The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Thursday, 30 November 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 21 years ago

Controversy ensued in Tuesday evening’s parliamentary sitting, as the opposition MPs had their say on the Administrative Justice Bill’s second reading. “It is against the Constitution,” “Contrary to legal principles,” “Gives no remedy to the citizens in administrative cases,” were among the comments heard and elaborated upon.

Gavin Gulia (MLP)

Gavin Gulia, MLP main spokesperson on Home Affairs, while agreeing with the bill in principle, had reservations with regard to the fact that the suggested administrative tribunal could only provide remedies through declarations, which are not directly enforceable. He also commented that creating a tribunal, instead of a court having specific administrative jurisdiction, was nonsensical and was not logically or economically viable.

Justyne Caruana (MLP)

Giving a technically critical view of the bill’s intricacies, Labour’s spokesperson on Youth, Sport and Culture, Justyne Caruana highlighted the difficulties that would be faced in the interpretation of the legal principles mentioned in the bill, when the same principles are not mentioned in others. She gave examples of where these principles were not applied in the bill itself, such as the fact that the tribunal would be chaired by a judge or magistrate appointed by the President on the advice of the Prime Minister, instead of being appointed by the Chief Justice. Ms Caruana also stressed that tribunal fees should be minimal so that recourse to administrative remedies would be for all; as well as the need for there to be more services provided at the courts in Gozo.

Joe Brincat (MLP)

“A tribunal that makes declaratory statements, but does not have legal force (‘bite’) is not a court and does not give effective remedy,” Joe Brincat, the opposition’s main spokesperson for the Environment and National Heritage asserted. Continuing on Ms Caruana’s line of thought, Dr Brincat also made reference to the tribunal’s chairperson’s appointment, the submission of fees, as well as the judicial review clause in the bill, which did not empower the application of said review.

He then went on to recommend that the period of prescription be prolonged when the case concerns terms of general applicability, and that the work that is done by the Ombudsman should also be applied at the tribunal, so that work is not duplicated.

Jose Herrera (MLP)

Labour MP Jose Herrera was more vociferous about his concerns. “I disagree totally with the basis for this law – it is defective.” Though he felt that administrative remedy was a step in the right direction for Maltese democracy, he believed that it should not be implemented in this way. In praising Chief Justice De Gaetano, he said that they both agreed that the administration of justice should not be divided into such tiny segments for such a small country. “It is against the spirit of our Constitution,” he said, adding that a specific court should be given jurisdiction over Administrative Justice. He dubbed the judicial review in the bill as “overlapping Babylon” and could not understand the composition of the tribunal, as it made no sense.

“The Judiciary cannot be under the pendulum of the Executive – look deeper into the issue and reform the judicial structure, but not in this way, otherwise we will change it!” he warned.

  • don't miss