The Malta Independent 19 November 2026, Thursday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Wednesday, 8 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 21 years ago

The draft bill that makes alcohol consumption by minors a criminal offence is aimed at closing a number of loopholes in the existing legislation, Deputy Prime Minister Tonio Borg said yesterday in Parliament.

Speaking during the second reading of a bill to amend the Code of Police Laws, Dr Borg said that one had to acknowledge that a drinking problem existed locally, although he questioned whether it was fair to state that Malta had one of the worst scenarios in Europe.

The deputy prime minister said that to date only the sale of alcohol was illegal under the Wines and Spirits Act, but not under the Code of Police laws. Hence, only the individual or establishment selling alcohol to minors could be found guilty of breaking the law. An adult who bought alcohol and gave it to a minor could not, he said, because that person did not have a licence and therefore did not come under the terms of the Wines and Spirits Act.

“We are now making it very clear that no one, a licensed shop or otherwise, can sell, or provide, alcohol to minors. Taking this one step further, we are now saying that even people under the age of 16 will be committing a crime if they are found buying or consuming alcohol,” the minister said.

Dr Borg said a number of MPs and some agencies had raised the question of whether the legal drinking age should be increased to 18 instead of 16.

“We considered this option but we think it would be better to close the existing loopholes and strengthen the present legal framework, even more so since we have never had consumption considered a crime,” Dr Borg said.

Making consumption a crime was important because it would enable the law courts to impose a form of treatment as part of the sentence handed down to the minor.

Anglu Farrugia (MLP)

Labour MP Anglu Farrugia said this was a positive piece of legislation to counter a serious problem in Malta.

He said the problems started within the family and he warned that alcohol was not only consumed in public places but also in houses, flats and farmhouses rented or used by young people to organise parties.

Dr Farrugia said many families also had the bad habit of giving alcohol to their children when they were still at a young age. He praised the owners of bars or other establishments who organised alcohol-free parties for young people and called on the government to ensure that they are not penalised for doing so – simply because technically they have a licence to sell alcohol and have allowed minors inside their premises.

He also suggested that the courts should give greater importance to community service sentencing.

Michael Gonzi (PN)

Nationalist MP Michael Gonzi said he was concerned that the bill put every young drinker in the same category and he questioned whether the bill actually helped those who are not habitual drinkers but who just made a mistake at a time when they had personal problems. Dr Gonzi asked whether taking them to court would have the desired effect?

Silvio Parnis (MLP)

Labour MP Silvio Parnis said it was important not to underestimate the consequences of alcohol abuse and excessive drinking and the role of media to educate the public on the dangers of alcohol abuse.

Joe Brincat (MLP)

Labour MP Joe Brincat agreed in principle with the bill but pointed out a number of shortcomings. He said a number of loopholes in the bill as it is written could allow people to escape punishment.

Dr Brincat said that band clubs, for example, were not considered to be public places, because they belonged to private members, even if they welcomed tourists. He suggested that the law should be more restrictive and cover every location, except where the minor lives with his or her parents.

Franco Galea (PN)

Nationalist MP Franco Galea said the proposed law was good, but he asked why no one was focusing on the reasons why young people were consuming alcohol, smoking cigarettes and using drugs.

Mr Galea said the law would only be a success if it was enforced properly and diligently by the authorities. Here, however, he raised a number of points on how the law would be enforced.

“If young people are caught with alcohol in their hands, will be they be arrested by the police, will they be taken to a police station or to another centre? Will they be arraigned in court under arrest? Have the police authorities agreed on the protocol to be observed when they have to take action against minors consuming alcohol,” Mr Galea asked.

  • don't miss