Switzerland votes in a referendum today on whether to give economic aid to the European Union’s 10 youngest members, an initiative alternately described as neighbourly goodwill and a bribe to keep poor Eastern European workers out of Switzerland.
Switzerland and the EU agreed on the aid plan, which was linked to a package of cooperation deals on issues ranging from energy to open borders, in difficult negotiations that concluded in 2004. Under Switzerland’s brand of direct democracy, any legislation that is challenged in petitions by at least 50,000 citizens must be put to a referendum.
The payments would go some way to compensating the new EU members for the fact that only a fixed number of their workers are allowed into Switzerland until 2011, unlike those from the original 15 EU countries who are free to seek jobs here in unlimited numbers.
Already, one in four of Switzerland’s wage earners is foreign.
Under the government-sponsored law, Switzerland would spend one billion Swiss francs ($800 million) over five years on the eight Eastern European and two Mediterranean countries that joined the bloc on 1 May 2004.
Some 4.8 million voters are eligible to vote. Recent surveys indicate a majority in favour of the spending plan, but a large undecided vote could change the outcome.
Opponents argue that Switzerland is being forced to pay for EU expansion and that approving the law, which allows the government to authorise more funds over the next 10 years, could set a dangerous precedent for future demands from Brussels.
“We’re not voting about one billion (Swiss francs), we’re voting on a law that will open the floodgates to unlimited further payments without the consent of the people,” said Hans Fehr, a legislator with the nationalist Swiss People’s Party and the head of CINS, a conservative campaign to safeguard Switzerland’s independence.
Backers say the funds will help reduce income gaps in Europe and ultimately benefit the Swiss economy by strengthening Eastern European economies that promise to be important future trading partners.
Most of the money – around 490 million francs ($395 million; 305 million euro) – would go toward infrastructure, education and trade development projects in Poland, with Hungary and the Czech Republic receiving 130 million francs ($105 million) and 110 million francs ($90 million) respectively. The remaining 270 million francs ($220 million) will flow to Lithuania, Slovakia, Latvia, Estonia, Slovenia, Cyprus and Malta.
“If the law is confirmed on Sunday, the result will be that we’ll have to pay and pay and pay. Next it will be for Romania, Bulgaria, Croatia, Macedonia, Serbia, Montenegro and all the other eastern countries up to Ukraine,” Fehr told The Associated Press. “It’s a bottomless barrel.”
One spectre repeatedly raised by backers of the plan is that Brussels could take a new, hard line in future bilateral negotiations with Switzerland if voters veto the payments. Cooperation agreements on transit, energy and research issues between the neutral country and the EU are all currently under negotiation.
In particular, the EU could enforce a rule requiring all goods crossing its borders to be announced 24 hours in advance. The rule is currently suspended, but its implementation could spell trouble for Switzerland, which relies on trade with the EU.