The Malta Independent 20 November 2026, Friday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Monday, 6 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 13 years ago

Structure Plan Policies on Archaeology

The Structure Plan contains a set of seven policies that specifically address the treatment of development likely to affect archeologically remains. Guidance for the designation of areas and sites of archaeological significance are outlined in Structure Plan Policy ARC 1, while Policy ARC 2 details the criteria for rating sites according to their significance. Additionally, Structure Plan Policy ARC 3 gives guidance for development planning permission applications affecting important archaeological areas and sites, including areas and sites having such potential. Development of such sites will not normally be permitted until adequate opportunities have been provided for the recording and, where desirable, the excavation of such sites. Policy ARC 4 lists priority sites for protection.

Policy ARC 2 is most critical as it classifies archaeological sites according to their universal/national, regional and local significance and concurrently outlines a hierarchy of measures that should be taken to mitigate development from negatively affecting archaeological assets.

Sites that have universal and national significance due to their monumentality and rarity are considered as Class A sites and there is a presumption against development encroaching too close to the monument, hence the provision of a minimum buffer zone of a hundred metres. The buffer zone is essential to maintain the natural setting around the monument, where this still survives. It also protects any minor or yet undiscovered archaeological remains within the environment of the Class A site. Thus, buffer zones are also useful to control land use activities that are beyond the remit of the agency managing the archaeological site. Previous to the Structure Plan, heritage protection under the Antiquities Protection Act 1925 was monument-specific. As a consequence, development encroached close to the monuments such that the environment around some Class A sites has already been compromised by development, such as at Kordin III in Paola, as well as a number of World Heritage Sites such as the Hypogeum at Paola, Tarxien Temples, and Ta’ Hagrat in Mgarr.

Sites of regional significance qualify as Class B owing to their quality but are more numerous than the Class A monuments. Most of these sites consist of ancient tombs and cart-ruts and it is desired that they be preserved at all costs and that adequate measures should be taken to preclude any damage from immediate development. However, no buffer zone is specified in the Structure Plan for Class B, but all Local Plans have adopted a buffer zone of 50 metres for Class B. Again, there are instances where development encroached very close to these features, such as Ghajn Dwieli, where a sub-station had to be built in between a group of Punic tombs as the area had already been built.

Class C and Class D ratings are less concerned with the level of significance of the archaeological features and are rather more useful for the mitigation measures they offer. As archaeological features are a non-renewable finite resource, the policies advocate towards the precautionary principle and emphases that every effort should be made to investigate, record and where possible, save the features discovered.

For instance, Class C provides guidance for accidental discoveries or ones that have been re-discovered after they were buried for some reason in the past, such as the ancient harbour remains re-discovered in May 2005 near the Marsa canal. The policy states that every effort should be made to conserve the remains, even if these have to be reburied for preservation after proper investigation and documentation, and also to provide subsequent access and reserving the potential for future excavation in line with the principle of sustainability. Often, development projects encountering such discoveries are required by Mepa to modify parts of the design of the project to integrate the conservation of the archaeology.

Class D recommends preservation by record as the last resort. It is reserved for archaeological features where “numerous other examples are known”, though this is not ethically considered correct as archaeology is finite, irreplaceable and once destroyed, it is lost forever, losing information and knowledge that may not have been fully understood. Nevertheless, this mitigation has to be applied, but only in exceptional circumstances. A case that would qualify for this last option concerns ancient tombs encountered in the 1980s during the construction of Triq Belt il-Hazna near the Marsa power station. These archaeological features could not be preserved owing to the necessity of the infrastructural project. It is not known whether the tombs were adequately excavated and recorded before they were destroyed.

Mepa’s National Protective Inventory of archaeological sites and GIS

In addition to the above, Structure Plan Policies ARC 6 and ARC 7 deal specifically with the need for Mepa to maintain a comprehensive inventory of all archaeological sites and features. The information of the inventory cards follows the Council of Europe’s Core Data Standards for archaeological sites. This information is availed of when evaluating development applications within archaeologically sensitive sites. The data is compiled in-house or contracted externally and includes desktop research and on-site surveys. The data is kept in both hard copy and digital format as well as on a Geographic Information System (GIS). Mepa was the first public agency to introduce digital mapping in 1988 and GIS in 1993. GIS is a system whereby maps, instead of being plotted on paper, are stored digitally in computer databases and may be accessed simultaneously by different users on their workstations in different offices. Most of the data is also available on the Mepa website for public access via the internet. Different maps may be generated from data obtained by state-of-the-art technologies in the field of cartography. The different maps may include the conventional base maps showing buildings, roads and the coastline; contours showing ground relief; and thematic maps, for example planning applications, enforcements and also an archaeological map.

