In 2002, 41 per cent of women said they had never had a cervical smear test, according to an article in the July edition of The Malta Medical Journal.
The article, entitled Effectiveness of Opportunistic Screening for Cancer of the Cervix Uteri, was written by Roderick Busuttil and Albert Cilia Vincenti, both from the Pathology Department at St Luke’s Hospital, and Miriam Dalmas from the Malta National Cancer Registry.
It pointed out that, according to the National Health Interview Survey (NHIS), carried out in 2002, 41 per cent of the women interviewed said they had never had a smear test.
Carried out by the Department of Health Information, the survey had a random sample of 5,510 respondents, of whom 2,213 were women aged 16 and over.
Around 12,800 women in the EU die each year from cervical cancer and in Malta there were 132 new cases of cervical cancer between 1992 and 2002. Of these 49 proved fatal.
The study said that, although a free cervical screening service had been available at the primary health centres and St Luke’s Hospital since 1978, there is “still not an organised national cervical screening programme in place and, as a result, all the cancer screening activity is opportunistic in nature.”
In fact, “only a small proportion of the female population at risk is actually being screened.”
“Women at higher risk of cervical cancer due to their lifestyle, especially sexual practices, are known to be more likely not present for cervical screening,” the report said.
The highest percentage of women who had never had a smear test were from the Inner Harbour Region and Gozo and Comino. The highest cases of invasive cervical cancer were found in the Inner and Outer Harbour Region.
The report found that the incidence rate for invasive cervical cancer in Gozo is “significantly lower than the national rate”.
It said that this could be “partially explained by the different attitudes of Gozitan women regarding sexual practice”.
“The NHIS data shows that Gozitan women report very low rates of multiple sexual partners – none of the women reported having multiple sexual partners, while 35 per cent declined to answer the question.”
There were 132 case files of patients diagnosed with invasive cervical cancer at St Luke’s Hospital between 1992 and 2002.
According to the report, 92 of these files were still available and 77 of the patients concerned were still alive and 15 had died. However, the files of 40 patients could not be retrieved, and of these six were still alive and the remaining 34 were deceased.
The files did not have any information related to the sexual lifestyle of the patients and the only data documented was related to the number of children to whom the women had given birth.
Only 54 per cent of the files had information about the patient’s smear test history. All of these had been carried out at St Luke’s Hospital and there was no record of any smear test carried out in private laboratories.
However, in some of the cases there were notes that indicated the patient had had a smear test carried out privately.
According to these files, only 10 per cent had had smear tests regularly (once every three years) while 44 per cent had not had any tests before cancer was diagnosed.
According to EU recommendations, cervical smear testing should be carried out every three years. However, the study pointed out “that this practice is not being adhered to in Malta.”
Furthermore, it added, the major aim of cervical screening is to reduce the incidence and mortality rate of invasive cancer.
The study said that there had been no significant reduction in incidence and mortality of cervical cancer in Malta over time, even though cervical screening services have become more available and accessible. It added that the female target population currently screened is unknown and “the effectiveness of this cancer screening is therefore questionable.”
Since the mortality rate has not reduced, the study is “reinforcing doubts about the effectiveness of the screening activity as it is not detecting the precancerous lesions.”
The study noted that mortality and incidence rates of cervical cancer have remained constant over the last 36 years.
Finally, the authors suggested setting up a national study to establish the number of women undergoing regular cervical screening so that the percentage of the target population being screened can be established.
The study should include all public and private hospitals that offer cervical screening and health promotions should “focus on increasing the frequency and scope of campaigns promoting the advantages of cervical screening” to
prevent cervical cancer.