A fruitful debate was held on Friday evening in parliament, discussing the 2007 financial estimates for the Ministry of Urban Development and Roads, encompassing around Lm21 million. Various ongoing and planned projects were mentioned, and constructive criticisms made from both sides of the House.
The estimates were approved, with 26 votes against and 30 in favour, after a division was called.
Charles Buhagiar (MLP)
Charles Buhagiar, Labour’s main spokesperson for Public Works, Roads, Public Transport and Construction, began by commending the projects that are currently underway, such as those at Manuel Island and Tigne Point, the Cruise Liner Terminal and Cottonera; yet he did mention that these are not materialising without cumbersome problems being faced – traffic management and parking being the most imminent.
Embellishing upon the Cottonera Waterfront project, he emphasised that having a number of developers instead of one created several problems and that though the work that was being done was good, it impeded adequate access to the building of a hotel, that it is said, is in the pipeline.
He yet again mentioned parking in Cottonera as being a drastic problem faced by the residents: “It needs to be dealt with,” he said.
Buhagiar also plunged into a rendition of the history of “project development” on the Opera House Site, Dock 1 and St Elmo, stating that they were a priority for this government, as evidenced in an interview with Minister Jesmond Mugliett on The Times, at the beginning of his mandate, yet nothing has been done about them. “What is happening?” he repeatedly asked.
The Schreiber project, and that at the Crafts’ Village in Ta’ Qali, were other projects he felt were promised and yet did not materialise – “It’s about time things began to take effect, and that something is done about them,” he pressed.
Being quite vociferous about parking, traffic management and access to Valletta, Cottonera and Sliema, the Labour MP insisted that several assets needed development and exploitation.
Park and Ride, pedestrian zones in Valletta, a vertical connection from the Waterfront Cruise Liner Terminal to the Barrakka, and a ferry shuttle service in the Grand Harbour, are all good ideas, he said, “are we not capable of moving forward and taking the plunge?”
Regarding roads, Buhagiar complained about the state and quality of the new roads, saying they left much to be desired, especially with regards to Girolamo Cassar Avenue, the street in front of Castille which has undergone works three times over. He also voiced concerns about the roads being done through EU funding, asking whether set standards were being applied to all jobs undertaken, and whether the 2004-2006 funding would still cover projects that were in its ambit, yet have not been started such as the Hal Far Road, Manoel Dimech Bridge and San Lawrenz Street.
Stefan Buontempo (MLP)
Labour’s spokesperson on Housing, Stefan Buontempo, was quite critical about projects that were assured, and yet not effected, such as those at White Rocks, Dock 1, St Elmo, and the Valletta main gate. He made a plea that words should not be wasted in promises, but proactive action should be taken.
Buontempo expressed his worry about the environment, saying that this was not being regarded in projects undertaken and that work was taking place at the detriment of the residents in the areas concerned, and the community at large.
He ended his intervention by stating that a Labour government will rectify these issues, “because we show discipline and seriousness, and have the nation at heart.”
Anton Refalo (MLP)
Dr Anton Refalo, MLP main spokesperson for Gozo, said that in the 2004 budget speech, much was promised in terms of development and accessibility in Gozo, yet two years down the line, Gozo Channel fares have increased thrice over, Gozitan Public Transport Operators are not subsidised while Maltese are, and the budget allocation for Gozo in terms of road reconstruction is pitiful – not a cent of the Italian Protocol funds reaching the island and only 5% of EU funding being set aside in this respect.
Mario Galea (PN)
Mario Galea, the government’s whip, began his intervention stating that Minister Mugliett “never had it so good,” being impressed with the opposition’s poor criticism.
He then went on to make suggestions with regard to the Transport Authority, ADT, saying that a solution needed to be found regarding the licensing of hearses, karozzini, and that the market should be opened for the Open Top Bus Services instead of being strictly controlled by the authority.
Joe Falzon (PN)
Joe Falzon showed pride in the ministry’s performance, and said that there has not been a time wherein so much quality work has been done, stating that 20 years ago, the situation was very different.
He asked that the ministry concentrate on roads in residential areas that are suffering from a negative impact when main roads are being constructed.
“An effective construction management plan has to be implemented,” he said, “in conjunction with the Ministry for the Environment.”
Jesmond Mugliett (PN)
The Minister for Urban Development and Roads, Jesmond Mugliett, was appreciative of the opposition’s argumentation, especially that of Charles Buhagiar, saying that the shadow minister was always of help when consulted.
Mugliett mentioned the regeneration of roads and “big” projects that were being undertaken, such as Tigne Point and the Cruise Liner Terminal, articulating that the ministry has improved and matured in the process of its implementation.
He also made reference to the capital projects being done through ADT, such as the electrical mini-cabs initiative, the open top buses tender, as well as that for trackless trains, the taxi-meter fixtures, and the ferry shuttle service in the Grand Harbour that still needs to be worked upon.
Regarding current projects, Mugliett elaborated upon the accessibility measures being employed from the Valletta Waterfront to the city centre, stating that they posed problems and challenges, such as that of traffic management, yet were being viewed through a “historical environment protection” lens, hence one of “clean” transport.
In light of Park and Ride, which will start as of today, parking and accessibility for residents, tourists and the workforce in Valletta will be improved, he said.
As for the projects at St Elmo, the Opera House and the Valletta Main Gate, the minister said that it has been a busy year, and other projects took precedence and were thus given priority.
The ministry does not have the capacity to do everything all at once, and there are certain obstacles when it comes to funding and/or feasibility, he continued.
However, with Dock 1 and the Schreiber projects, things are moving forward, he claimed.
Taking a look at the capital projects for 2007 and thereafter, Mugliett highlighted the Crafts’ Village in Ta’ Qali, as well as the further development of Cottonera, which, he said, is changing the residents’ mentality, increasing property prices and upping the area’s economy.
Answering a question put to him by Labour MP Charles Buhagiar, regarding the link road from Kappara to Manoel Island, Mugliett said that it will start in 2007 or 2008, but it was more viable to finish off the Manoel Dimech Bridge and the Kappara roundabout, before looking into reconstructing the link road.
In his reply to another of Buhagiar’s questions, about the period of EU funding for certain projects, the minister vouched that Hal Far Road and San Lawrenz Street would be finished this year; as for the Manoel Dimech Bridge, the funding allowed for the project to end a year after the period ended, meaning in December 2007.
Mugliett wound up his intervention by asserting that during his mandate, around 62 per cent of the road network in Malta had been rebuilt.
“We are on a learning curve, but we are continuing to strive and manage, although it is true we need to learn more about traffic management,” he confessed.