The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Thursday, 23 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

A man was jailed for 15 years yesterday after a jury, following four hours of deliberation, found him guilty of the attempted murder of a motorist during a road rage incident in Sliema in January 2003.

Paul Hili, a 56-year-old aircraft technician from St Julian’s, was sentenced after the jury, by eight votes to one, found him guilty of trying to kill student Victor Testa.

The incident took place in St Francis Street when Hili was driving down the one-way street in the wrong direction.

The jurors also unanimously found Hili guilty of contravening a one-way sign and breaching the peace with shouting and swearing. By this verdict, the jurors dismissed the defence theory that Hili was acting in self-defence when he hit the victim with a wooden stick.

During the trial, which began on Monday, the court heard how Mr Testa was returning home from his private accounting lesson when, as he was driving up St Francis Street, another car, driven by Hili, came towards him in the wrong direction. Hili asked Mr Testa to reverse a few feet so he could pass, but he was not satisfied and expected Mr Testa to reverse the entire length of the road.

An argument ensued and Hili got out of his car. The two motorists chased each other around the cars until Mr Testa, who was frightened, decided to take refuge at his aunt’s home a few metres down the road. Mr Testa found no one home and as he was walking back to the car, he picked up a ceramic pot in order to have something with which he could defend himself.

As he got to his car and told Hili to leave him alone, Hili hit him with a wooden stick that looked like the leg of a chair. The court heard how Mr Testa was hit at least three times.

Mr Testa was rushed to hospital and was in danger of losing his life. Doctors who testified during the trial explained that the victim’s skull had been fractured and that the collapsed bones had damaged his brain. A neurosurgeon told the jurors that the victim had suffered a 15 per cent disability as a result of the attack.

In submissions on punishment, just after the jurors returned with their guilty verdict, defence counsel Ian Farrugia said the defence was still convinced that the accused had not intended to kill Mr Hili. Prosecuting officer Mark Said, however, said that this type of incident is on the increase in Malta and the accused should receive an exemplary punishment in an effort to reduce the level of arrogance being shown on the Maltese roads.

He said the punishment should serve as an indication that everyone should respect the law and not that might is right. He said the prosecution was not insisting on either the maximum – 30 years – or the minimum – seven years – but that the punishment reflected the seriousness of the case.

Just before the judge read out the sentence, defence lawyer John Attard Montalto raised a legal point, claiming that the verdict that had been delivered just an hour before was null and void because, he said, there were a number of requisites which a court document such as a verdict had to have. He said that in the verdict on this case, there were no indications as to on what articles of the law his client was being found guilty. He said that these had to be included in every judicial document, including a verdict.

But Senior Counsel to the Republic described this claim as a “poor attempt to undermine the validity of the verdict which had already been registered”. He said verdicts are regulated by three articles in the Laws of Malta and none of the requisites mentioned by the defence were included in these articles.

Mr Justice Joseph Galea Debono ruled against the request of the defence, as all the provisions of the law had been observed. He ruled that the verdict was valid.

Going on to read the judgement, to which the accused listened attentively with his eyes closed and with his head leaning forward, Mr Justice Galea Debono said the Court should set an example and make it abundantly clear that such arrogance on the Maltese roads cannot be tolerated.

“The message that has to come across here is that violence is completely unacceptable,” he said. In his judgement, the judge also remarked on the grip that had already been prepared on the weapon that was used in this case. He condemned Hili to 15 years in jail.

Senior Counsel to the Republic Mark Said prosecuted. Dr John Attard Montalto and Dr Ian Farrugia appeared for Hili while Dr Giannella Caruana Curran and Dr Manwel Mallia appeared in parte civile for Mr Testa.

  • don't miss