A man who, the court heard, punched another man with a knuckle-duster during a fight in Paceville on 3 December 2000 has been jailed for 18 months.
David Vella, 28, from Pembroke, was jailed after the court heard doctors testifying that the injuries sustained by Sean Cassar were caused by “some hard instrument such as a knuckle-duster…(because) the actual naked fist could not cause those semi-linear marks”.
The incident took place on that December afternoon in St Julian’s, when Vella assaulted Mr Cassar after the latter hit his car when he fell off the pavement. In his testimony in court, Mr Cassar said he fell off the pavement when he reacted to help his girlfriend, Michelle Bartolo, after she had been hit by Vella’s car.
In her judgement, magistrate Miriam Hayman said the court was not convinced by the theory of the defence that the injuries sustained by Mr Cassar were the result of three or four rings Vella was wearing. Magistrate Hayman, in fact, quoted the doctor as saying that he “excluded the fact that the marks could have been induced by rings”.
Magistrate Hayman said the court was convinced that Vella had used a knuckle-duster – considered to be a weapon. She said that Vella had already been convicted on serious crimes in the past and had not learnt anything from the various chances he had been given.
She said that this attitude could not be tolerated, especially when this type of incident took place in venues frequented by youngsters who wanted to enjoy themselves, and even more so when the aggression was accompanied by the use of such weapons. “The injuries sustained by Mr Cassar were very serious and the accused’s attitude is not acceptable in a civilised society and cannot be tolerated,” said magistrate Hayman, jailing him for 18 months.
Police Inspector (now Superintendent) Raymond D’Anastas prosecuted.