Malta should not be one of those EU states against whom the European Commission will be commencing infringement proceedings because the government has never received notification from the Commission, the Forum Malta fl-Ewropa quoted a government spokesman as saying yesterday.
On Tuesday, the Council of Ministers failed to reach agreement on amendments to the working time directive. At the end of the meeting, Employment Commissioner Vladimir Spidla voiced his disappointment over the failure to reach agreement and declared that the European Commission will commence infringement proceedings against the 23 member states not meeting the requirements of the current directive.
In a statement, the Forum Malta fl-Ewropa said an Education, Youth and Employment Ministry spokesman had said there should be no infringement proceedings against Malta by the European Commission.
During Tuesday’s extraordinary Social Affairs Council meeting, the Council of Ministers failed to reach a political agreement on a draft directive aimed at amending Directive 2003/88/EC concerning certain aspects of the organisation of working time.
This meeting took place after a set of compromise texts were tabled by the Finnish Presidency in an attempt to break the deadlock and settle this longstanding issue.
The main point of divergence was yet again the opt-out clause and the possible phasing of its use, due to the notable differences in the labour market situations and the need of and conditions for maintaining the opt-out clause.
The Working Time Directive currently sets a 48-hour maximum average weekly working time, inclusive of overtime, calculated over a period of four months, together with stipulated rest periods. Nevertheless, member states can seek derogations from the reference period for the application of the rule on the maximum working week and can opt-out from the application of the 48-hour rule if the worker agrees to carry out such work.
The salient features of the Finnish Presidency compromise aimed to tighten the application of the opt-out to ensure that such employee agreements are voluntary and that the employee will not suffer any prejudice by the employer if he or she does not agree to opt-out. The Presidency’s compromise proposed a 60 hours’ capping to weekly working hours, calculated as an average over a three-month period.
That meant a maximum of 20 hours of overtime over a period of seven days. Furthermore, the proposal did not regard the inactive part of the on-call time as working time, unless otherwise decided by law or collective agreement; neither was the inactive part to be taken into account in the calculation of rest periods, unless otherwise provided for in member states.
At the start of the Social Affairs Council meeting, France, Italy and Spain, supported by Belgium, Luxembourg and Cyprus, tabled an amendment demanding a definite deadline over the scrapping of the UK-negotiated opt-out from the
48-hour maximum working week rule.
Since 2004, Malta has always opposed amendments to this effect, given that it favours the retention of the opt-out clause due to the particular nature of its irregular and seasonal trends of its labour market. The United Kingdom once again voiced its support over the retention of the opt-out and garnered enough support from other countries, especially the new member states, to manage to fight off pressure from the blocking minority which favoured a complete abolition of the opt-out provision.
The current EU Presidency was the fifth Presidency to try to break the deadlock of this three-year saga.
To become EU law, the draft proposal must be approved by a qualified majority vote at Council level.