The debate regarding the Administrative Justice Bill continued in Parliament on Wednesday, with both sides of the House calling for more transparency and consultation.
Tonio Borg (PN)
Different governments passed laws under which issues could not be solved within common law courts but through administrative tribunals, Justice and Home Affairs Minister Tonio Borg said. Various tribunals have been set up under various laws passed in Parliament.
Dr Borg explained that one of the aims of the proposed bill is to revise the principles in administrative tribunals and write them down into law. Tribunals in the First Scheme, he added, must be tied to principles of good administrative behaviour.
The minister pointed out that documents relevant to a particular case must be made public, and reasons must be given with each sentence passed by the tribunal. Otherwise, he added, the concerned party would not be able to appeal.
A second aim of the bill, said Dr Borg, is to place all tribunals under one main tribunal. Therefore, the workings of all the administrative tribunals will be gradually transferred to the administrative review tribunal, he said. Through this process, he added, we will not be straying away from the courts of justice, but coming closer. This is something new and we must be careful, although prudence does not mean being conservative, he affirmed.
Dr Borg emphasised the need for centralisation. The more centralisation, the less spending, he stated.
The minister concluded his remarks by stating the bill is a good one although the government is open to more proposals.
Marie Louise Coleiro Preca (MLP)
With reference to the minister’s concluding remarks, the Labour MP asked, “Who was consulted in the whole process?” She added that laws must be understood by people and be tools for people, not simply be made by lawyers in Parliament and interpreted in court.
Ms Coleiro pointed out there will be one tribunal for so many tribunals. With regard to who will preside over such a tribunal, she affirmed what Labour MP Jose Herrera had noted in a previous sitting: i.e., that a judge is not an ex-judge, and a magistrate is not an ex-magistrate. Ex-judges and ex-magistrates cannot be regulated by the Constitution.
The system must be transparent, she added, but too much depends on the minister, with no space for consultation with other entities. This does not allow or promote transparency, the Labour MP said. In addition, she explained, it is evident that there is no room for consultation because the minister will be deciding all, she further noted.
Ms Coleiro Preca also pointed out necessary reforms must be made regarding legal aid, because justice must be made accessible to all. She also noted that some laws relating to certain administrative tribunals must be revised.
The Labour MP concluded her remarks asking the government to reconsider various aspects of the bill proposed.
Alfred Sant (MLP)
Opposition Leader Alfred Sant referred to a specific case which took place four years ago whereby Mario Camilleri, presently an inmate, allegedly bribed a judge and chief justice. This case, he said, shocked the judicial system.
Dr Sant also referred to the Law Courts cleaning contract that had been given to a company with links to the same inmate. He criticised the government for its lack of transparency in dealing with the case.
The Labour leader once again emphasised what he called the government’s lack of transparency. No political or administrative responsibility was assumed, he said. In addition, he added, the same people who were involved publicly in such an affair dare not put themselves under public scrutiny.
Mario de Marco (PN)
Nationalist MP Mario de Marco said the bill is aimed at further developing administrative rights. He added the bill is aimed at serving the people, and promoting justice under whichever government.
Dr de Marco mentioned that court procedures are inaccurate and are sometimes costly. Justice needs time and money. Tribunal procedures are cheaper, involving more expertise, he pointed out.
Part of the process involved the creation of the Ombudsman, which had proven successful, noted Dr de Marco. Therefore, the aim of this bill is to continue building on what is already there. Consolidating the principles followed by tribunals – the right to fair and equal hearing for both parties concerned, and the principles of natural justice – is also important.
With regard to Ms Coleiro Preca’s criticism about judges, ex-judges, and magistrates, Dr de Marco pointed out that these people are equipped with experience, knowledge and know-how. The system will not unite all tribunals immediately, he added.
Referring to expert assistants, he said these will carry out consultative roles. However, he asked whether they will be present for each session, or only when they think necessary. In addition, he concluded, consultation must be transparent and therefore made public.
Jason Azzopardi (PN)
Nationalist MP Jason Azzopardi noted that the bill has far-reaching consequences. The tribunal needs years to consolidate. He mentioned the French tribunal model, which, he said, has been tried and tested, and was found to be strong and respected. Years have to pass before this goal can be reached in Malta, but steps have to be taken one at a time, he said.
Parliament adjourned until Monday 4 December at 6pm with Dr Azzopardi still in possession.