The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Tuesday, 28 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 13 years ago

The trial of three members of the German Cap Anamur humanitarian organisation began yesterday in Agrigento, Sicily, where the organisation’s president Elias Bielder, the captain of the organisation’s eponymous aid ship, Stefan Schmidt, and first officer Vladimir Daschkewitsch face charges of aiding and abetting illegal immigration.

Malta had been dragged into a legal and diplomatic wrangle in June 2004, just a month after it joined the European Union, between itself, Germany and Italy over the Cap Anamur’s cargo of 37 irregular migrants.

After a stay at the Malta Drydocks for repairs, the Cap Anamur left Malta and came across a boatload of migrants calling for help from a stranded, non-seaworthy rubber dinghy, which the ship proceeded to pick up and carry toward Sicily.

When the ship requested entry into Sicilian waters, Italian authorities had tried to pass the buck to Malta and demanded Malta take responsibility for the migrants, on the basis that the migrants had been rescued from Maltese waters and that the ship had passed through Maltese waters, with the migrants aboard, en route to Sicily. A diplomatic standoff ensued, which saw Malta holding its ground, unrelenting in the face of Italian pressure. The Home Affairs Ministry at the time had made it clear that the ship had never requested assistance from Malta. Nor had the ship informed Malta it had irregular migrants aboard or that the vessel had rescued people dispersed at sea.

Malta also argued that if the migrants had been rescued close to the Libyan coast, international rules provided that the ship’s captain should have transported them to Libya.

Italy had also argued that Germany – since the ship was German – held responsibility for the ship’s human cargo.

But the standoff continued for some three weeks, with Malta, Germany and Italy refusing to budge. “Nobody should expect that, days after this ship rescued these people without informing the Maltese authorities and now that it is off the coast of Sicily, Malta should take responsibility for these immigrants,” the Justice and Home Affairs Ministry had stated at the time.

After 21 days of idling near the Sicilian coast, Italy buckled under pressure from the United Nations and the Vatican, and pleas from the ship’s captain that he was concerned about the well-being of the migrants and that several were threatening to throw themselves overboard, access to the Sicilian port of Empedocle was granted.

On arrival in port, however, the ship was seized and the three crew members were promptly arrested on charges of aiding and abetting illegal immigration, only to be later released.

Cap Anamur is believed by the Italian authorities to have used the African migrants to make a point against Italian asylum policies. The Italian authorities insist that while the ship had claimed the migrants were legitimate Sudanese refugees deserving asylum, most in fact had been economic refugees from Ghana and Nigeria. The Cap Anamur staff deny the accusations, saying their only aim was to bring the migrants to safety and give them the right to claim asylum in Europe if they needed it.

In a statement issued yesterday, the Cap Anamur organisation said: “The accused acted as it did for humanitarian reasons and in no way broke Italian laws. Having confidence in Italian law, we assume that the charges will be dropped and that the process will end with a clear acquittal. The rescue of refugees can in no way be considered a criminal offence.”

After yesterday’s hearing, the cross-examination of witnesses will be heard on 11 December, but the case could likely go on for several years. Some 20 German human rights organisations yesterday called for a quick end to the proceedings.

  • don't miss