The Malta Independent 19 November 2026, Thursday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Wednesday, 22 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

The verdict against a man who is standing trial for the attempted murder of a 24-year-old student when he allegedly hit him on the head with a wooden stick, is expected to be handed down today after the jurors retired to consider their verdict.

Paul Hili, 56, from St Julian’s is standing trial for the attempted murder of Victor Testa at around 8.30pm on 27 February 2003 in St Francis Street in Sliema. He is also accused of contravening a one-way sign and breaching the peace with swearing and shouting.

The second day of the trial by jury yesterday brought the trial to its final stages, with the defence and the prosecution making their final submissions to the panel of jurors before they retired to consider their verdict.

Mr Justice Joseph Galea Debono, who is presiding over the trial, also addressed the jurors yesterday and is expected to continue addressing them this morning. They will then retire.

During his submissions, defence lawyer John Attard Montalto insisted that his client had acted in self-defence and that he had only been trying to defend himself after he felt threatened by the pot the alleged victim had in his hand.

Dr Attard Montalto said the piece of wood that had allegedly been used to inflict the injuries sustained by Mr Testa showed no traces of blood and this was an important element in the case. He said his client had no choice but to use the first thing that came to hand to defend himself against something that could have potentially hurt him.

Prosecuting officer Mark Said said the accused had provoked the whole incident by driving down a road in the wrong direction and then expecting another motorist to reverse the length of the road in order to let him pass the wrong way. He said the self-defence argument made no sense, because he had not been threatened with anything. On the contrary, he said, it was the accused who had threatened the victim.

Dr Said said the fact that no blood had been found on the wooden stick did not necessarily mean that the accused had not used it in an attempt to seriously injure or kill Mr Testa. He said the victim had suffered a 15 per cent disability as a result of being beaten with the wooden stick and insisted that the jurors should find Mr Hili guilty of attempted murder.

If found guilty, Mr Hili faces a maximum of 30 years in prison.

Senior Counsel to the Republic Mark Said prosecuted while Dr John Attard Montalto and Dr Ian Farrugia appeared for the accused. Dr Giannella Caruana Curran and Dr Manwel Mallia appeared in parte civile for Mr Testa.

  • don't miss