Benjamin Angel, the Cabinet member of Commissioner for Economic and Monetary Affairs Joaquin Almunia and who is responsible for the enlargement of the eurozone, yesterday said he was reasonably optimistic that Malta will manage to satisfy the criteria to adopt the single currency on 1 January 2008.
Speaking to journalists, Dr Angel said he could not promise certainty but said that Malta was on the right track towards satisfying the necessary criteria. He said Malta’s changeover plan was “very comprehensive and detailed” and that it was one of the best changeover plans when compared to all the other countries
adopting the euro in 2008.
Dr Angel said the commission was pleased to see that Malta was taking the adoption of the euro seriously and warned that without information the transition from one currency to the other would not be smooth.
He said he was “very satisfied” with what has been achieved so far.
Dr Angel said Malta still had to satisfy three Maastricht criteria before adopting the euro in 2008. He said one was spending two years within the exchange rate mechanism which Malta will satisfy by May 2007, the inflation rate and the fiscal deficit.
He said it was important that results are sustainable and that the results are long term and not a result of one-off measures. He said one of the only elements in which Malta is still lagging behind is that of Automated Teller Machines distributing the euro.
Another guest speaker in yesterday’s first national conference on the introduction of the new currency was Harald Zulauf, the chief executive officer of Media Consulta International, the agency that is responsible for the public relations of various EU institutions. He said he was very pleased with the “professional and wide-ranging” information campaign that the National Euro Changeover Committee has embarked upon. He said the excellent turnout at the conference showed that the changeover has attracted considerable interest.
Asked about the advantages and disadvantages of introducing the euro, Mr Zulauf said the euro stands for prosperity, wealth and increased transparency. Moreover, foreigners coming to Malta will have the opportunity to pay with the single currency instead of changing currencies and thus Malta can compete more in the globalised world.
On the negative aspect, Mr Zulauf said that more than actually negative, one can better describe them as difficulties. He said the rise in the cost of certain products and services is surely something that has to be dealt with and added that the way the NECC and the government has decided to deal with this was positive.
Professor Karl Kollmannn, an advisor to the Vienna Chamber for Workers and Employees said that when Austria introduced the euro, people were not so happy with the single currency but as time passed, they started to get used to it. He said there are no risks in adopting the euro but stressed that all the possible information has to be made available. Prof. Kollmann said he was all out for a name-and-shame policy, “saying this is the price sinner”. He said this helps build and improve consumer confidence.
But Luc Hendrickx, the Director of Enterprise Policy and External Relations within the European Association of Crafts, Small- and Medium-sized Enterprises (UEAPME), did not agree with a name-and-shame policy. “There are and will be abuses. There are good and bad boys everywhere. It is in the retailers’ interest to retain their market share by abiding by the rules,” he said.
Mr Hendrickx said the introduction of the euro is certainly beneficial to small- and medium-sized enterprises. He spoke about the importance of good communication with business owners and said that Malta was well on track, especially with the memorandum of understanding between the government and the Chamber of Small- and Medium-sized Enterprises (GRTU).
Emanuel Constans, the ombudsman within the Economy, Finance and Industry Ministry in France said it was imperative to pre-empt the problems that might arise through euro adoption. He said perception of price increases may last long and will take time to pass.
Dr Angel agreed with this and added that it was important to nip misconceptions at the bud. He said prices in various countries increased in items which are not so important for the country’s retail price index but such increase was nonetheless significant for people because it related to daily items such as newspapers and coffee, for example.
PM Lawrence Gonzi
Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi delivered the closing speech at yesterday’s conference. He said the adoption of the euro was the “next logical step for Malta” following European Union membership in 2004. He said that from the outset, beyond the introduction of the euro, the government realised that the criteria to join the eurozone were important for the country in order to be competitive. He said these criteria were vital for the country’s success and satisfying these criteria was a major challenge.
“The deficit stands at 2.7 per cent of the gross domestic product and public debt has started to edge downwards. We are reasonably confident that a sustainable rate of inflation is achievable by the time we request another report towards the end of the first half of 2007. We believe we have managed to achieve what many people thought was unachievable. The results speak for themselves,” he said.
