Parliamentary secretary Tonio Fenech yesterday announced that the EU’s Code of Conduct Group (Business Taxation) had found Malta’s system to be compatible with its principles and that its tax measures are not harmful to business.
He said that after years of discussions, the Group yesterday approved the recommendations made by the government and this means that the tax advantages given to foreign investors in Malta could be administered without any country questioning the measures.
Mr Fenech was speaking during the debate to approve the financial estimates of the Prime Minister’s Office in Parliament yesterday evening.
Joe Debono Grech (MLP)
Opening the debate, Labour MP Joe Debono Grech spoke at length about the Armed Forces of Malta and argued that not all soldiers were being treated equally. He alleged that many soldiers had been passed over for promotion even though they enjoyed years of seniority.
Mr Debono Grech said the armed forces carried out sterling work for the country and its people. He called on the Prime Minister to listen to the lower ranks and to get the real picture of the conditions that these soldiers are working in.
He said soldiers and their families were disillusioned and it was not right that they earned a salary that was lower than that of other civil servants, even more so when they worked longer hours and at greater risk to their well-being.
Mr Debono Grech said it was not right that a particular group of soldiers received preferential treatment. He said that each complaint had to be studied individually and he promised that once in government, he would personally see to it that those who suffered some injustice would be helped and given support.
Jose Herrera (MLP)
Adding to what Mr Debono Grech had said earlier, Dr Herrera spoke about an officer in the AFM who was doing work of a senior ranked official, however when he applied for a promotion, his application was not accepted because the security services had not recommended the promotion.
Dr Herrera asked how it was possible to deny promotion to someone on the basis of a security service report to carry out a job he was already doing: “why was he not prevented from doing this job in the first place?”
The Labour MP said the promotion was not given because of a report that had been made many years ago, and the security services had seen this as a possible security threat. Dr Herrera said the facts clearly showed that the officer had acted correctly at the time and therefore there was no security threat whatsoever. He called on the parliamentary secretary and the Prime Minister to look into the matter.
Labour leader Alfred Sant
Labour leader Alfred Sant yesterday reiterated much of what he said in his reply to the budget speech and attacked the government for its incompetence and lack of direction.
Dr Sant said the government had, over the past two weeks of debates, painted a picture that everything was fine, that the country’s finances are good and that the economy was back on track.
He said the opposition had done its best to show the country what was really going on and that the party was careful not to exaggerate the situation.
He said people were expecting the government to give a clear direction to the country but all they got was a lot of playing around with figures. The public, he said, was eager for change in government, a government that answered the people’s questions.
Dr Sant promised that once in government, Labour would carry out a professional audit of the government’s finances.
The Opposition Leader said the government was constantly contradicting itself.
“Are the people living better? The Prime Minister is saying they are. However, the statistics show otherwise. Real income has gone down by three per cent. They tell us that the economy is improving, so why is the income of Maltese and Gozitan families decreasing?” Dr Sant insisted.
Turning to tourism, Dr Sant asked why the recommendations made by the consultative group were not made public. He said that even the outgoing president of the MHRA had said that the inter-ministerial meetings had not worked well.
He said the government’s solutions for the economy were puerile and that confusion in the tourism sector was solely the government’s fault. Quoting from the report drawn up by economist Joseph Falzon, he said the results of this analysis clearly showed that the economy was stagnant.
Dr Sant said that exportation was falling, inflation and the cost of living had eroded the public’s quality of life and the country’s competitiveness.
“The government should have given priority to creating a competitive country, to bringing down the rate of inflation and to boosting the manufacturing, farming, fisheries, health and education sectors,” Dr Sant said.
Referring once again to the surcharge, Dr Sant reiterated that once in government he would reduce the surcharge on water and electricity bills by 40 to 50 per cent.
The Opposition Leader said the government had criticised the Labour Party for making such a suggestion and had asked where the party expected to get the money from.
“The government is finding it hard to find the money to implement what we are suggesting but then has no problem whatsoever to spend millions of liri on consultancy fees, on travel, on vehicles, on Brand Malta and on Dar Malta,” Dr Sant said.
Dr Sant said he hoped that the government was going to implement what it was promising to do in 2007 considering that it can take up to two years to gain access to EU funds.
With regards to the Gozo helicopter service, Dr Sant said he would re-introduce the service by giving a subsidy. He said that if low-cost airlines could be subsidised, there was no reason why the helicopter service could not as well.
Concluding, Dr Sant said the budget was weak, empty and without a sense of direction.
Tonio Fenech (PN)
Parliamentary secretary Tonio Fenech criticised the deputy leader of the opposition Dr Charles Mangion for basing all his arguments on one single report, that prepared by economist Prof. Joseph Falzon.
Mr Fenech said he respected the economist’s opinion, however, like every report, it has to be analysed before it could be taken as fact. He said the government took this report into consideration and in its analysis found a number of shortcomings in the methodology used and in the conclusions reached by the economist. The parliamentary secretary said no one had contradicted the report and Dr Mangion should have compared this report to others before making certain sweeping statements on the economy.
He said the report is not the bible of what happened over the past five years, contrary to the impression being given by the Labour Party.
Mr Fenech said all the statistics clearly showed that the economy was growing and the country was succeeding in its efforts to attract more foreign direct investment.
Mr Fenech hit out at the opposition for criticising the government over the publication of one correction to an NSO release when over 30 other releases clearly show that this was a genuine mistake.
Mr Fenech spoke at length on Prof. Falzon’s report and used statistics to show that contrary to the conclusions reached by the economist and the statements made by the Labour Party, all sectors of the economy, apart from tourism, had registered substantial growth over the past nine months.
Prime Minister
Lawrence Gonzi
Winding up yesterday’s debate, Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi said the government would be voting on how the country will be administering over Lm1bn in 2007.
He said the budget had a clear direction and the aim was to give back to people some of the wealth that had been created through their own sacrifices.
He said the Opposition Leader used many adjectives to describe the government and the budget but the fact remained that Labour’s criticism was superficial and weak.
“Why does everything have to be negative? Criticise as much as you want but at least give credit for what is good in the budget,” he said.
Dr Gonzi said European Commissioner Joaquín Almunia this week made it clear that Malta was on the right track to join the euro. He said it was true there are obstacles ahead, but the least Labour could do is to be mature and accept this positive analysis.
The Prime Minister said that economy was picking up and although there was still a long way to go, he was confident that the country would register further progress.
“This is a budget upon which we aim to build the future of this country and that of its people. This is a budget for all of us,” he said, adding that the government wanted Malta to become a leader in the Mediterranean in financial services and ICT.