The Malta Independent 19 November 2026, Thursday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Tuesday, 7 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 21 years ago

The financial estimates for the Foreign Affairs Ministry were approved yesterday, with Minister Michael Frendo announcing that the technical studies related to the joint oil-exploration venture with Tunisia had been concluded.

Dr Frendo said this by no means meant that oil had been found, but that the talks could now move to Foreign Ministerial level.

The general theme by the MLP was support for the government in working for Malta’s good in the EU and on the issue of irregular immigration.

George Vella (MLP)

Labour European Affairs spokesman George Vella

said that the European Parliament was gaining more in stature and more value was being placed on reaching consensus within. “It is positive to see democracy working in practice,” said Dr Vella.

One of the areas that foreign policy needed to address, he said, was that of the European Constitution. “We need a new treaty. If not, the EU is going to become jammed. There are some countries that just want to see small changes to the present one and that’s it. We have had a period of reflection, but it seems that the jury is still out on the issue,” said Dr Vella.

He pointed out that French Interior Minister Nicholas Sarkozy wants a mini treaty to be put into effect until after the 2009 European Parliamentary elections, followed by the drafting of a new treaty. Others, he said, wanted a watered down or simplified text of what was on offer in the present treaty, but they wanted it put into effect before 2009.

Dr Vella said that Malta will be affected by this issue. “So we should put our foot down and decide on what we want and make our position clear,” he said.

Narrowing down foreign policy, he said, one also had to look at the Mediterranean dimension, where there were problems with energy, water, textiles and agriculture.

“We also have the problem of terrorism and the repercussions it has on our tourism industry. If we, as an EU member state, want to contribute, we should push for the Euro-Med process. People say that we can understand North African countries and we can make a difference, and so we should push hard to make that difference,” said Dr Vella.

When he brought up the issue of irregular immigration, Dr Vella said that Malta was the smallest and most badly affected country. “We were promised assistance, but now we have heard both British and German ministers say that there is a limit to the amount of solidarity that can be expected,” he said.

The government had the total support of the opposition in dealing with the issue of irregular immigration, said Dr Vella. In conclusion, he said: “Everyone is hoping that matters will be resolved under the German Presidency and Chancellor Angela Merkel. She has promised to look into establishing the EU’s frontiers, a return to European values, improvisation and removing red tape, which is precisely what is needed.”

Leo Brincat (MLP)

MLP foreign affairs and IT spokesman Leo Brincat said that, over the years, foreign policy had changed dramatically. “When there was regional conflict, other countries used to wait before taking action – Kosovo or the Middle East being prime examples. Today it has changed, because the world has seen the repercussions that violence can have on economies. Terrorism is one such example. Crises spread,” said Mr Brincat.

Malta can no longer afford to wait and react, he said. “We must be pro-active and we must put our point of view across. We must remember that, outside Europe, there are plenty of opportunities – we should not forget that. Former US President Bill Clinton said there was a very fine line between local and foreign policy – today’s day and age no longer allows it,” he said.

He thanked Holland and the United States for voluntarily taking in some of Malta’s irregular immigrants, but said that it was nothing but a symbolic gesture. “The numbers were very small,” he said.

He, like Dr Vella, pledged unconditional support to the government. “But we feel we have to point out that while everyone seems to be listening to our problems, there is not enough concrete action.”

He said that visits to Japan and China were pencilled in for next year, but complained that the government never briefed the opposition on such matters. “Instead, it is the foreign countries that brief us. It should be the government that briefs us, especially if a sensitive matter is being discussed,” said Mr Brincat.

He also spoke about Libya, pointing out that relations between the two countries had cooled. “Since we adopted the practice of demanding visas for entry, relations have taken a step back. Libya was and still is important to us economically and politically,” he said.

Mr Brincat reminded the House of the time when Malta professed itself to be the bridge between Europe and North Africa.

“If we are not careful, we will end up being bypassed by a flyover where Libya just goes over our heads and straight to larger EU countries. The imposition of visa requirements has led to fewer Libyans coming to Malta because membership has made Malta more expensive and less accessible,” said Mr Brincat.

He said that Foreign Minister Michael Frendo had said Malta can rekindle ties with Libya. “But what have we done? Not much. We need reciprocal respect between our countries. Libya also has a difficult situation to deal with in curbing irregular immigration. We should embark on helping them monitor their borders. It will help Europe as much as it will Libya,” said Mr Brincat.

