Do you feel that Maltese fishermen are embracing EU policies? Are they being educated to think in the spirit of the policies?
I know that Maltese fishermen are very similar to their European counterparts in other member states. Their capabilities are identical to those of other Mediterra-nean EU member states and similar to those of fishermen of the same categories of vessels in other EU states. A certain percentage of these fishermen are not of a high educational standard, but this is also the situation in other member states. Their academic capabilities do not necessarily affect their
ability to embrace EU policies.
There are many ways in which they can obtain the necessary information on developments related to EU policies and regulations. The general media, and their association with cooperatives, help them to identify areas where developments occur. These fishermen will then rectify their knowledge through direct questions to the officials involved in the Fisheries and Aquaculture Division.
Maltese fishermen are quite well-versed in certain aspects of the current EU policies. Just to mention a couple of issues: the EU, in its 2002 reform of the Common Fisheries Policy, set off a Mediterranean Action Plan and also the need of involvement of the stakeholders in the decision-making process. This second issue resulted in the formation of the Regional Advisory Councils (RAC). Maltese fishermen had been talking about the need to control the number of fisheries in the Mediterranean for the last 10 years and they have been indicating certain gears and fishing methods as exerting too much pressure on existing stocks.
This is a position that has been mentioned by representatives of Maltese fishermen a number of times when they have participated in the formation of MEDISAMAK (Mediterranean Association of Professional Fishermen) and in other meetings relating to the preparation of the Mediterranean RAC in Brussels. Maltese fishermen are well aware of participation of stakeholders in the decision-making process as they have been participating in the local Fisheries Advisory Board for the past 10 years in fact they are very positive about the formation of the Mediterranean RAC, unlike most of their
Mediterranean counterparts. I think this shows that Maltese fishermen are very much aware of EU policies and are well prepared to move with the necessary trends.
How is total allowable catch being introduced in Malta?
Total Allowable Catch (TAC) was introduced in Malta well before the EU. In 1995, the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT) introduced this concept of TAC to blue fin tuna fisheries in the Mediterranean and the Atlantic. This TAC came into force in 1999 but was based on part of the catches of 1993 and 1994. Malta still fishes blue fin tuna under this catch allocation and this year, during the ICCAT meeting in Dubrovnik in Croatia, Malta’s catch allocation will be included in the general EU quota, since we now form part of the European Union.
At present there are no other stocks fished in the Mediterranean that are covered by TACs and quotas. However, Malta is also involved in Hoki quotas in the New Zealand Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). This means that Maltese-flagged vessels fish Hoki in the New Zealand EEZ, using Maori quotas. These quotas are regulated by the New Zealand government officials.
How will the Common Maritime Policy affect the fishing practices of Maltese fishermen?
It is very possible that the Common Maritime Policy (CMP), proposed through the green paper, may affect the fishing practices of Maltese fishermen. The green paper status indicates that this proposal is still at the consultation stage and, in fact, we have one year in which to present all our concerns, ideas and counter proposals. The CMP will involve a large number of sectors, such as the environment, research, regional policy, transport, enterprise and competition, governance, jurisdiction and also fisheries.
Fisheries is one of the stakeholders, but the CMP aims to tackle the maritime environment in a comprehensive and holistic manner. It intends to highlight the interaction between sectors. Fisheries will definitely have a lot to offer in the discussion and maturation of this policy.
A number of experiences already gained in the Fisheries sector, such as
the ecosystem-based approach, the regional and international shared management of stocks and experiences in governance and jurisdiction will serve as a reference to the development of this comprehensive policy.
It is very possible that the end result will suggest a form of spatial planning from which fisheries will benefit by enjoying a status within these plans. Better management of our seas may also benefit fisheries in terms of reduced physical interaction with other forms of maritime transport.
The maintenance of the environmental sustainability of the seas is an insurance for the existence of fisheries, as these depend on the ability of ecosystems to generate and maintain fishable stocks.
The introduction of a medicine box has been a controversial issue among fishermen. Are they qualified to use the equipment in the box? If not, are they liable for damages if something happens through the use of the emergency kit? Are any fishermen trained in first aid?
