A court ruling pronounced last week was one of the best bits of common sense I have ever heard in that mad, mad building.
Make no mistake, although I no longer report from there on a regular basis, I can tell you that I have seen my fair share of madness in there, crazy decisions and downright crazy people.
But last week – and I must reserve praise for him – Magistrate Lawrence Quintano handled a delicate case in the most professional, yet down to earth manner I have ever seen.
Three girls stood accused – aged 18, 17 and 14 respectively (two of them sisters) – of various snatch and grabs incidents. In the first sitting, the girls were charged and pleaded guilty, incurring the wrath of Dr Quintano. He said that people could no longer plead guilty in his courtroom and expect to get off with a lighter sentence than they would otherwise get. To this effect, he appointed a probation officer to look into the case and ordered that the youngsters be home by 8pm.
On Tuesday, the court reconvened to hear the probation officer’s report; he said the girls’ attitude seemed to have improved, but that two weeks was not nearly enough to assess them properly. It was immediately clear that Dr Quintano was not satisfied and genuinely wanted to try and make a difference to these girls’ lives. Here, one must also reserve praise for defence counsel Franco Debono, who agreed with the court that it was in the best interest of the girls.
To this effect, another hearing has been scheduled for late January and February to have a better assessment of the girls’ behaviour.
As the youngest has a history of playing truant, Dr Quintano is phoning the school’s head himself every few days to make sure that the child (because that’s what you are at 14) is attending school. He warned her not to slip up as he was keeping a personal tab on her activities. She smiled sheepishly, and interpreting her actions – she was in awe of this big man sitting behind a bench – perhaps showing her the discipline combined with affable behaviour that is clearly lacking in her life.
It turns out that her 18-year-old sister has a drug problem. The magistrate really touched all those concerned with his next move. He asked whether the accused had contacted Caritas to enrol in some form of drug rehabilitation scheme. She told him she had tried, but could not get through. “Mgr Victor Grech is a personal friend of mine. You can go and knock on the door and ask for him, and tell him that I, personally, have told you to tell him I have insisted that you do this,” he said.
You see all sorts of behaviour when the accused are in the dock. Usually defiance, remorse or a plain “I don’t care” attitude. Yet, you can always see it in their eyes when a member of the judiciary touches a chord – and that was the case with this girl. You could see the admiration and awe etched on her face – like everyone else, she was touched.
Make no mistake – we are not looking at an indulgent person here – the magistrate was firm with them at all times – but what can be achieved with some tact is amazing.
The next girl looked edgy all the time during the hearing and once a couple of details came out, it was immediately clear why. She had been bullied at school for the last two years and started playing truant to get away from her tormentors. She sat, hands nervously twitching and looking very embarrassed as the probation officer told the court that she had left school without any qualifications.
Magistrate Quintano spoke to her mother and grandmother and urged them to encourage the girl to take up some form of course at MCAST. “The days when children left school for good at 14 or 16 are gone. There are opportunities now. She will not get bullied at MCAST – the most that can happen is that she will meet some nice young man who might take a fancy to her,” he said. He pushed the family to get the girl enrolled in something for their, and her good. “Not everyone can be a lawyer or a doctor in life – but there are opportunities for all. Go out and grasp one, live a good life,” he urged the young girl – again dumbstruck by the magistrate’s words.
He warned the girls that they would not get off the hook easily and told them not to step out of line as he would be watching and listening. Perhaps these girls are young enough to be “saved” by the simple actions of one caring magistrate who has the power to do something, to make a difference in their lives.
Maybe they will not heed his wise words, maybe they will keep their nose clean until they use up their “get out of jail free” card and return to their old ways. Maybe they will not even get that far. Hopefully they will and even if one of them makes it – and I have a feeling the last one I mentioned will – it will be thanks to the actions of one man. It really is enough to make you wonder if we are reaching out to problem children enough.