The inventory to date contains over a thousand archaeological sites on land and within the territorial waters of the Maltese islands. Despite the attempt to collect information about all the known and previously recorded sites that are no longer visible, the inventory cannot ever be exhaustive due to new discoveries, but is updated routinely with information about such new discoveries. The function of the inventory is not only related to preserving archaeological sites but is useful for site prediction modelling, thus ensuring that any potential remains within areas so far having a negative yield of discoveries are also taken into consideration. According to Policy ARC 6, all sites recorded in the National Protective Inventory will be protected in accordance with Development Planning Act powers and by reference to the ratings given in Policy ARC 2.

Mepa’s archaeology inventory for the Marsa area, for example, contains at least 11 sites ranging from megalithic remains on the Kordin promontory, Phoenician; Roman and Palaeochristian tombs on Jesuits’ Hill; near the Abattoir and Ghajn Dwieli, ancient harbour-related structural remains near the power station; along Racecourse Street and near the ex-tram shed, ancient reservoirs on Jesuits’ Hill, Roman baths beneath Capuchin’s Bastion, architectural and sculptural fragments dredged from the Marsa seabed and a Medieval Chapel at the Marsa sport grounds.

Current Practice Planning Process

The planning process is continuously changing as it has to respond and adapt to emerging needs. Mepa receives over 6,000 development applications annually of which an average of 800-1,000 applications are for development within archaeologically sensitive areas.

Once an application for development is submitted by the architect on behalf of the client, the documents and drawings are vetted for any missing information and the application is given a unique reference number (file number) and plotted on Mepa’s GIS. The file containing the submissions is forwarded to a case officer who would administer the application through the planning process. The case officer holds internal and external consultations with relative experts. For instance, in the case of archaeology, consultations are held with Mepa’s Integrated Heritage Management team, the Heritage Advisory Committee and the Superintendence of Cultural Heritage. Recommendations by the consultees are included in the case officer’s report, alongside the proposal, relevant policies, any comments by objectors (members of the public, institutions or NGOs), a discussion about the merits of the application and finally, a recommendation for the granting or refusal of the application to be determined by the deciding bodies – the Mepa Board and the Development Control Commissions (DCC). There are three DCCs: one for Urban Conservation Areas, one for schemed areas and one for Outside Development Zones. Mepa decides on major projects. The members of the deciding bodies are appointed by the government and are independent from the Mepa Planning and Environment Protection Directorates. The directorates consist of case officers, planning officers and environmental officers who compile data and prepare recommendations to the deciding bodies. The latter may not agree with the recommendations as there may be other factors of priority that override the directorates’ recommendations. The deciding bodies may refuse an application if there is an overriding case for the preservation of the archaeological remains, especially if the architect does not include safeguarding measures.

Archaeological Monitoring

In many instances, on the recommendations received from the heritage experts, permits are granted with a number of conditions to safeguard the archaeology within the site and which are agreed to by both the architect and the applicant. Often, such conditions include the requirement for the preserve in situ of the remains, or else to record and cover the remains, and as explained earlier, in exceptional cases to record and destroy the remains.

The basic principle of archaeology-related conditions is the obligation of the architect and/or the applicant to inform Mepa and the SCH in writing two weeks before the commencement of any excavation work so that the regulatory agencies send their qualified representatives to monitor the works and who will be able to identify any accidental archaeological discovery. To ensure that the agencies are informed before the works commence, developers have to deposit a bank guarantee calculated at the rate of Lm5,000 per 200m2 of archaeologically sensitive area being disturbed. That is, the more extensive the ground disturbance works are, the larger the bank guarantee is. If the agencies are not informed before the works commence, or their instructions are not followed with the consequence that archaeological assets are damaged or destroyed, the bank guarantee is forfeited. This has been resorted to in a few cases but most developers adhere to these conditions stringently. This form of polluter pays approach proved successful as the risk of the forfeiture of the bank guarantee seriously jeopardises the profit margin being made from the development.

Despite all this, there are still some who excavate within archaeologically sensitive areas without a planning permit or without informing the agencies. Some even carry out the works during the weekends and during the night in order to avoid supervision. The excuses made by the perpetrators are quite imaginative, such as that “the workers were new” or “the subcontractor did not know about the conditions” among others, consequently, the bank guarantee is forfeited. The amount forfeited is deposited in a special fund held by Mepa and which is used to issue financial grants for projects of environmental improvement and the restoration of scheduled properties. Still, the developer has the right to appeal against this in front of the Planning Appeals Board.

