Public Transport Association (PTA) president Victor Spiteri defended his organisation yesterday against accusations by Alternattiva Demokratika (AD) chairman Harry Vassallo, by claiming that the local bus service is one of the biggest contributors to the protection of the environment on the island.
“AD have never had the decency to meet operators and discuss the problems that we have in providing the service,” Mr Spiteri said in a press statement issued yesterday. “Instead, it takes the easy way out by criticising without suggesting any sustainable solutions.”
Maltese buses carry out 4,300 trips a day on a 300 square metre island, far more than the average in other countries, Mr Spiteri said. Referring to the Halcrow report commissioned by ADT in the past few months, he said that the PTA disagrees with the proposal to dispense with 700 trips a day, on the grounds that the service also has a social aspect.
As for the state of the buses themselves, Mr Spiteri claimed that these cannot be replaced without some form of financial assistance.
“Unfortunately, the government didn’t stick to the agreement it reached with bus owners in 1995 by replacing the whole fleet. In fact, only 147 of 508 have been replaced,” Mr Spiteri continued. “So Dr Vassallo should be aware that, with the low income bus owners receive, they cannot replace old buses without a subsidy.”
According to Mr Spiteri, sustainable public transport represents the only solution to traffic congestion on the island. “But there has to be investment in the infrastructure on the island, such as bus termini to accommodate commuters and employees of public transport,” Mr Spiteri added. “To make the service efficient and punctual, we have to introduce priorities such as bus lanes and bus corridors, as other countries do. With these in place, we can organise a route network to cater for the needs of today.”
Mr Spiteri strongly rejected Dr Vassallo proposals that public transport contracts should be available to anyone who is capable of providing the service under a given set of conditions, arguing that when routes were handled by several operators instead of only one, many of them went bankrupt.
“It was a good decision 30 years ago to form one company to provide such a network”, said Mr Spiteri. “If you eliminate the PTA and go for tendering instead, all the unprofitable routes will end up either without a service, or with commuters having to fork out a fare similar to a taxi service, or with a schedule involving hours of waiting.”
Mr Spiteri also defended the Prime Minister’s decision to abandon the Connections Project two years ago, arguing that sea transport is unreliable because of weather conditions. “One has to also consider that if public transport loses commuters, more subsidy will have to be forked out from tax payers’ money, and this makes no sense,” he added.
Regarding traffic jams, Mr Spiteri pinned the blame for the worsening situation on “a flawed policy by both governments”, which viewed new cars coming into the islands as a sign of economic progress, without making the necessary infrastructural preparations such as building new roads, providing parking areas and safeguarding the health and environment of the general public.