The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Wednesday, 29 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

On Monday, Parliament began discussing a bill to create an Administrative Review Tribunal and to streamline and ensure uniformity of the various administrative tribunals.

Parliamentary Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici described the proposed bill as ambitious and far-reaching.

The clauses will be introduced gradually, he said, adding that the bill lists 57 administrative tribunals set up in terms of primary legislation and a further 13 set up by subsidiary legislation.

Each of these entities would fall under a Tribunal of Administrative Review, but to guarantee efficiency this will not happen immediately.

Dr Mifsud Bonnici said tribunals had a number of advantages over the law courts: they provided expert knowledge in technical matters and best practice, and proceedings before tribunals were cheap and were concluded in a short time.

He said the administrative tribunal was flexible, did not have a backlog and its decisions were not bound by precedent. Also, the tribunal was not as rigid as the law courts.

Dr Mifsud Bonnici said the bill would lead to the centralisation and uniformity of decisions. The tribunals would have to respect the parties’ right to a fair hearing, including the principles of natural justice, which will be concluded within a reasonable timeframe, and to ensure procedural equality and equal opportunities for the parties to present their case.

The bill, he added, stipulates that all the proceedings have to be held in public and that the reasons behind a particular judgment – albeit not in detail – had to be given.

Opposition justice spokesman Anglu Farrugia said the opposition agreed with this bill.

However, he said, there were some issues that it felt had to be addressed.

The opposition, said Dr Farrugia, felt that instead of a review tribunal, there should be a ordinary court presided over by a judge.

He said that the issue of decisions being enforced – something that did not always happen – had to be discussed.

He said the public’s questions had to be answered, referring a number of times to the award of a contract for the cleaning of the law courts that had been given to a company with links to a convicted criminal.

Dr Farrugia asked various questions about the government’s position on this matter, adding that he is still awaiting replies to parliamentary questions he had asked earlier.

At the start of Monday’s sitting, the House paid tribute to the late Dr Jimmy Farrugia, former speaker of the House and Nationalist politician, who passed away on 25 November.

  • don't miss