Besides, as regulator, Mepa endeavours to protect archaeology through persuasion and negotiation with the architects and the developers. Mepa tries to do its best to find an adequate compromise between development and conservation and the management of the site after the development is completed, especially if it happens to be within private land.

Accidental Archaeological Discoveries or Infringements

Sometimes, development starts notwithstanding that discussions and consultations are still in progress as part of the planning application process. Mepa then has to intervene through enforcement and stop the works. In such cases, the offence is either reported by third parties or noted by Mepa officers. The relevant Mepa Units are informed, and officers proceed on site immediately.

The works are stopped if found to be in contravention of the law or not in accordance with the conditions of a planning permit.

Accidental archaeological discoveries made during development works are increasing due to intensification of development and monitoring, and when this occurs, consultation with the SCH is mandatory.

If required, the perpetrator is asked to reinstate the site (backfill), or implement any other safeguarding measure.

It is also usual practice that an appropriate fine equivalent to the damage or restoration costs is recommended.

Problems of implementation. Marsa – A Case Study

During the past two decades there has been a noticeable improvement in the general attitude towards the management of the environment and heritage.

Despite this, some private and public entities still fail to observe the requirements of the Development Planning Act and Structure Plan policies.

Sometimes, developers commence work without bothering to submit an application for a planning permit and consequently, Mepa has to enact its enforcement powers and stop the works being carried out without a permit.

A case in point concerns the Flood Relief Project at Marsa within a Class B Site of Archaeological Importance.

Works were taken in hand without a planning permit soon after the application PA 6965/04 was submitted.

Apparently the project engineers did not carry out any research or consultation about the potential presence of archaeological remains in the area during the design stage or when starting the works.

The planning application was in its initial stages of processing when the excavation works for the new canal commenced.

The works would have been better planned if the engineers consulted Mepa’s archaeological GIS inventory.

Furthermore, proper studies on storm water management and the storage of rain water would have shown whether the design of the project was the best solution.

On the morning of 8 April 2005, two reports were received by the Mepa Integrated Heritage Management team by conscientious members of the public.

Within 15 minutes of the reports, Mepa officers preceded to the site, confirmed the presence of archeological remains that seemed significant in terms of scale and importance and asked the workmen to stop.

By then, a lot of damage had already been inflicted to the remains as a result of the excavation of a trench that was approximately five metres wide and 15 metres long, revealing Classical period masonry cross walls at intervals.

Mepa enforcement officers were called in and the discovery was reported to the Superintendent of Cultural Heritage.

Arrangements were made to fetch a representative of the SCH who came on site during the same morning, confirming the significance of the find and also asked the workmen to stop works in terms of the Cultural Heritage Act.

From then on, the SCH liaised with the Works Division about the design of the project and the rescue excavation of the site.

Details about the archaeological remains discovered at this site are given in the following paper in this volume.

Problems and Deficiencies

The main problems and deficiencies in the management of archaeological assets and other heritage sites may be summarised as follows:

• Lack of awareness

• Disregard to laws and obligations

• Lack of efficient institutional communication

• Lack of human resources to empower the institutions

Those who are aware about local heritage and are ready to make a real effort in conserving such heritage form a minority.

The country and the different stakeholders have different agendas and heritage may not always be a priority.

The human resources in the management of heritage are lacking and there are still a number of difficulties on co-operation between state agencies, NGOs and the public.

There is need to overcome these weaknesses by working further together to protect the fast diminishing archaeological heritage. This may be done by generating further awareness at grassroots level and by encouraging public participation.

Conclusion

It must be recognised that the Development Planning Act, the Structure Plan and the establishment of Mepa in 1992 have brought about significant improvements in the protection of archaeological heritage.

Despite this, development pressure and local attitude towards environmental responsibility has often crossed swords with ethical idealism.

There is still a lack of awareness about what archaeology is and what it stands for and why it is significant for the present and future generations.

This lack of appreciation is absent at all levels of local society.

All citizens demand their rights, but many shy away from their obligations as required by local legislation and moral law.

Most Maltese get enthused when they visit heritage sites in other countries, but unfortunately, this appreciation is often not extended to local heritage, or at least as long as no archaeological remains are discovered in one’s own back garden!

Joseph Magro Conti is manager, Integrated Heritage Management Team

Malta Environment and Planning Authority

  • don't miss