers, producers and fishermen.
He said the government claimed that the MLP knew nothing about the sector and that it was giving so much money to help farmers and fisherman. However, Mr Farrugia said, the story was totally different.
Taking a look at the income figures for all various areas that make up agriculture, Mr Farrugia said farmers, fishermen, poultry producers, pig breeders and others had suffered greatly over the past two years. Farmers were not better off, he said, contrary to what the government was stating.
The government is not performing in this sector, he said, adding: “We must not forget that agriculture is the provider for the food and beverage sector.”
Mr Farrugia said the Labour Party was not only credible but its vision for the sector has been carefully planned and was totally in line with the framework of measures in the new EU rural regulations.
“All our efforts are built on what the EU is proposing for this important sector. Our vision has always inspired hope and I hope that my criticisms and suggestions will lead to positive changes,” he said.
Joe Brincat
Labour MP Joe Brincat dwelt at length on the memo sent to the police instructing them not to take action against those breaking certain hunting law or regulations. He said this was of concern because the law applied to everyone and no one could just tell the police not to do anything.
He said this was sending a bad message and that only in certain cases could the police be told who to arraign and not to arraign.
Dr Brincat said that just because these individuals would not be arraigned for committing a crime, that did not mean that they could not face charges within the time-barred period which was two years. “They can still be notified before the end of those two years and they will still be held responsible,” Dr Brincat said. Reiterating that no one has the power to play around with the law, he called on the minister to explain what the government’s position on the matter is. Dr Brincat also criticised the government for bypassing parliament and allowing Mepa to invent a formula that pending applications could be considered approved if it was clear that a positive decision would have been taken.
He said this was incorrect and the government should have taken the issue to parliament and introduced a transitory clause to deal with these pending cases.
In so doing, he said, the laws passed by parliament were being used like chewing gum. He called on the minister responsible to look into the matter and to “use an amendment instead of hiding behind a screen”. With regard to the announcement on the animal hospital, he asked whether Lm60,000 was enough to offer a decent service. “Will owners have to pay or not?” he asked, adding that if they did, they should expect a good service round the clock.
Dr Brincat said he hoped the proposed animal hospital would not turn out to be another Mater Dei, taking years to be built.
Concluding, he said he was pleased to note that plans for the development of the golf course appear to have been shelved and that it did not make sense to turn land that was being cultivated for food into a golf course.
Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando
Nationalist MP Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando said he was surprised that Labour MP Roderick Galdes had stated that the projects announced by the government were not being implemented. He said that some just could not be completed overnight.
With regard to the recycling plant in Marsascala, he said that even Dr Alfred Sant agreed that the plant had to be modernised, and thus, Mr Pullicino Orlando asked Mr Galdes, “you want to criticise us for wanting to upgrade it?” He said the family park was aimed at embellishing the area and turning a tract of land that is presently being used as a dump.
Mr Pullicino Orlando said the government was making full use of EU funding, funds that became available after Malta became a member of the European Union.
“Had we not become members, from where would we have got all the funds to get things done? If we have taken your (Labour’s) idea of partnership, we would received nothing and done nothing.”
He said the proposed animal welfare centre was a positive development and called on Labour to acknowledge this.
Joe Falzon
Nationalist PM Joe Falzon said the subject matter was of national importance and therefore had to be treated in a balanced and objective way.
He said that thanks to EU funding, the government was in a position to carry out many projects that would help the environment. Mr Falzon insisted on the need to achieve sustainable development and to encourage people to take a greater role in environmental matters.
Frans Agius
Parliamentary Secretary Frans Agius said the Labour spokesman had failed to refer to numerous items in his critique of the government’s work on the environment and rural development.
He said the budget gives direction to the sector and thanks to fresh investment, farmers, producers and fishermen are now better off. Dr Agius said the government was addressing areas of particular importance in the sector, especially education. He criticised Labour for telling farmers that a safeguard clause would protect farmers when the EU made it very clear that this would not happen.
