The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Thursday, 23 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 20 years ago

The discussion on pension reform continued yesterday morning in parliament, with both sides of the House accusing each other of playing political games.

The MLP busied itself by defending accusations that it was making U-turns on the issue, while the PN rebutted claims that it was trying to implement the pensions reform without consulting the public and that it was eroding the welfare state.

Various MLP speakers also repeatedly reminded the House that it was the MLP that had set up the welfare state. The PN, on the other hand, focused its arguments on the fact that the country needed to reform the pensions system now, before it was too late.

Noel Farrugia (MLP)

Opposition MP Noel Farrugia said that any type of reform should be implemented to address specific needs. “And not to rectify a problem you have created yourselves,” he said.

Mr Farrugia said that implementing the reform proposed by the MLP would mean paying National Insurance contributions for another 10 years or so. “The government is not carrying out reform, it is simply dumping the problem on future generations,” he said.

He said the MLP felt that it made no sense to dump extra burdens on society, especially the younger generations.

“The MLP’s progressive arguments are generating faith among the people and this has been translated into electoral mandates – no one can dispute that the MLP won the MEP and local council elections. We are here to coordinate a wide sense of reform to improve our society which can generate solidarity and a better social-economic environment,” he said.

Mr Farrugia also said that merchandise was increasing in price, but wages were not increasing correspondingly. “We do not criticise for the sake of it, we criticise in order to improve the situation for everyone in Malta,” he said.

Silvio Parnis (MLP)

Opposition MP Silvio Parnis pointed out that it was the MLP that had introduced two-thirds pensions. “But I ask the members of the government bench to recall how they voted on that issue when it was brought up in parliament,” he said.

Mr Parnis also said it was not fair to say the MLP was trying to steer clear of the issue of pension reform. “Again, I remind all those here that it was the MLP that got rid of beggars on the streets, introduced social benefits, created the bonus, children’s allowance and government housing. We have every right to question things,” he said.

Every proposal the MLP put forward was shot down by the government, said Mr Parnis. “So you can criticise, and we can not. Every time we question anything, you say that we are trying to put a spoke in the wheel. We know there is a problem in the pension system and we have discussed it ourselves,” he said.

Clyde Puli (PN)

Nationalist MP Clyde Puli said that pension reform was needed and the bill of law as put forward was a just one for all levels of society. “The opposition always knew this reform was needed. It was only in 2006 that the MLP said that this reform was not needed,” he said.

In the 1998 budget speech, said Mr Puli, the then Finance Minister Leo Brincat said that if Malta did not do anything about pensions by 2010, there would be a crisis.

“So in 1998, when the MLP was in government, they said reform was essential. But now in 2006, they say that this is not the right time, that it’s better to postpone it and discuss it in 2010,” he said.

Everyone had provided feedback, said Mr Puli, even the public, when they came up with a plan. Everyone that is, except the Malta Labour Party.

Leo Brincat (MLP)

Labour MP Leo Brincat said that the government and some sections of the local media were trying to make out that the MLP was trying to put a spoke in the wheel of government plans in regard to pension reform. “But never, at any stage, have we tried to sweep this issue under the carpet. We feel that, like the situation with the reform of financial services, we need consensus on this issue, because it affects this and future generations,” he said.

“Looking at the MLP position paper, one can see that we are not trying to make waves, but have made suggestions based on formulae that can bring about a permanent agreement, instead of changing things around when another government is voted in. Having said that, there is nothing wrong with small refining changes by successive governments,” said Mr Brincat.

He said that had the MLP said it wanted to postpone pension reform by 20 or 30 years, the government would have been right to brand it irresponsible. “All we are saying is that we should talk about it in 2010 – and that is only in four years’ time. And that would be consistent with what I had said in 1998 as Finance Minister,” said Mr Brincat.

“This issue touches every citizen, no matter what his or her background. We cannot limit consultation to constituted bodies; we need consultation with the general public. We go around and speak to people individually, as I’m sure the PN does as well. People do not even know what is being discussed. It’s not the PN’s fault, but we cannot impose this. It is important to have national consensus on the issue,” he said.

Mr Brincat said the MLP felt that the implementation of this new legislation would erode the welfare state, and added: “We could never associate ourselves with anything that will make people’s lives worse.”

Tonio Fenech (PN)

Parliamentary secretary Tonio Fenech was straight out of the blocks to shoot down the MLP’s claim of consistency on the issue. “The MLP has always been consistent on the issue? I’d say that they have performed a huge U-turn. This should be something we work on together,” he said.

Any dreams of having total agreement on the reform process was sheer folly, he said. “Everyone gave their opinion, but a national conference will not bring total consensus. There are going to be differences. At the end of the day, after people give their feedback, a decision must be taken,” said Mr Fenech.

“The MLP says there is no consensus, but there is no consensus simply because the MLP will not even discuss the issue. We are already late, we cannot wait another five years. The MLP has made a U-turn for political convenience – it’s as simple as that. That is not political spin at all. Those are facts,” he said.

Between 1998 and 2004, said Mr Fenech, the MLP suggested that change was needed. “But you performed a U-turn by saying that a crisis will only come about in the period 2015 to 2030. You are the only organisation that is supposed to represent people that has not said anything except that the issue should be discussed in 2010,” he said.

Louis Galea (PN)

Education Youth and Employment Minister Louis Galea said that the issue of pension reform should not be used to play a political game.

“And that is what the MLP is trying to do, instead of properly entering into discussions to get to the root of the problem, as it is their duty to do. The MLP has a duty to take part in order to help the people of Malta and Gozo face the future and help safeguard the well being of future generations. They should contribute,” said Dr Galea.

He said that the government had been cautious in its approach of pension reform, with the commissioning of various studies and reports to gauge the repercussions of any decisions taken. “This matter was put on the agenda by the 1996-98 MLP government and it was followed up by the subsequent Eddie Fenech Adami government, which built on the progress made by Labour. It is an ongoing issue and it must be addressed,” said Dr Galea.

He said that two reports commissioned during the MLP administration showed that there was a need for the issue to be addressed. Far from eroding the welfare state, he said, the PN government was trying to improve it by ensuring that pensions are sustainable. “It is the MLP that is eroding the welfare system because they are not doing their duty to contribute to finding a solution to the problem,” said Dr Galea.

The government, he said, was proud that Malta had a strong social model that is more generous than countries that are better off. “We need a strong social safety net. Health, education, disabilities, the elderly – these issues all need to be addressed. This is a progressive proposal, it doesn’t only address today’s generation, it also looks to the future. Not only is it not eroding the welfare state – it will improve it,” said Dr Galea.

He closed with a parting shot: “This morning we have played the game in committee stage, but tonight we must play by the rules to reach a final conclusion.”

  • don't miss