Dolores Cristina (PN)
In opening the debate in the committee stage, Family and Social Solidarity Minister Dolores Cristina said the government had been advised to undertake a smooth transition rather than a “Big Bang approach” in order to help people plan their future and avoid major shocks.
Mrs Cristina said those who are over 55 years of age will not be affected by the reform. She announced that women who will turn 55 on 1 January 2007 may choose to retire on their 61st birthday, rather than when they are 60 years old, as is the current retirement age for women. With regard to the retirement age adjustment, Minister Cristina said that people who were born in 1962 or later will retire at 65 years, those born between 1959 and 1961 will retire at 64 years, those born between 1956-1958 will retire at 63 years, those born between 1952 and 1955 will retire at 62 years and those who were born on 31 December 1951 or before will retire according to the current system.
Karl Chircop (MLP)
Labour spokesman on social protection said he could not understand the urgency with which the government is pushing for the pension reform. He said the population pyramid is stabilising itself notwithstanding the fuss about the changing demography. Infertility rates, he said, will leave an effect only in the long run. He said that there would not be the need for urgency if more women entered the labour market, better child care facilities were provided and the economy were in a state of good health. He also said the government currently makes a Lm9 million surplus as regards NI contributions and pensions.
He said that the National Associations of Pensioners magazine Il-Pensjonant commented that, “the association is not against the reform but expects that it is just with everyone and recognises the needs of the Maltese and Gozitans… the draft does not address sufficiently this problem and no attempt to eradicate anomalies.”
Dr Chircop accused the government of ignoring anomalies regarding British Services Pensions in the pension system. He added that the Alliance of Pensioners’ Associations had said that rights acquired by pensioners should not be undermined and that after the reform, no one should be worse off than before. He said people will be worse off because of the increase in contributions and working life.
The Labour MP complained that the government arbitrarily chose 65 years as the retirement age without backing it up with research. He said this will have serious repercussions in society. He also said that prospective pensioners have to pay 2,080 contributions to be entitled to a pension. This, he said, creates social regression.
Dr Chircop also criticised the government for saying all young people favour the reform, as only the University Students’ Council (KSU) and the National Youth Council (KNZ) said the reform is a good one. Dr Chircop added that the two organisations are notorious for their PN allegiance.
Louis Galea (PN)
Education, Youth and Employment Minister Louis Galea said the pensions issue is very important and that major EU countries have all tackled it. He added that the government is geared towards beginning a process that will be reviewed every five years.
The minister criticised Dr Chircop for not taking the Maltese young people into account. While today’s pensioners wish to improve their situation, he said, young people who are tomorrow’s pensioners are in favour of the government’s proposals.
Minister Galea said the draft is clearly not trying to solve anomalies present in the current pensions regime regarding British Services Pensions and Treasury Pension, which were brought about by the 1970s Labour government. He said the aim of the exercise was not to eliminate anomalies but to guarantee a sustainable and adequate pension for those who still have 20 years of working life ahead of them and those who have just begun working or will do so in the near future.
The Education Minister said that if the government were any less responsible, it would have sat back and done nothing, as the pension problem will not be rampant by the 2008 elections, nor by the 2010 target set by MLP. However, Dr Galea said, we are relatively a bit late in tackling the issue.
The complexity of social benefits and the lack of information in order to deal with them simultaneously has driven the government to tackle each benefit separately and gradually, Minister Galea said. He maintained that the one could only criticise the government for being too cautious. “If we had taken heed of the liberal World Bank-proposed reform, you would have accused us of resurrecting Milton Friedman,” concluded the minister.