The latest Eurobarometer poll has shown that for the first time, the majority of the Maltese are now in favour of the introduction of the euro. He said various surveys are indicating that the biggest concern of the Maltese people in this whole process is the possible increase in prices during or after the changeover process.
He said the NECC is about to launch an information campaign aimed at businesses to ensure they are informed on the way prices should be displayed during the voluntary dual display period and, once a positive decision on Malta’s adoption of the euro has been taken, also during the mandatory dual display period.
“I am convinced that the absolute majority of our businesses are operated by honest citizens. It is also in their own long-term interest to ensure that consumers feel comfortable buying from them. We shall be supporting these people. However, we shall also be tough with those who might decide to take unfair advantage during this sensitive transition period. We will not allow the few to give a bad name to the entire business community. We owe this to consumers, to the business community itself and to the country at large,” he said.
Dr Gonzi said the government and NECC will be striving to ensure that the changeover process will be smooth for everyone. He said the government also intends to introduce the euro into school curricula, so school children of all levels will be given every opportunity to familiarise themselves with the new currency.
MLP Leader Alfred Sant
Opposition Leader Alfred Sant insisted that the biggest challenge to convert from the lira to the euro remains that of consumer protection and that the authorities have to guard against an upward creep in consumer prices.
Dr Sant said various studies have shown that there was little or no upward affect on prices when the euro changeover took place. He said that unfortunately, these studies were conducted in the interests of the government and financial systems that were responsible for the changeover and little participation by consumer organisations.
The Labour leader said the opposition still believes that the euro should have been adopted when the country’s growth rate would have reached the four per cent mark. However, Dr Sant declared – as he has done in the past – that the Malta Labour Party, when and if in government, will continue to implement the euro adoption at the set date. “It would create too much economic upheaval and would not be in the national interest were one to reverse the current ongoing process.”
Dr Sant said the introduction of the euro is all about the sustainability of public finances and about the sustainability of a number of macroeconomic objectives such as low inflation, external trade balance, economic growth and the diversification of economic activity.
“Labour wanted Malta to be well prepared and change its course of profligacy to prudent management without submitting the Maltese society to undue hardship. I know that some will say that this is further dooming and glooming by the opposition. Yet the experience we have been through in the past three years – related to prices of food, medicines, educational and sundry household services, not to mention accommodation – certainly validates what we have said for a long time about the real nature of economic competitiveness and inflation in a micro economy,” he said.
He added: “My conviction is that we still need to do much more to ensure that by the time the euro is introduced, we will have the best administrative apparatus to dampen and control any unjustified inflationary effects.”
Dr Sant criticised the NECC for not having a consumer representative for discussions on the euro changeover process.
NECC chairman
Joseph FX Zahra
NECC chairman Joseph FX Zahra said the NECC was presently working on its final set of guidelines to address pricing strategies of the inflation sensitive low-value, high-volume products and services, such as SMS prices. He said such guidelines will not be incorporated into the legislation as “we have no intention to tamper with market forces”, but it will serve to provide options and recommendations to companies so that they can remain as revenue neutral as possible during the changeover.”
Mr Zahra also spoke about the FAIR initiative which is a commitment whereby retailers with the FAIR sticker on their premises promise not to increase prices purely as a result of the changeover and to implement the dual display correctly and to receive the necessary training on aspects related to the changeover.
PS Tonio Fenech
Opening the conference, parliamentary secretary Tonio Fenech said joining the euro on 1 January 2008 seems an achievable task which effectively means that there are only 400 days to go. He said an important issue which requires continued attention relates to the false perception of price increases linked to the introduction of the euro. He said 69 per cent of the Maltese believe that the euro introduction will bring about abuses by retailers.
“We must do everything we can to combat this false perception that the euro means higher prices. It is a battle for the hearts and minds of Maltese consumers and losing it will mean very serious consequences in terms of consumers’ attitude towards the euro. Euro adoption is our next step. Let’s write history together in a way that all Maltese will feel proud to have achieved a smooth and seamless changeover,” he said.