The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

The Malta Independent Online

Malta Independent Sunday, 3 December 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

A civil court has found against the Director of Contracts in a case instituted by a disgruntled bidder for a Water Service Corporation tender to repair leaking water pipes.

The conditions of the tender had been that the job, to repair 2,000 leaks, would be divided in half; after the first 1,000 repairs were completed, the corporation would send quality controllers to check that the work had been done properly by inspecting a 25 per cent sample of the work done.

Charles Dimech won the tender, but the quality control check done by WSC after the first 1,000 repairs, found that 62 to 64 per cent of the work was faulty, when only a 10 per cent rate should have been considered as acceptable.

However, the Contracts Committee decided to disregard the quality control report and to accept Mr Dimech’s explanation that only eight leak repair jobs were defective. The rest of the defects had to do with the replacement of the trenches dug up in connection with the work. The committee accepted Mr Dimech’s promise of a better performance and was also perhaps swayed by the advice of the Director of Contracts, Joseph V. Spiteri, who was heard to say that “no street in Malta is level”.

Another tenderer, Grezzju Ellul, having first protested to no avail, took the Director of Contracts to court claiming damages. The court, presided over by Mr Justice Tonio Mallia, found that the Contracts Committee had no right to disregard the quality control checks, nor to go beyond the tender document regulations, and deciding that WSC did not have the necessary experience to interpret the tender document constituted “arrogance”. The court annulled the committee’s decision and found that Mr Ellul’s rights had been infringed.

  • don't miss