The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Saturday, 2 December 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 21 years ago

A court of appeal ruled yesterday that a collective agreement reached between Malta Shipyards Ltd and the General Workers Union was binding, as it is had the same validity as any other contract.

The union had appealed against a judgment by the First Hall of the Civil Court.

The appeal court, presided over by Chief Justice Vincent Degaetano, Mr Justice Albert J Magri and Mr Justice Tonio Mallia, heard that Malta Shipyards had filed a writ against the GWU claiming that the union had broken the collective agreement signed by the two sides.

The shipyards said that in January last year it had received an email from the GWU in which the union announced it was taking immediate industrial action. The company said that in doing so, the union was in breach of the collective agreement.

The union replied that it had not violated the said agreement.

The First Hall of the Civil Court had ruled in favour of the shipyards, a decision against which the union appealed.

Yesterday, the court of appeal said the union’s submission that the collective agreement was an industrial peace treaty was based wholly upon English case law, but this was not necessarily applicable in the Maltese context.

Local industrial law was mostly founded upon English law, but elements pertaining to contracts and their enforcement were totally different from those that are applicable in England.

The court said that Maltese law regarding contractual agreements was based upon Roman law and the Code Napoleon. The difference, it said, lay in the fact that Malta is a civil law country while England is a common law country.

In Maltese law, there is no understanding between all social partners that a collective agreement was merely a peace treaty that is legally unenforceable.

The court said that every valid contract was binding upon the parties concerned unless the law provided

otherwise.

There is no mention of any exception to the general law of contracts in the case of collective agreements.

As a result, the collective agreement had the force of law on the parties to it and was legally enforceable, just like all other contracts.

The GWU’s appeal was rejected and the case was sent back to the first court to be continued.

Lawyer Andrew Borg Cardona appeared for Malta Shipyards while Dr Aron Mifsud Bonnici and Dr Marvic Debarro appeared for the GWU.

  • don't miss