A Libyan man who was given a one-year suspended jail term in March was jailed for one year after a magistrate ruled that he had committed another crime during the operative term of a suspended sentence. At the same time the magistrate cleared him from the charge of relapsing because the prosecution had not proved it.
Abdul Baset Dabia, 37, was originally charged with urging another Libyan to commit a theft, to stealing his partner’s vehicle from Hamrun, to driving the car without a valid driving licence or insurance policy and to relapsing.
During the compilation of evidence against him, the court heard how police constable Ryan Portelli was on patrol on 4 September when he noticed Dabia driving a car that was not registered in his name but was the property of Anna Spiteri. He said the car had an expired road licence and no insurance. The court heard how Ms Spiteri was Dabia’s partner and they lived together in Hamrun.
Mr Portelli told the court that when he stopped Dabia and ordered him to hand over the car keys, the Libyan replied that he did not have keys but had started the car using the wires under the dashboard.
During her testimony, Ms Spiteri said that she could not afford to pay the road licence and insurance for her car and had left it parked in front of her house. She said Dabia usually used the car. She said she filed a police report that the car had gone missing after she returned home and did not find it parked where she had left it in the morning but had told police that she was sure Dabia had taken it.
Handing down his judgement, magistrate Giovanni Grixti said Dabia was not involved in the theft committed by another Libyan man and cleared him of the charge.
On the second charge – that of stealing his partner’s vehicle – magistrate Grixti said that since Ms Spiteri said she knew who had taken her car, this was use without permission rather than theft, so he cleared Dabia of this charge as well.
Magistrate Grixti ruled that in view of his admission to driving the car, he was finding him guilty of driving the car without a road licence and insurance cover and he fined him Lm1,500 and disqualified him from driving for a year.
On the relapsing charge, magistrate Grixti ruled that the prosecution had not brought sufficient evidence to prove this. However, he noted that in March, he had jailed Dabia for one year suspended for a year. “Although this had not been mentioned by the prosecution, the court cannot ignore it,” the magistrate said. He therefore changed the suspended jail term into an effective jail term.
Police inspector Romina Veneziani prosecuted.