The Malta Independent 19 November 2026, Thursday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Sunday, 19 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Speaking on the morrow of the death of monetary theorist Milton Friedman, and without ever mentioning his name once, Central Bank Governor Michael C. Bonello on Friday night rendered homage to the great theorist by encapsulating his ideas as the way forward for Malta.

Mr Bonello was speaking at the annual Institute of Financial Services dinner at the Hilton, the only public policy speech he makes in a year.

While Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi, speaking at the same dinner, was rather self-congratulatory, Mr Bonello was more challenging. The euro, he began, is a necessary, but not a sufficient condition for faster growth. “Unless we establish limits on how much we consume... and allocate a greater proportion of the national income to investment, the advantages of euro area membership cannot be fully realised.”

Speaking in the current pre-election campaign environment when frequent references are being made to tax reductions and subsidies, Mr Bonello went against all possible currents in trying to persuade his listeners that politicians should be rallying popular support for the need to strengthen the country’s political capacity to generate wealth on a sustainable basis.

A primary objective, he said, should be the correction of existing macroeconomic imbalances: output growth must match spending growth more closely. A key element in bridging this gap is increased productivity.

The level of productivity has remained roughly unchanged since 2001, and is projected to increase at an annual rate of only one per cent to two per cent in 2007 and 2008. “For a country that is highly dependent on exports,” Mr Bonello said, “this is not good enough.” Not enough people work and, those who do work, do not work long enough: labour participation is still low at 58 per cent compared to an EU average of 70 per cent and the Maltese will have worked seven days less this year than the Dutch, and three days less than the EU average, despite the abolition of compensation for a holiday that falls on the weekend.

Government absorbs almost half of the GDP, the 10th highest percentage ion the EU.

Mr Bonello gave two examples of resource misallocation:

1. The absence of fees for government-supplied health care, regardless of one’s ability to pay.

2. A higher education characterised by a student stipend system that is probably unique.

Recurrent revenue has often not been able to keep up with recurrent expenditure. In 2005 this expenditure amounted to 41 per cent of GDP and revenue at 42 per cent. As a result, the six per cent of GDP allocated to capital spending had to be funded almost entirely by additional borrowing, thus increasing debt-servicing costs.

Investment/GDP ratio has been static at best in recent years. The share of GDP devoted to R&D stood at 0.6 per cent in 2004, compared with an EU average of two per cent.

Malta’s international competitiveness can only be achieved through increasing the size, flexibility and skill level of the labour force.

“The only way forward is to pursue the medium-term objective of a balanced budget over the business cycle by reducing recurrent expenditure, by redistributing the resources available and by making the most efficient use possible of both domestic and EU funds.”

There must be a further contraction of the public sector and a rethinking of the philosophy behind social spending programmes and other transfer payments. “We have to ask,” Mr Bonello added, “whether today’s blanket approach to welfare, higher education and health is promoting a culture of reliance on the State rather than the encouragement of private initiative.”

The time has come, he added, for a radical reform that reconciles the objective of social cohesion with financial sustainability. Non-essential transfer payments should be reduced, especially those that are of a universal nature and do not address a proven need. The introduction of means testing must be seriously considered, accompanied by continued efforts to reduce tax evasion.

In the field of higher education, Mr Bonello says a strong case can be made for at least the partial replacement of grants with loans for students and gave details of what is done in Singapore.

Countries that save or invest more than others, he concluded, will enjoy a higher per capita income. Prosperity tomorrow can only be achieved by making sacrifices today.

He urged a bipartisan, consensual approach to such a strategy, adding it has worked elsewhere and even in Malta’s financial services sector.

Dr Gonzi announced that last week agreement was reached at EU level within the Code of Conduct Group on Business Taxation (made up of representatives of all member States) on Malta’s new tax system. This agreement had previously been cleared in terms of State-aid rules by the College of Commissioners. Following discussions with the industry and the Opposition, Dr Gonzi added, draft legislation will be shortly presented to Parliament.

In conclusion, to revert to Milton Friedman: one suggestion for Mr Bonello’s speech next year: Mr Friedman’s quest to replace anti-poverty programmes with a negative income tax that gives cash to the working poor in the form of an earned-income tax credit, is today favoured by both Right and Left for boosting incomes at the bottom.

  • don't miss