Dr Agius said the government was revising its strategic plan for the coming seven-year period and support for Malta would be e100 million, of which e80 would come from EU funds. He said the plan focused on four areas: increasing the sector’s competitiveness, providing a better environment, a better quality of life in rural areas and the setting up of local action groups.
The strategic plan will be finalised by March of next year.
Dr Agius said the government was keeping the promises it made to farmers and fishermen and that the opposition was not in tune with reality.
Minister George Pullicino
Environment and Rural Affairs Minister George Pullicino said the government believed so much in the importance of the environment that it was investing Lm47 million next year, with capital investment alone increasing by Lm6 million to Lm22 million.
Minister Pullicino said he was disappointed that the opposition had little to say about the budget and that the policy documents they had published provide them with little inspiration.
The Labour Party, he said, was not offering concrete proposals even though it were saying that the government has brought “ruin” to the sector.
“It appears that the Labour Party has wasted its time in opposition,” the minister said, adding: “They are confused because they are trying to find solutions using yesterday’s tools.”
He said farmers had faith in the farming sector and the government was investing Lm4.4 million to help them restructure. Total aid to farmers and livestock breeders this year was Lm10.1 million, he said.
Turning to the funding for the period 2007 to 2013, Mr Pullicino said farmers, livestock breeders and fishermen would be benefiting from around Lm40 million or e100 million.
Fishermen alone would benefit from the Lm2 million investment in hard-standing facilities and a revision of the agreement with regard to excise-free fuel for fishermen was under way.
The minister said that it was now time to plan for the future when subsidies will be phased out, and the focus had to be on rural development, on quality Maltese products, on the producers themselves and the organisations they are members of.
“We cannot continue to close our eyes to the changes that are occurring around us,” the minister said.
With regard to Mepa, the minister said the revision of the development zone had been completed and that 90 per cent of the land for which claims were made to be developed had in fact been turned down.
He said that activities carried out by Mepa had contributed nearly seven per cent to the country’s GDP and it had approved a project worth around Lm100 million.
With regard to waste management, the minister said the government had brought about a revolution and that work on the landfill in Maghtab was at an advanced stage.
Work on the network of pipes that will be used to collect gases from the landfill has begun, he said, and would be completed by April of next year.
Mr Pullicino said that apart from the modernisation of the waste recycling plant in Marsascala, the government was investing in a family park to embellish the surrounding areas. The government will also be increasing the number of bring-in sites and by February of next year, 300 bring-in sites will be available. The government target is 400, he said.
The minister added the National Waste Management Strategy for 2007-2013 is being revised by two technical committees.
On the subject of NGOs, Mr Pullicino said it was true that the government and NGOs did not agree on everything, but “differences apart, we both have the same aim – a better environment”.
The minister spoke about the government’s commitment to animal welfare and said that a foundation was being set up to manage, among other things, the after-care centre. To get the project off the ground, Lm60,000 was being allocated.
He said the government was seconding two people who will be operating the ambulance service on a 24-hour basis, along with the help of NGOs. The Environment Ministry will also be maintaining the vehicle and providing biodiesel.
Mr Pullicino said he was disappointed that following the introduction of the littering regulations, he did not get enough support from local councils, even though they are arguing that the expense to operate green wardens was not covered by the fines these were issuing.
To this end, the government is examining the possibility of using government employees to do this work and also the enforcement of regulations on buildings sites. These regulations are expected to enter into force next year.
He said the government was close to signing an agreement to provide litter bins around Malta and Gozo.
Concluding his speech, Mr Pullicino said the ministry would continue working to improve the environment. He said that the government was spending Lm130,000 to install photovoltaic panels on various government buildings. These panels will generate an amount of electricity consumed by 22 households.
“This country is not ours. We inherited it from our ancestors and we are borrowing it from future generations. That is why we are duty-bound to pass it on, possibly in a better state than we found it,” Minister Pullicino said.