Malta needed to preserve its Mediterranean identity, he said. “We need to use our geo-strategic position to build a more Mediterranean identity for the whole region. We are good listeners, as well. Look at the Middle East; we need to push for a peaceful solution, especially as we have good relations with the US, the EU, Palestine and Israel. All that happens in the Medi-

terranean affects us. We should do all we can to avoid a clash of civilisations.”

Mario de Marco (PN)

Nationalist MP Mario de Marco said that the world needed to address the Palestine situation. “We must not be equidistant, we need to be close to all parties,” he said.

He said that the EU must pledge more concrete help to tackle irregular immigration. “We received e900,000 for sea patrols, food and medicines thanks to hard work put in by (Justice and Home Affairs) Minister Tonio Borg and (Foreign Minister) Dr Frendo,” said Dr de Marco.

He concluded: “Foreign

policy, the social sphere and economic well being in Malta and the Mediterranean depends on what happens in the international sphere.”

Michael Frendo (PN)

“This was an interesting debate. It is important that it takes place because, as others have said today, foreign issues are at the heart of the political, social and economic basis of a country,” said Foreign Minister Michael Frendo.

However, Dr Frendo said he could not accept criticism to the effect that the government was merely a reactive one and not pro-active. “We look at realities that Malta might have to address in the future and we start addressing them now. Focus is important,” he said.

Malta needed to put its foreign policy forward for its own strategic aims, said Dr Frendo. “We are waiting for the MLP to give us their input. We were told that in September the MLP was working on its vision statement, but we have not seen anything yet,” he said.

Dr Frendo said that one must never forget that it was Malta’s agenda that came first. “That is why we have strategic aims. That is our agenda, we need to make that a part of Europe’s agenda – not vice-versa,” he said.

He also spoke about the oil exploration agreement with Tunisia and said that the technical assessment by experts had been concluded and that both parties had agreed to pass the matter over to the foreign ministries for political discussion. He said the time was now ripe to find a common stance on the issue and hammer out an agreement.

“This does not mean that we have found oil. Far from it, but the process is still very much alive and we are making process. The technical assessment took a bit longer than expected, but what are two months in the face of a diplomatic impasse that had been idle for 35 years,” said Dr Frendo.

He said he expected that he and his counterpart begin to discuss the new developments in the very near future.

He also agreed with the earlier suggestions made by Dr Vella who said that Malta needed to be more proactive on the European Working Time Directive, saying that Malta had a strong position on the issue in order to retain its competitiveness. “We do not want to limit people’s opportunities, but on the other hand, the EU has always been careful about this and takes into account the realities of all countries,” he said.

Dr Frendo said irregular immigration was and still is a huge problem. “We need to coordinate. We are not headless chickens – far from it. We started from a situation where it was not recognised that Malta had a problem, but other states saw the numbers and thought that it was not as bad as was being painted,” said Dr Frendo.

He said that to truly understand the magnitude of the problem, one needed to look at the numbers relatively. “Even when it came to financial perspectives – before, the key was worked on lowest and sparsest populations. We got it altered by putting our position forward. We approach issues systematically and with zero tolerance if it is in Malta’s interest, and that is why we are being successful. We are astute,” said Dr Frendo.

He said that foreign policy was no longer about delivering lectures and speeches. Foreign policy is not delivering lectures. It is looking at the small print and seeing that your country’s

interests are in the small print.

He said he was happy that Malta, Italy and EU Commissioner Franco Frattini had held various meetings on the issue of irregular immigration. “The EU can and must do more for Malta. We feel that we have succeeded because the item is not at the top level of the EU and of various member states,” said Dr Frendo.

He said that he felt, at times, that Malta was being treated as a small country with a small problem. “And yes, I lashed out in Paris, Frankfurt and others places. I pressed our case in the international press. For The Herald Tribune I penned a piece entitled: Malta needs help now – and they changed it to Small country, big problem, said Dr Frendo.

He also spoke about the standoff related to the Spanish trawler that picked up immigrants in international waters and wanted to offload them in Malta. “I refused – it was a turning a point, it showed that Malta would not accept everything. We showed the world that we would not back down. There was a lot of pressure – international and local – but we would not back down,” he said. Dr Frendo said that this was the first true example of burden-sharing in Europe.

Government MPs Mario Galea and Robert Arrigo also spoke during yesterday’s debate.

  • don't miss