The medicine box issue has been raised a number of times. However, the situation is very clear. Any fishing vessel that travels into waters where it will not be in a position to assure medical treatment to the fishermen on board has to have an extensive medical equipment box, stocked with all the medicine and equipment indicated by the relevant Council Directive.
In the history of this directive, fishermen of other member states have also attempted to turn it into a controversy, but the answer is simple: the life of a fisherman may be saved through the long-distance guided use of the medicine and equipment contained in the kit.
The captain of each fishing vessel is fully responsible for the well-being of his crew and therefore his first aid abilities, or the first aid abilities of one of his crew, are his responsibility. The Fisheries Division has attempted to set up sources for master fishermen and their crews.
Are all fishermen certified navigators?
A number of Maltese fishermen are certified navigators but this number is definitely not the majority. Maltese fishermen, like many other fishermen in other EU states, are capable of great seamanship and although they are not certified navigators, they are as capable as those who are, and have been operating for a great number of years. This situation is not unique to Malta or to the Mediterranean.
The same categories and classes of vessels in all member states are mainly mastered by fishermen of long experience, great seamanship but few or no certificates.
In some member states, the masters of these vessels were awarded a certificate to skipper only their own vessels.
These certificates were awarded to them on the basis of their long experience at sea. In other member states, capable fishermen who did not have the required educational level to enable them to participate in navigational certification courses enjoyed the possibility of experience at sea within established institutions such as fisheries inspectorates, maritime navies or military navies. This was not available in Malta and Maltese fishermen do not, as yet, have specific courses to attend.
Do you feel that such policies are compatible with the artisan nature of the Maltese fisheries sector?
The artisanal nature of fisheries is not a Maltese prerogative. Vessels in the majority of the fleets of other member states are smaller than 12 metres and fisheries in most EU Mediterranean states are analogous or identical to Maltese fisheries.
The policies contained in the CFP aim at the sustainability of fisheries and therefore artisanal and industrial fisheries should both benefit. The principals governing fisheries are equal to both artisanal and industrial fisheries.
Within the regulations there is recognition of the smaller sectors of the fleets. It is a known fact that regulations enforce the use of satellite monitoring systems of vessels larger than 15 metres. Catch logbooks are required only in vessels that are larger than 10 metres. Catches that are below 50 kilogrammes do not need to be registered in logbooks. All these exceptions indicate that the regulations prepared to implement the policies have taken into consideration small vessels and their effort.
Has the ministry thought about regularising the status of fishermen?
This question is not very clear. The status of fishermen is a well-established one. Fishermen are a group of people that have the ability to catch fish. These people either own fishing vessels or form part of crews on board fishing vessels. Normally, fishermen in Malta are self-employed, even if they form part of a crew. This situation arises in view of the system of repartitioning of the value of catches. This means that most crews do not work for a fixed salary but they are involved in a sharing arrangement with the
master and/or owner of the vessel of the profits of each fishing trip. This form of sharing is not unique to Malta.
Will the retirement age of fishermen go down to 55?
I cannot understand the reason for this question. There may have been a situation in other member states whereby social assistance and benefits were directed at the pre-retirement of fishermen through the Financial Instrument for Fisheries Guidance (FIFG). To my knowledge there has never been a regulation enforcing retirement ages. This is a policy that is within the competence of the member state and I do not recall that the Maltese Government has ever enforced pre-retirement in fisheries. The retirement age of Maltese fishermen will definitely follow the
policies that the Maltese
government will publish with regard to the retirement of workers in general.
Is the government considering organising a course that trains fishermen, as opposed to the Higher National Diploma Course in Fisheries Science which trained operators?
The Higher National Diploma Course in Fisheries Sciences for the Mediterranean was a well organised and necessary course. This course was a basic technical and scientific course that did not specifically aim at producing Fisheries Officers but personnel with a sound know-ledge of fisheries. The participation of young fishermen in such a course will ensure the very sound technical and scientific formation of a new generation of fishermen.